Jeevs Mahil decides which coaches get put in front of Octopus Ventures' portfolio founders, and after years of those introductions she has a clear, slightly uncomfortable view on why so many founders pick the wrong one.

James and Jeevs get into why "ex-founder" tells you almost nothing useful about whether someone can actually coach you, the one question to ask before your first session that most founders skip entirely, and the real ROI behind getting this call right versus wrong. Get this one wrong and it costs a lot more than the coaching fee.

More from James:

Connect with James on LinkedIn or at peer-effect.com

A founder writes in feeling off track and wants to know if the problem is his plan or his execution. James Johnson and Freddie Birley don't let him off with "it's both."

They walk through how to tell which one is actually broken, why most "plans" fail the moment someone asks how often you're checking against them, and why the instinct that got you through Seed can be the exact thing working against you at Series A. Stick around for the rocks-and-sand analogy, which might explain more about your last quarter than you'd like.

More from James:

Connect with James on LinkedIn or at peer-effect.com

Three exits in, Alex Fenton knows exactly what buyers look for, and it's not what most founders think. James and Alex talk through keeping every door open, why a three year plan beats a five year one, and the blunt piece of feedback from a manager that changed how Alex leads. Including the real difference between planting seeds and planting saplings when you're building a team built to last.

More from James:

Connect with James on LinkedIn or at peer-effect.com

James and Freddie tackle a question most founders won't say out loud: feeling insecure or competitive with your co-founder. They get into what's actually driving it, the conversation that fixes it faster than any amount of self-reflection, and the point where the answer isn't a better conversation, it's a different partnership. Including the feedback ratio behind every high performing team and relationship that lasts.

More from James:

Connect with James on LinkedIn or at peer-effect.com

Antoine Pouppez co-founded neuroClues six years ago. Today it's raised over £25M and employs 40+ people across Belgium and France, building MedTech that treats neurological disorders through eye tracking.

His approach from day one: if it's core to the product, you build it yourself, no matter how much longer or more expensive that is. James and Antoine get into why that decision holds up outside MedTech too, how he kept investors on side through a year long delay, and the one question that decides what's worth doing properly versus what can wait.

More from James:

Connect with James on LinkedIn or at peer-effect.com

A founder writes in asking why their team won't move faster. James Johnson and Freddie Birley take the question apart, and the real answer has almost nothing to do with the team.

They get into what actually causes execution to stall at Series A, the trap of being responsive instead of intentional, and why giving up control feels comforting right up until it costs you your business. Practical, direct, and probably not the answer you were expecting.

More from James:

Connect with James on LinkedIn or at peer-effect.com

Ryan Saridar runs Elryan.com, one of the largest e-commerce marketplaces in Iraq, and he's built a rule that changes how his entire management team handles bad news. Nobody on his team gets to sit on a problem and hope it resolves itself.

Ryan breaks down the exact line he uses to separate a genuine excuse from a simple update, why he hires for behavioural fit before skill, and what changed the moment he stopped trying to control outcomes and started building a team that tells him the truth first. If your management team only flags problems once it's too late to fix them, this is the one to send them.

More from James:

Connect with James on LinkedIn or at peer-effect.com

James Johnson and Freddie Birley answer a listener question on how to actually get value from coaching, not the version you perform for LinkedIn, the version where you say the thing you have been avoiding saying out loud.

They cover the line between reflection and procrastination, why a pattern of last-minute rescheduling is rarely just about being busy, and why watching what someone does with their time tells you more than what they say they care about. Founders who are coached, or considering it, will hear something they recognise.

More from James:

Connect with James on LinkedIn or at peer-effect.com