エピソード

  • I Will Build My Church | The Identity of Christ and the Endurance of His Church
    2026/11/17

    Send us Fan Mail

    Who is Jesus Christ? It is perhaps the most important question anyone can answer. And yet, throughout history, the world has continually offered answers that reflect its own image rather than the truth revealed in Scripture.

    In this week's episode, we're doing something a little different: sharing a sermon on Matthew 16:13–20.

    When Peter confesses that Jesus is the Christ, the Son of the living God, Jesus responds with a remarkable promise: "I will build my church, and the gates of hell shall not prevail against it."

    But what does that promise mean? What is the foundation of the church? What are the keys of the kingdom of heaven? And what assurance does Christ give to His people in the midst of opposition, suffering, and even death?

    In this sermon, we consider:

    • The world's false answers to the question of Christ's identity.
    • Peter's confession of Jesus as the Christ, the Son of the living God.
    • Christ as the foundation upon which His church is built.
    • The promise that the gates of Hades will not prevail against the church.
    • The keys of the kingdom and the biblical purpose of church discipline.

    Though the world remains troubled, Christ is still reigning. He is building His church, guarding His people, and preparing them for the day when He returns.

    Scripture: Matthew 16:13–20

    Thanks for listening to Weighed in the Balance, the show where we examine to see if claims can hold up to scrutiny.

    Support the show

    Do you think this claim is found wanting? Let us know on social!!

    Click here to find us everywhere!!

    続きを読む 一部表示
    27 分
  • Is Cameron Riecker's Biggest Objection Really Insurmountable?
    2026/11/10

    Send us Fan Mail

    Is there an insurmountable obstacle to becoming Protestant? Cameron argues that without an infallible interpreter, Protestants have no reliable way to determine what Scripture actually teaches. If Scripture can be interpreted in different ways, how can we know which interpretation is correct?

    In this episode, I respond to Cameron's objection and turn to one of the great Reformed theologians of the seventeenth century: Francis Turretin.

    In his Institutes of Elenctic Theology, Turretin addresses the doctrine of the perspicuity, or clarity, of Scripture. His argument is not that every passage of Scripture is equally clear, that every theological question can be answered without interpretation, or that Christians never disagree. Rather, he argues that Scripture clearly teaches those things necessary for salvation, without requiring unwritten tradition or the infallible judgment of the Roman Catholic Church.

    We examine:

    • Why Scripture must be interpreted in light of the whole counsel of God.
    • What the Westminster Confession teaches about Scripture interpreting Scripture.
    • Turretin's defense of the perspicuity of Scripture.
    • The distinction between what is necessary for salvation and what is not.
    • Why disagreement among Christians does not disprove the clarity of Scripture.
    • The difference between the fact of the Trinity and the mystery of how the Trinity exists.
    • Whether the Roman Catholic Magisterium actually solves the problem of doctrinal disagreement.
    • The biblical meaning of the keys of the kingdom and church discipline.

    Cameron, I appreciate the more measured approach in your recent discussion. I hope this response can contribute to a genuinely productive conversation.

    The question is not whether Christians disagree. They do. The question is whether Scripture itself provides the authoritative standard by which those disagreements must be judged.

    Does Turretin provide a reasonable answer to Cameron's objection? Is this really an insurmountable obstacle to Protestantism?

    Let me know what you think in the comments.

    Weighed in the Balance is the show where we examine to see if claims can hold up to scrutiny.

    Subscribe for more discussions of Protestant theology, Roman Catholic apologetics, church history, and biblical interpretation.

    Support the show

    Do you think this claim is found wanting? Let us know on social!!

    Click here to find us everywhere!!

    続きを読む 一部表示
    44 分
  • You Don't Need Rome to Find Christian History | Responding to Cameron Riecker
    2026/11/03

    Send us Fan Mail

    Do Protestants need to become Roman Catholic in order to recover the history, unity, and doctrinal stability of the Christian Church?

    Roman Catholic apologist Cameron Riecker argues that Protestantism cannot provide the certainty that people are looking for. Without an infallible teaching authority, how can Christians know which interpretation of Scripture is correct? And what happens when Christians disagree?

    In this episode of Weighed in the Balance, Jonathan Brooks examines Cameron Riecker's arguments and considers whether the Roman Magisterium actually solves the problems it claims to solve.

    We'll consider:

    • Why some Protestants are drawn to Rome in search of a connection to church history.
    • Why recovering the writings of the early Church Fathers doesn't require becoming Roman Catholic.
    • Whether the disagreements among Protestants invalidate Sola Scriptura.
    • Where Jesus directs His disciples to find their stability.
    • Whether the Council of Jerusalem in Acts 15 establishes the authority of the papacy.
    • Why the authority of church councils must remain subordinate to Scripture.
    • Why Christians can disagree about important secondary doctrines without abandoning the Christian faith.

    The central question is this: Where does Scripture direct us to find our confidence?

    Not in an allegedly infallible institution, but in Jesus Christ, the perfect Savior who is able to save to the uttermost those who draw near to God through Him.

    You don't have to give up the gospel to recover Christian history.

    And you don't need Rome to find Jesus.

    If you appreciate thoughtful, historically informed Protestant apologetics, please consider subscribing.

    Weighed in the Balance — the show where we examine to see if claims can hold up to scrutiny.

    Support the show

    Do you think this claim is found wanting? Let us know on social!!

    Click here to find us everywhere!!

    続きを読む 一部表示
    58 分
  • Martin Luther: The Monk Who Changed the World | Reformation Day Special
    2026/10/31

    Send us Fan Mail

    On October 31, 1517, an Augustinian monk named Martin Luther set in motion events that would change the course of Western Christianity.

    But Luther didn't set out to start a new church. He was a deeply troubled monk struggling with his own conscience, desperately seeking peace with God within the medieval Roman Catholic Church.

    What happened between that troubled monk and the Protestant Reformation?

    In this Reformation Day special, we explore the life of Martin Luther, the religious world into which he was born, and the events that led to the Protestant Reformation.

    We'll examine:

    • The state of medieval Christianity and the religious practices that shaped Luther's world.
    • Luther's early life, his thunderstorm experience, and his entrance into monasticism.
    • His struggle with guilt, sin, and the righteousness of God.
    • His experiences in Rome and his growing disillusionment with the institutional church.
    • The indulgence controversy and the publication of the Ninety-Five Theses.
    • The debates at Heidelberg and Leipzig.
    • Luther's confrontation with the Roman Church at Worms.
    • The development of the Lutheran Reformation and the Augsburg Confession.

    Along the way, we'll consider the imperfect man God used to accomplish an extraordinary work.

    Luther was no saint. His later writings against the Jews were reprehensible, and his personal shortcomings were considerable. But the story of the Reformation isn't ultimately a story about the greatness of Martin Luther.

    As Luther himself reportedly put it, when asked how he had accomplished so much, he ate, slept, drank Wittenberg beer, and the Word of God did it all.

    That's the story of the Reformation.

    Weighed in the Balance — the show where we examine to see if claims can hold up to scrutiny.

    Happy Reformation Day!

    Support the show

    Do you think this claim is found wanting? Let us know on social!!

    Click here to find us everywhere!!

    続きを読む 一部表示
    1 時間 29 分
  • Does the PC(USA) Still Teach the Christian Faith? | Everhard vs. Redeemed Zoomer
    2026/10/20

    Send us Fan Mail

    Does the PC(USA) still hold forth the Christian faith? And when a denomination tolerates teaching and practices that contradict Scripture, is separation justified—or is it schism?

    In this episode of Weighed in the Balance, I continue examining the debate between Dr. Matthew Everhard and Redeemed Zoomer over whether the founders of the Presbyterian Church in America were wise to leave the mainline Presbyterian Church in 1973.

    Before evaluating Dr. Everhard's argument, I want to establish the biblical framework by which we should evaluate these questions. What is the Christian faith? What does Scripture teach about sin, salvation, and the righteousness of God? And what does it mean for a church to remain faithful to the gospel?

    Working through Romans 1–3, I consider the universal sinfulness of humanity, our need for Christ's righteousness, and justification by faith alone. From there, I examine several of the issues raised in Dr. Everhard's opening statement:

    • The Lord's Supper: Why does Scripture require the church to take the holiness of God and the discipline of the table seriously?

    • Church discipline and the constitution: What happens when a denomination's constitutional provisions appear to conflict with biblical teaching?

    • Lawsuits over church property: How should we understand Paul's prohibition against believers bringing civil disputes against one another, especially when congregations seek to leave a denomination?

    • Ordination and the deity of Christ: What does it mean when a denomination appears to tolerate the denial of Christ's deity while restricting those who hold a complementarian view of church leadership?

    • The vows we take for our children: Why is the church in which we raise our children a matter of Christian faithfulness, rather than merely an emotional preference?

    Throughout this discussion, I want to be clear: I am not claiming that every congregation or individual within the PC(USA) is outside the Christian faith. I recognize that there are faithful Christians within that denomination, and that leaving can carry profound personal, spiritual, and financial costs.

    The question, however, is whether the denomination's institutional commitments remain faithful to Scripture—and whether those commitments can justify separation.

    What do you think? Do the examples discussed in this episode strike at the vitals of religion? And if a denomination tolerates teaching that contradicts the essentials of the Christian faith, is separation justified?

    Leave your thoughts in the comments.

    Subscribe to Weighed in the Balance, the show where we examine to see if claims can hold up to scrutiny.

    Support the show

    Do you think this claim is found wanting? Let us know on social!!

    Click here to find us everywhere!!

    続きを読む 一部表示
    1 時間 11 分
  • Christian Discourse Has a Problem
    2026/10/13

    Send us Fan Mail

    What happens when the pursuit of Christian unity becomes more important than biblical truth? And can we defend the unity of the visible church while condemning faithful Christians who leave a denomination that has departed from Scripture?

    In this episode of Weighed in the Balance, Jonathan Brooks responds to an online controversy surrounding the Reconquista movement and the claim that the Presbyterian Church (USA) possesses the only legitimate Presbyterian jurisdiction in America. We examine the historical roots of the Associate Reformed Presbyterian Church, the nature of ecclesiastical schism, and the question of whether Christians are obligated to remain in churches that tolerate serious doctrinal error.

    But this episode is about more than Presbyterian polity. It's also about how Christians ought to conduct themselves when discussing serious theological disagreements in public.

    Can we defend the truth without abandoning Christian charity?

    In this episode, we discuss:

    • The controversy surrounding Reconquista and the PC(USA).
    • Whether the PCA and ARP were wrong to separate from their predecessor denominations.
    • The historical origins of the Associate Reformed Presbyterian Church.
    • Whether leaving a church because of heresy is inherently sinful.
    • The relationship between institutional unity, sound doctrine, and biblical faithfulness.
    • Why calling fellow Christians schismatics, morons, or worse does nothing to establish your argument.
    • The biblical call to gentleness, self-control, and gracious speech.

    Christians should take the unity of the church seriously. We should also take doctrinal fidelity seriously. Neither concern gives us permission to abandon the commands of Christ in how we treat those with whom we disagree.

    As we continue this series on schism, our aim is to examine these claims carefully and charitably, weighing them against Scripture and the history of the Reformed tradition.

    Support the show

    Do you think this claim is found wanting? Let us know on social!!

    Click here to find us everywhere!!

    続きを読む 一部表示
    34 分
  • Was the PCA Right to Leave the PCUS? | Schism & the 1973 Split
    2026/10/06

    Send us Fan Mail

    What is schism? When is separation from a church sinful—and when can separation actually be necessary?

    In this episode of Weighed in the Balance, I begin examining the debate between Redeemed Zoomer and Dr. Matthew Everhard over whether it was wise for the founders of the Presbyterian Church in America to leave the Presbyterian Church in the United States and form a new denomination in 1973.

    Before getting into the debate itself, we need to understand why the founders of the PCA said they left. The 1973 Message to All Churches provides an unusually valuable primary source. The founders described themselves as a true branch of the Church of Christ, expressed deep sorrow over their separation from their "spiritual mother," and nevertheless argued that loyalty to Christ required them to separate when the church would no longer maintain biblical purity and exercise proper discipline.

    I examine their arguments concerning:

    • The biblical meaning of schism
    • Christian unity and the visible church
    • When separation from a church may be necessary
    • The three marks of the church
    • The PCA founders' own explanation for the 1973 separation
    • Sola Scriptura and the rise of theological liberalism
    • The failure to exercise church discipline
    • The significance of the Westminster Standards
    • Whether the 1973 PCUS should be evaluated on its own terms rather than primarily by what the PC(USA) became decades later
    • Dr. Matthew Everhard's opening argument in the debate
    • Redeemed Zoomer's argument concerning the historical Presbyterian mainline

    I also argue that an important distinction needs to be made: it is one thing to demonstrate that the PCA is preferable to the PC(USA) today; it is another thing to establish that the founders of the PCA were wise—or biblically justified—in separating in 1973.

    This is only the beginning of the discussion. In future episodes, I intend to continue working through the debate.

    What do you think? Was the 1973 separation justified? Was the language of "discipline in reverse" appropriate? And should the debate focus primarily on the circumstances of the 1960s and 1970s rather than the present-day PC(USA)?

    Support the show

    Do you think this claim is found wanting? Let us know on social!!

    Click here to find us everywhere!!

    続きを読む 一部表示
    49 分
  • Cameron Bertuzzi's Argument Fails
    2026/09/22

    Send us Fan Mail

    Does Irenaeus prove the Roman Catholic papacy?

    In this episode of Weighed in the Balance, we continue examining Cameron Bertuzzi's argument that Protestantism faces an inescapable dilemma when it appeals to early Christian writers such as Irenaeus.

    Irenaeus is an extremely important witness to early Christianity. But does accepting his testimony about the authorship of the Gospels require us to accept everything he says about the church in Rome? And does Irenaeus' reference to the Roman church's "preeminent authority" actually establish the later Roman Catholic doctrine of papal primacy and universal jurisdiction?

    We examine those questions by looking at:

    • Irenaeus' testimony concerning the succession of bishops at Rome
    • The famous passage concerning Rome's "preeminent authority" (potentior principalitas)
    • The Latin transmission of a work originally written in Greek
    • Whether Irenaeus actually teaches papal primacy or universal jurisdiction
    • The distinction between an early bishop of Rome and the later doctrine of the papacy
    • The historical evidence for Luke's authorship of Luke-Acts
    • Cameron Bertuzzi's use of early Christian testimony
    • The argument from the historical reliability of Christian and Islamic sources
    • The dating and transmission of the Gospels compared with later Islamic hadith collections
    • Why historical evidence cannot simply be reduced to "Irenaeus said it, therefore it must be true" or "Irenaeus said it, therefore Rome must be right"

    The goal of Weighed in the Balance is simple: to examine claims carefully and see whether they can hold up to scrutiny.

    If you're Roman Catholic, Protestant, Orthodox, or simply interested in the historical development of Christian doctrine, I'd love to hear your thoughts in the comments.

    Support the show

    Do you think this claim is found wanting? Let us know on social!!

    Click here to find us everywhere!!

    続きを読む 一部表示
    50 分