Find your place in the world. Dig in, and take responsibility from there.

-Gary Snyder

When the world faces existential threats like climate change, how do we make ethical choices that matter? In this thought-provoking episode, host Tom Schueneman explores philosopher Thomas Rieder's groundbreaking book "Catastrophe Ethics: How to Choose Well in a World of Tough Choices."

Opening with a powerful scene from Netflix's "Landman," this episode confronts the fundamental ethical dilemma of our time: we're deeply embedded in harmful systems we can't easily escape. As Billy Bob Thornton's character bluntly states, fossil fuels run the world—until they don't. Stop them now, and civilization grinds to a halt.

Travis Rieder's book, "Catastrophe Ethics," presents a compelling framework for navigating our moral responsibilities in the face of existential threats, such as climate change. At the heart of the discussion lies the pressing question of how individuals can act ethically in the face of overwhelming challenges that often render personal efforts seemingly insignificant.

While individual actions may seem insignificant in addressing catastrophic threats, Rieder argues that collective action—the organization and alignment of many individual acts—creates meaningful change. Instead of succumbing to cynicism or denial, we need new moral tools for reasoning through unfamiliar ethical challenges.

In this episode, I explore Rieder's insights, which encourage us to shift from a duty-bound sense of obligation to a more authentic, value-centered approach to our actions. By embracing ongoing reflection and adaptation, we can cultivate a more meaningful connection to our choices, even when the stakes feel impossibly high. Ultimately, the episode invites us to find our place in this complex world and take responsibility—no matter how small—because every action counts in the collective fight against climate change and other global crises.

Rieder's investigation of climate change action within 'Catastrophe Ethics' reveals a profound and often frustrating reality: the ethical choices we face are frequently clouded by a sense of impotence against the larger backdrop of global crises. As we navigate through the complexities of individual agency versus collective action, we find ourselves grappling with the paradox that while our personal contributions may seem negligible, they are nonetheless crucial to the broader movement toward change.

Rieder's call for a new ethical framework—one that prioritizes authentic values over rigid duties—invites us to rethink our approach to environmental stewardship. We reflect on how to cultivate a mindset that embraces adaptability and reflection in our daily choices, rather than succumbing to a sense of futility.

By acknowledging the noise and distraction of modern life, Rieder encourages us to sift through the chaos and find actionable paths forward, all while sharing a few witty anecdotes about our attempts to navigate this moral labyrinth without losing our collective sanity.

The Puzzle of Individual Action

- Why individual actions feel meaningless against collective threats

- The disconnect between moral imperatives and personal impact

- How 8 billion people acting independently create informs "The Puzzle"

Beyond Traditional Ethics

- Why ancient moral frameworks struggle with modern polycrisis challenges

- The limitations of duty-based ethics in addressing climate change

- Moving from obligation to authentic, value-centered action

The Statistical Insignificance Paradox

- Individual carbon...

It's 3:00 AM. All is quiet, the world is asleep.

But is it?

In this illuminating episode, we journey into the darkness to explore the vibrant and often overlooked world of nocturnal creatures, guided by the passionate insights of naturalist Charles Hood. His book, Nature at Night, serves as our compass, leading us through a landscape where life thrives under the stars.

Hood paints a vivid picture of the night as a time of transformation and activity, challenging the commonplace notion that all is quiet when darkness descends. Instead, he reveals a dynamic ecosystem full of sounds, movements, and interactions that awaken our sense of wonder.

From his unexpected path through academia to his extensive travels documenting wildlife in remote corners of the globe, Hood's extensive experiences as a naturalist and writer inspire us to appreciate even the most overlooked aspects of our environment, from the familiar raccoons in our backyards to the mesmerizing vertical migrations of oceanic creatures.

Hood maintains an optimistic outlook, reminding us that nature will persist, adapt, and thrive, regardless of the challenges it faces. His insights serve as a call to action for all of us to cultivate curiosity and appreciation for the natural world, urging listeners to step outside, explore, and connect with the life that surrounds us, especially in the magical hours of the night.

• Nature at Night: Discover the World That Comes Alive After Dark, From Timber Press
• A Salad Only the Devil Would Eat: The Joys of Ugly Nature, From Heyday Books
• Double Hyenas and Lazarus Birds: A Sideways Look at the Pacific Ocean and Everything in It, From Heyday Books
• More books by Charles Hood

• Nature is a dynamic cycle, thriving at night when the human world is asleep, highlighting the unseen beauty that flourishes in darkness.
• Charles Hood's exploration of nocturnal life encourages us to appreciate the often overlooked aspects of nature that exist right outside our doors.
• The concept of ugly nature, as expressed by Hood, challenges our perceptions and invites us to find beauty in the mundane and forgotten places.
• Understanding the vertical migration of ocean creatures reveals a complex, interconnected web of life that continues to inspire curiosity and fascination among nature lovers.
• Hood's journey through his unconventional educational path illustrates that persistence and a willingness to embrace the unexpected can lead to incredible experiences in life and nature.
• The podcast emphasizes the importance of supporting local bookstores, as they play a crucial role in keeping our literary culture vibrant and accessible.

• timberpress.com
• heydaybooks.com
• Monterey Bay...

Protests and social movements are often seen as spontaneous eruptions of public sentiment. What drives people to take to the streets? What motivates them to take their anger and frustration offline, out in the open?

In this insightful conversation with sociologist Dana Fisher, we explore the motivations behind collective action, especially in today's political climate of rising authoritarianism under the Trump administration.

Dr. Fisher, a leading voice in climate sociology, examines how various social issues intersect, particularly how the current political environment has galvanized protests surrounding climate change, civil rights, and the decimation of federal services.

Fisher's extensive fieldwork provides a nuanced understanding of how communities respond to crises. Her books and articles provide a roadmap for how individuals can contribute to meaningful change from the ground up, within their communities. She argues it is up to us, not outside forces, to shape our desired future. But we have to participate. "There are no free riders."

Fisher shares her latest research and insights into the motivations of protesters, drawing parallels between the current resistance movements and historical precedents. Climate change, she argues, is not just a standalone issue but is intertwined with broader struggles for justice and equality.

Social movements can coalesce around shared grievances, revealing that while climate may not always be the primary motivation for protestors, it is nevertheless a significant part of a larger narrative of resistance. As Fisher articulates, understanding these connections is crucial for fostering solidarity among diverse activist groups, and she encourages listeners to engage deeply with their communities to effect change.

Books by Dana Fisher

• Buy Saving Ourselves at this link and get 20% off with the code #COP20.
• Use the same code for 20% off on American Resistance

TED Talk

• How to Be an Apocalyptic Optimist

How do we find our footing and protect our peace of mind in a world that often feels overwhelming, where fear and uncertainty seem to be the new normal?

In this deeply personal and reflective episode, host Tom Schueneman opens up about his own “days of fear and loathing,” sharing his journey through a period of profound depression. He bravely navigates the distinction between everyday “blues” and the isolating grip of clinical depression, offering not prescriptive advice, but a heartfelt account of what helped him find a glimmer of hope and a path back to himself.

If you’ve ever felt the weight of the world or the quiet whisper that nothing matters, this episode is a comforting hand that reminds you that you’re not alone and that healing is possible.

Navigating Today’s “Challenging Times”: A candid look at the societal pressures – from climate change to political upheaval – that can impact our mental well-being.

The Blues vs. Depression: Understanding the critical difference between life’s natural melancholies and the debilitating, one-dimensional experience of clinical depression.

Breaking the Stigma: Addressing the societal hurdles, especially for men, in acknowledging and seeking help for mental health struggles.

A Personal Descent: Tom shares his raw experience with depression in 2014, describing it as a “black hole” and a form of “psychological or emotional suicide,” echoing Camus.

The Turning Point – Nature’s Embrace: An impactful moment of finding solace during a simple walk in San Francisco’s Aquatic Park, where “anxiety’s knife-edge eased.”

The Power of Green Space: How daily contact with nature became a crucial, self-prescribed balm, more potent than any pill.

Opening Up to Therapy: The journey of starting cognitive behavioral and talk therapy, the vulnerability it requires, and the profound connection that can foster healing.

Finding Hope and Moving Forward: Tom’s path to recovery and the lasting practices, like daily walks, help him maintain his mental well-being.

A Call for Self-Compassion and Courage: An inspiring message to nurture our mental health, find courage amidst fear, and approach the world with compassion.

Tom Schueneman: With a thoughtful and introspective voice behind the microphone, Tom openly shares his personal experiences to connect with listeners on a human level. In this episode, he steps into the role of a fellow traveler, offering his story as a beacon of understanding and hope in navigating mental health.

Suicide and Crisis Hotline: Text of Call 988

National Alliance on Mental Illness (NAMI) HelpLine: 1-800-950-NAMI (6264), Mon–Fri, 10 a.m.–10 p.m. ET

• “The Myth of Sisyphus” by Albert Camus: Referenced in describing the philosophical weight of depression.
• John Muir: His

Green amendments are emerging as an effective and essential tool in the quest for environmental justice, ensuring that citizens have the constitutional right to a healthy environment, which is intricately linked to their rights to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness.

In our conversation with Maya Van Rossem, the founder of Green Amendments for the Generations, we discuss how these amendments provide the necessary legal framework to protect our natural resources from industrial harm and pollution, safeguarding both current and future generations.

With 19 states already taking steps towards drafting such amendments, we explore the tangible benefits experienced by states like Montana, New York, and Pennsylvania, where citizens enjoy cleaner air, water, and healthier communities. The discussion also highlights the ongoing challenges, including opposition from industries that benefit from environmental degradation, and how grassroots movements can effectively overcome these hurdles.

Exploring the strategic roadmap for achieving widespread adoption of Green Amendments across the United States, Van Rossem outlines the tactical approach of building momentum at the state level before advancing towards a federal amendment.

The movement aims to create a robust foundation for a national constitutional amendment that acknowledges and protects environmental rights by fostering awareness and support within individual states. We explore the diverse pathways through which citizens can advocate for Green Amendments, from legislative proposals to citizen initiatives, emphasizing the importance of grassroots involvement.

Join us as we unpack the bold vision behind the Green Amendment movement and its potential to transform environmental rights into enforceable legal standards nationwide.

• The concept of Green Amendments emphasizes the need for constitutional rights to a healthy environment alongside life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness.
• As of now, 19 states have proposed Green Amendment initiatives, with notable successes in Montana, New York, and Pennsylvania.
• Green Amendments empower citizens to challenge environmental harm and demand accountability from government officials and corporations alike.
• The recent Held v. Montana case showcases the power of Green Amendments in protecting environmental rights against legislative negligence.
• Green Amendments are not just about current generations; they also ensure the protection of natural resources for future generations.
• Advocacy for Green Amendments is a grassroots movement, urging individuals to take action in states lacking such protections.

Links referenced in this episode:

• globalwarmingisreal.com
• cagreenamendment.org
• greenamendment.org

Reviewing A City on Mars by Kelly and Zach Weinersmith

The notion of colonizing Mars often sounds like a thrilling adventure, but let’s hit the brakes on that rocket ship for a moment. Right off the bat, we tackle the idea that Elon Musk’s vision of a bustling Martian colony is, to put it mildly, a touch delusional.

As we delve into the complexities of what it would actually mean to settle on another planet, we confront the sobering reality that space isn't just a hop, skip, and jump away; it’s a harsh environment where every human function must be rethought.

We explore whether escaping a troubled Earth is viable or if our human flaws will simply accompany us to the red planet. Ultimately, our discussion highlights the pressing need to learn how to live sustainably and peacefully here on Earth, our true home, before we think about packing our bags for Mars.

Takeaways:

• Colonizing Mars is not just a technical challenge but a profound philosophical question.
• Elon Musk's timeline for colonization seems overly optimistic given the myriad obstacles ahead.
• Humans tend to carry their societal issues with them, questioning the idea of a utopian colony.
• To escape Earth’s problems by colonizing Mars is a flawed perspective; the challenges remain the same.
• Living sustainably on Earth should be our priority; if we can't manage here, why would it be better elsewhere?
• Space exploration is essential, but we must first learn to thrive on our home planet.

Links referenced in this episode:

• globalwarmingisreal.com
• Kelly Weinersmith
• Zach Weinersmith

Global warming is a long history spent in the hall of ironies, a statement that resonates throughout our discussion today. We delve into the fascinating yet troubling journey of climate science, tracing back to Svante Arrhenius, who first calculated the impact of accumulating greenhouse gases over a century ago, to the alarming forecasts of the 1950s that continue to haunt us. Amidst this, we uncover the unsettling tactics of climate denial, echoing the tobacco industry's playbook, where for-hire scientists sowed doubt to stall progress.

Lipsky shares his extraordinarily well-researched insights on how this narrative unfolded, revealing how the merchants of doubt have clouded our collective response to an existential crisis. Join us as we explore the paradoxes of our climate reality, where the awareness of impending crisis often clashes with a lack of decisive action, leaving us to wonder: How did we end up here?

This episode is a witty and thought-provoking discussion revealing the intricate relationship between science, politics, and public perception.

Takeaways:

• Svante Arrhenius's early calculations of greenhouse gases highlight a century-long understanding of climate science.
• The irony of climate denial mirrors the tobacco industry's playbook, using misinformation to sway public opinion.
• David Lipski's 'The Parrot and the Igloo' reveals the long history of climate change awareness and its frustrating denial.
• Our discussions on global warming reflect a tragicomedy, emphasizing the urgent necessity for action in a delayed response.
• The historical context of climate science illustrates how public understanding has evolved yet remained stagnant in action.
• Despite awareness since the 1950s, global warming remains contentious, showcasing our collective failure to act decisively.

About David Lipsky

Visit GlobalWarmingisReal

Roy Scranton's Learning to Die in the Anthropocene: Reflections on the End of a Civilization invites us to confront a sobering truth: we cannot escape our fate. As we grapple with the challenges of our time, Scranton emphasizes the importance of facing our future with patience, reflection, and love rather than panic or denial.

His reflections draw from a life steeped in experience, including his service in Iraq, where he learned that truly living often requires us to embrace the reality of mortality. This episode explores Scranton's compelling narrative, where a dark optimism emerges, suggesting that there lies a path forward even in the face of seemingly insurmountable challenges. Together, we will unpack how letting go of illusions can lead us to survive and potentially thrive, even when the odds appear stacked against us.

Join me as we navigate this philosophical terrain, offering a glimpse of hope amidst the chaos and a reminder that our engagement is paramount in this make-or-break decade.

Takeaways:

• In confronting our climate crisis, we must embrace a dark optimism that fuels our actions.
• Learning to let go of our illusions is essential to truly engaging with reality.
• As we navigate this perilous decade, our relationship with nature must be reconciled for survival.
• Scranton's reflections illustrate the importance of patience and love in facing our daunting challenges.
• While the odds of survival seem slim, our collective efforts can still make a meaningful difference.
• Engagement in climate action is crucial; every effort counts in the face of adversity.

#ClimateChange #BookReview #RoyScranton #anthropocene