Frodo and Sam press on toward Mordor — and pick up an unlikely guide. In this episode, Dan and Alex walk through Book IV of The Lord of the Rings (the second half of The Two Towers), tracing Frodo and Sam's journey through the Dead Marshes, their capture of Gollum, the encounter with Faramir in Ithilien, and the road toward Shelob's lair.

Along the way: why Tolkien's refusal to write allegory makes these characters feel more real than any parable; the "fall without hope of spring" and Nietzsche's slave morality; Frodo's true motives for sparing Gollum; Faramir as the moral center of the story (and why the films undersell him); the ethics of lying to an enemy; and Sam's reflection on what it means to be "landed" in a story rather than choosing one.

They also touch on the weight of names (Sam, the Gaffer, and Treebeard), C.S. Lewis's Perelandra and The Great Divorce, and what it looks like to be the loyal second character rather than the hero.

Next episode: Book V of The Lord of the Rings, the first half of The Return of the King.

Got comments, criticism, or corrections? Email or send a voice memo to bookclub@mountainair.media.

Timestamps00:00 — Intro00:03 — Housekeeping: Pippin and the palantír00:04 — Book IV summary00:06 — Themes: why these stories aren't sensational00:14 — Slave morality & "a fall without hope of spring"00:22 — Break / The Theo Show00:23 — The Gaffer's insults & the power of names00:34 — Faramir vs. Boromir00:45 — Break / Telling the Truth00:47 — Faramir continued: honesty and lying to evil00:55 — The fall of Gondor01:00 — Sam on adventure and heroism01:07 — Outro

Boromir is Slain! The orcs capture Merry and Pippin and march in haste to Isengard. Aragorn, Logolas and Gimli attempt a hopeless pursuit on foot, only to find the remains of the orc host slaughtered by the Riders of Rohan, but clues of the hobbits’ escape lead the trio into Fangorn Forest where they reunite with Gandalf, resurrected after his fall in Moria. The four companions go to Edoras where Gandalf releases King Theodin of the bewitchment of Saruman. They ride to Helm’s Deep to aid the Rohirim in the defense against the onslaught of Saruman’s armies, while the Ents march on Isengard. Rohan is successfully defended, and Isengard is overthrown.

Episode Sponsor: Active Listening

*SPOILER ALERT!* If you haven’t seen the movie The Fellowship of the Ring, or read the first chapter of The Two Towers, there is a spoiler in this episode of something in the movie that in the books happens later. Not likely any of you are as fresh to this story as Dan, but still, fyi…

Book 2 Summary: Frodo awakes in Rivendell. A council led by the Elf Lord Elrond decides that the One Ring must be destroyed, and having shown his resilience to the Ring’s evil power, Frodo volunteers to take the Ring to the Mt. Doom where it was forged and the only place where it can be unmade. A fellowship of 9 companions is formed and accompanies Frodo on this quest. Shortly into their journey, the fellowship reluctantly passes through the ancient and deserted Dwarven Mines of Moria where they are besieged by orcs and a Balrog, an ancient demon of Shadow and Flame. In the ensuing battle, Gandalf confronts the Balrog, allowing the rest of the fellowship to escape Moria, but in so doing, falls into the abyss. The remaining fellowship seeks refuge in the Elven realm of Lothlórien. They are welcomed by Lady Galadriel, who bestows gifts and blessings upon them. The journey continues by boat down the River Anduin to the Falls of Rauros, where compelled by treachery, Frodo breaks from the fellowship accompanied only by Sam.

Episode Sponsor: Asking Meaningful Questions

Dan and Alex begin a new adventure in The Lord of the Rings!

Summary of Book 1:

Gandalf the Wizard has discovered that the magic ring the hobbit Frodo Baggins has inherited from his older cousin Bilbo is no ordinary trinket; it's The One Ring of the Dark Lord Sauron. Frodo accepts the task of delivering the ring to Rivendell where wiser and more powerful allies might work out its destruction before it can be reclaimed and Sauron rise again to his former power. Pursued by the Dark Lord’s sinister agents, Frodo and his small band of loyal friends make the dangerous journey, but not without incident or a fair amount of strange help.

But Dan and Alex mostly talk about Tom and Goldberry...as they should.

Next episode will cover The Fellowship, book 2.

Episode Sponsor: Being a Self-regulator

Send emails and voice-memos to bookclub@mtnair.media

Dan and Alex have been on a walking tour through Middle-earth. They followed The Hobbit, Bilbo Baggins, from the doorstep of his hobbit hole, over hill and under tree, to the dungeons of The Lonely Mountain and back again, but a new adventure is calling–and their road continues ever on and on… into The Lord of the Rings!

Our next episode will cover The Lord of the Rings, Book 1, the Fellowship of the Rings (Chapters 1-12).

Music for this episode was used with permission from Clamavi De Profundis. Check them out here:

Patreon

Youtube

Spotify

Episode Sponsor: "Eating The Frog"

The Theo Show

Alex's Middle-earth playlist

Dan and Alex continue their Walking Tour through Middle-earth as they talk about their experience in the second half of J.R.R. Tolkien's The Hobbit.

Send questions, comments, criticisms, and corrections, by written email or Voice Memo to bookclub@mtnair.media

Episode Sponsor: Consequences

Video at: https://youtu.be/u6Y_pV-AsCQ

We begin our walking tour through Middle-earth on the trail to the Lonely Mountain with Bilbo Baggins in J.R.R. Tolkien's The Hobbit. In this episode, we discuss our experiences in the first 9 chapters, from Bag End to Mirkwood.

Episode Sponsor: Doing Something New

https://open.spotify.com/show/3eT6KpkOcJOO3Ss4Zz1lHe?si=e94a0ffcc5be4e8b

Like Elwin Ransom, we're going on a walking tour, or like Bilbo Baggins, we're going on an adventure! Maybe not literally, but imaginatively as we briefly leave the works of C.S. Lewis and wander into Middle-earth. Our first stop will be The Hobbit. Read ahead if you don't want spoilers.

Next Episode: The Hobbit, chapters 1-9