Send us Fan Mail

⚠️ SPOILER & CONTENT WARNING: This episode contains major plot spoilers for Chapters 1 through 13 of The Butcher Legacy by Alaina Urquhart. Discussion includes themes of serial crime, abduction, and psychological horror. Listener discretion is advised.

"He may be locked in a cage, but his shadow still walks the streets."

Welcome back to the Cozy Midnight Collective! Tonight, we open the case files on Alaina Urquhart’s highly anticipated trilogy finale, The Butcher Legacy.

Two months after surviving the Berkshires, Dr. Wren Muller returns to the New Orleans morgue seeking normalcy. But as Halloween nears, young women begin vanishing without a trace. Hundreds of miles away, Pastor Philip Trudeau struggles to mask his own violent compulsions behind the church pulpit—and Wren must come face-to-face with a caged Jeremy Rose to stop a nightmare that refuses to die.

Episode Breakdown:

• 00:00:28 – Intro & Content Warnings
• 00:01:43 – The Midnight Draw (Tarot Ritual)
• 00:08:41 – The Werewolf in Sheep’s Clothing
• 00:19:10 – Wren’s New Normal
• 00:23:59 – The Cabin in the Woods
• 00:31:27 – The Real Philip Trudeau
• 00:39:34 – New Victims and the Resurrection House
• 00:47:38 – Confronting the Monster in the Cage
• 00:50:37 – A Grotesque Haunt
• 00:55:34 – Jeremy’s Mind Games
• 01:02:57 – Dr. Gabriel Price
• 01:11:04 – Until Next Time

Support the show

SUPPORT THE SHOW

Help us stay independent and ad-free by supporting the show directly at Buzzsprout Support Link.

BECOME A MEMBER

Want to hear the conclusion of the Purple Satin Killer? Join our Patreon for exclusive tiers, BONUS "Story Time" episodes, & a shout-out on the show - Patreon Link.

SEND US YOUR CONFESSIONS

We are currently accepting anonymous stories! Our Midnight Confessions Form is linked in our Instagram and TikTok bios, here or email us at Cozy.Midnight.Collective@gmail.com. Your identity is always protected.

Special Thanks to our Patreon Subscribers!

_______________________________________________________________________________________________

Produced + Edited + Mixed by | Morgan Davis & Lauryn Strickland

Artwork Designed by | Morgan Davis & Lauryn Strickland

Music by | Morgan Davis

_______________________________________________________________________________________________

LINKS

• Support us on ...

⚠️ SPOILER & CONTENT WARNING: This episode features a full, end-to-end case investigation of Hunt A Killer x MORBID: The Salem Slicer. Contains full game solutions, puzzle decoding, and discussion of cold case serial murders.

"Some family secrets belong in the dark... but tonight, we're opening the box."

Welcome to the debut of our brand-new late-night segment: Midnight Graveyard Gaming!

Tonight, Morgan and Lauryn take a seat at the detective desk to investigate Hunt A Killer x Morbid: The Salem Slicer. When young lawyer Abigail Fencer finds a mysterious lockbox in her father’s attic, decades of buried Salem terror resurface. Join us as we dissect police dossiers, analyze vintage news clippings, decode cryptic letters, and listen closely to exclusive case audio from Ash and Alaina to unmask the real Salem Slicer.

Investigation File Markers:

• 00:00:16 – Welcome to Midnight Graveyard Gaming
• 00:01:53 – The Midnight Draw
• 00:06:12 – Unboxing The Salem Slicer
• 00:17:38 – The Articles
• 00:30:14 – The Lockbox
• 00:36:43 – The Suspects
• 00:50:51 – Summary Reports & Interviews
• 01:19:02 – Flannery Richmond
• 01:23:57 – The Fiber Samples
• 01:30:40 – Narrowing it Down
• 01:33:21 – Morbid Transcript
• 01:50:04 – Final Answer
• 01:52:22 – Thanks For Playing With Us

Send me your positive energy + good vibes; some Dr. Pepper; some free-time??? I'm so thankful you are even considering sending me something. I can't wait to hear your stories & continue having my mind blown away by the wild, spooky world we live in! Thanks for the Fan Mail :)

Support the show

SUPPORT THE SHOW

Help us stay independent and ad-free by supporting the show directly at Buzzsprout Support Link.

BECOME A MEMBER

Want to hear the conclusion of the Purple Satin Killer? Join our Patreon for exclusive tiers, BONUS "Story Time" episodes, & a shout-out on the show - Patreon Link.

SEND US YOUR CONFESSIONS

We are currently accepting anonymous stories! Our Midnight Confessions Form is linked in our Instagram and TikTok bios, here or email us at Cozy.Midnight.Collective@gmail.com. Your identity is always protected.

Special Thanks to our Patreon Subscribers!

_______________________________________________________________________________________________

Produced + Edited + Mixed by | Morgan Davis & Lauryn Strickland

Artwork Designed by | Morgan Davis & Lauryn Strickland

Music by | Morgan Davis

_______________________________________________________________________________________________

LINKS

• Support us on ...

Send us Fan Mail

⚠️ SPOILER & CONTENT WARNING: This episode contains complete plot spoilers and the ending breakdown for Chapters 18 through the end of The Butcher Game. Discussion includes graphic thriller violence, pursuit, and trauma. Listener discretion is advised.

"The game is over... but the legacy has only begun."

Welcome back to the Cozy Midnight Collective! Tonight, we conclude our deep dive of Alaina Urquhart’s The Butcher Game.

We deconstruct the heart-pounding pursuit through the Berkshire pines, Wren’s intense final clash with Jeremy Rose, and the unresolved secrets left behind in the ashes. Plus, we share our official star ratings, preview what's in store for book three (The Butcher Legacy), and announce our brand-new show segment: Midnight Graveyard Gaming!

Timestamps:

• 00:00:28 – Intro & Finale Content Warnings
• 00:01:47 – The Midnight Draw (Tarot Ritual)
• 00:05:54 – Charlie’s Fate
• 00:11:54 – Old Friends
• 00:18:12 – July 6, 2002
• 00:30:57 – The Breadcrumbs
• 00:38:23 – Reluctant Teammates
• 00:55:13 – The Final Clash & Aftermath
• 01:07:53 – Far From Over
• 01:11:50 – The Collective’s Rating
• 01:14:55 – Goodbye

Support the show

SUPPORT THE SHOW

Help us stay independent and ad-free by supporting the show directly at Buzzsprout Support Link.

BECOME A MEMBER

Want to hear the conclusion of the Purple Satin Killer? Join our Patreon for exclusive tiers, BONUS "Story Time" episodes, & a shout-out on the show - Patreon Link.

SEND US YOUR CONFESSIONS

We are currently accepting anonymous stories! Our Midnight Confessions Form is linked in our Instagram and TikTok bios, here or email us at Cozy.Midnight.Collective@gmail.com. Your identity is always protected.

Special Thanks to our Patreon Subscribers!

_______________________________________________________________________________________________

Produced + Edited + Mixed by | Morgan Davis & Lauryn Strickland

Artwork Designed by | Morgan Davis & Lauryn Strickland

Music by | Morgan Davis

_______________________________________________________________________________________________

LINKS

• Support us on ...

Send us Fan Mail

⚠️ SPOILER & CONTENT WARNING: This episode contains full plot spoilers for Chapters 1 through 17 of The Butcher Game. Discussion includes graphic themes of serial violence, stalking, and trauma. Please listen with care.

"He didn't escape to hide... he escaped to hunt."

Welcome back to the Cozy Midnight Collective! Tonight, we launch into The Bayou Butcher Strikes Again! | The Butcher Game Part 1 (Chapters 1–17).

We trade the humid New Orleans marshlands for small-town Massachusetts as Jeremy Rose resurfaces with a brand-new trail of blood. We dissect Wren’s lingering trauma, Jeremy's dark leverage over a local pastor, and the mounting tension as the killer closes in on Wren's rental cottage.

Timestamps:

• 00:00:32 – Intro & Content Warnings
• 00:02:16 – The Midnight Draw (Tarot Ritual)
• 00:12:47 – Philip Trudeau
• 00:16:53 – Catching Up With Jeremy
• 00:31:00 – Wren’s Trauma and Forced Leave
• 00:43:41 – Baiting the Hook
• 00:57:58 – Called to Salem
• 01:05:18 – Spontaneous Seduction
• 01:17:30 – The Collective’s Predictions
• 01:19:51 – Goodbye

Support the show

SUPPORT THE SHOW

Help us stay independent and ad-free by supporting the show directly at Buzzsprout Support Link.

BECOME A MEMBER

Want to hear the conclusion of the Purple Satin Killer? Join our Patreon for exclusive tiers, BONUS "Story Time" episodes, & a shout-out on the show - Patreon Link.

SEND US YOUR CONFESSIONS

We are currently accepting anonymous stories! Our Midnight Confessions Form is linked in our Instagram and TikTok bios, here or email us at Cozy.Midnight.Collective@gmail.com. Your identity is always protected.

Special Thanks to our Patreon Subscribers!

_______________________________________________________________________________________________

Produced + Edited + Mixed by | Morgan Davis & Lauryn Strickland

Artwork Designed by | Morgan Davis & Lauryn Strickland

Music by | Morgan Davis

_______________________________________________________________________________________________

LINKS

• Support us on ...

Send us Fan Mail

⚠️ CONTENT & SPOILER WARNING: This episode contains plot breakdowns and spoilers for our entire July film watchlist. Discussion includes graphic horror, survival violence, and psychological thrillers. Listener discretion is advised.

"The projector is warm, the popcorn is buttery, and the screening room doors are locked..."

Welcome back to the Cozy Midnight Collective! Tonight, we open the vault for Midnight Cinema Society Volume 3: The Ultimate July Horror & Thriller Watchlist Breakdown.

We break down the dark, consuming fixation in Obsession, the mental exhaustion of Stephen King’s The Long Walk, the artistic melodrama of Mother Mary, the bloody 80s slasher camp of AHS: 1984, the graphic frontier terror of Bone Tomahawk, plus Unhinged, Beast of War, and The Odyssey. Grab your soda, dim the lights, and let's roll the tape.

Timestamps:

• 00:00:15 – Spoiler + Content Warning + Intro
• 00:01:25 – Relentless Dystopia + Psychological Dread
  • 00:01:32 – Movie: Obsession
  • 00:12:14 – Movie: Long Walk
• 00:17:19 – Dark Melodrama + Slasher Camp
  • 00:17:24 - Movie: Mother Mary
  • 00:24:00 - Movie: AHS
• 00:32:32 – Interactive Chaos + Creature Features
  • 00:32:38 - Movie: Beast of War
  • 00:44:34 - Movie: Unhinged
• 00:47:25 – Savage Frontiers + Mythic Nightmares
  • 00:47:28 - Movie: The Odyssey
  • 00:54:59 - Movie: Bone Tomahawk
• 01:04:29 – That’s A Wrap!

Support the show

SUPPORT THE SHOW

Help us stay independent and ad-free by supporting the show directly at Buzzsprout Support Link.

BECOME A MEMBER

Want to hear the conclusion of the Purple Satin Killer? Join our Patreon for exclusive tiers, BONUS "Story Time" episodes, & a shout-out on the show - Patreon Link.

SEND US YOUR CONFESSIONS

We are currently accepting anonymous stories! Our Midnight Confessions Form is linked in our Instagram and TikTok bios, here or email us at Cozy.Midnight.Collective@gmail.com. Your identity is always protected.

Special Thanks to our Patreon Subscribers!

_______________________________________________________________________________________________

Produced + Edited + Mixed by | Morgan Davis & Lauryn Strickland

Artwork Designed by | Morgan Davis & Lauryn Strickland

Music by | Morgan Davis

_______________________________________________________________________________________________

LINKS

• Support us on ...

Send us Fan Mail

⚠️ SPOILER & CONTENT WARNING: This episode contains full spoilers for the second half and finale of The Butcher and the Wren. Discussion includes graphic themes of serial murder, captivity, forensic pathology, and violence. Please listen with care.

"The game isn't over... it's only just begun."

Welcome back to the Cozy Midnight Collective! Tonight, we bring our two-part deep dive into Alaina Urquhart's The Butcher and the Wren to a chaotic, heart-pounding close.

We break down how Wren’s past collides with the Bayou Butcher, the psychological mind games leading into the swampy climax, that jaw-dropping cliffhanger ending, and our final star ratings for the book. Stick around after the review for our August Book of the Month announcement (The Butcher Game!), a teaser for Midnight Cinema Society Vol. 3, and details on how to send in your favorite conspiracy theories for our next Midnight Confessions!

Timestamps:

• 00:00:36 – Intro & Content Warnings
• 00:01:36 – The Midnight Draw (Tarot Ritual)
• 00:16:47 – The Unraveling Connection
• 00:33:13 – Jeremy Loses Control
• 00:41:44 – Uninvited Houseguest
• 00:49:18 – Hunting the Bayou Butcher
• 00:56:56 – The Climactic Finish
• 01:03:26 – The Collective’s Rating
• 01:08:41 – The End

Support the show

SUPPORT THE SHOW

Help us stay independent and ad-free by supporting the show directly at Buzzsprout Support Link.

BECOME A MEMBER

Want to hear the conclusion of the Purple Satin Killer? Join our Patreon for exclusive tiers, BONUS "Story Time" episodes, & a shout-out on the show - Patreon Link.

SEND US YOUR CONFESSIONS

We are currently accepting anonymous stories! Our Midnight Confessions Form is linked in our Instagram and TikTok bios, here or email us at Cozy.Midnight.Collective@gmail.com. Your identity is always protected.

Special Thanks to our Patreon Subscribers!

_______________________________________________________________________________________________

Produced + Edited + Mixed by | Morgan Davis & Lauryn Strickland

Artwork Designed by | Morgan Davis & Lauryn Strickland

Music by | Morgan Davis

_______________________________________________________________________________________________

LINKS

• Support us on ...

Send us Fan Mail

⚠️ SPOILER & CONTENT WARNING: This episode contains full spoilers for Part 1 of The Butcher and the Wren. Discussion includes graphic themes of serial murder, medical/forensic dissection, and physical captivity. Reader and listener discretion is advised.

"He leaves his calling card in the clay of the delta..."

Welcome back to the Cozy Midnight Collective. This July, we are venturing deep into the heavy, humid heat of the Louisiana low country to launch our two-part deep dive into Alaina Urquhart's The Butcher and the Wren.

In this episode, we open the file on the clinical, visceral chess match playing out across New Orleans. We break down Dr. Wren Miller’s brilliant instincts in the autopsy bay, the chillingly calculated methodology of the Bayou Butcher, and how the swamp acts as a character of its own.

Timestamps:

• 00:00:25 – Intro & Content Warnings
• 00:01:42 – The Midnight Draw (Tarot Ritual)
• 00:05:06 – The Bayou Butcher: Introducing Jeremy Rose
• 00:31:02 – Dr. Wren Muller
• 00:42:11 – A Deranged Puzzle
• 00:45:57 – The Heart- Stopping Hunt
• 01:07:18 – The Music Festival
• 01:22:13 – Wren’s Revelation
• 01:31:11 – Until Next Time

Support the show

SUPPORT THE SHOW

Help us stay independent and ad-free by supporting the show directly at Buzzsprout Support Link.

BECOME A MEMBER

Want to hear the conclusion of the Purple Satin Killer? Join our Patreon for exclusive tiers, BONUS "Story Time" episodes, & a shout-out on the show - Patreon Link.

SEND US YOUR CONFESSIONS

We are currently accepting anonymous stories! Our Midnight Confessions Form is linked in our Instagram and TikTok bios, here or email us at Cozy.Midnight.Collective@gmail.com. Your identity is always protected.

Special Thanks to our Patreon Subscribers!

_______________________________________________________________________________________________

Produced + Edited + Mixed by | Morgan Davis & Lauryn Strickland

Artwork Designed by | Morgan Davis & Lauryn Strickland

Music by | Morgan Davis

_______________________________________________________________________________________________

LINKS

• Support us on ...

Send us Fan Mail

⚠️ CONTENT & SPOILER WARNING: This episode contains full plot spoilers for P. Djèlí Clark’s Ring Shout. Our discussion includes themes of systemic racism, hate groups, historical violence, and body horror. Please listen with care.

"There are things born of hatred that hunger for the world."

Welcome back to the Cozy Midnight Collective. Tonight, we open a heavy, high-action historical dark fantasy file: Ring Shout by P. Djèlí Clark.

Set against the backdrop of 1915 Georgia, we dive deep into a world where a cinematic premiere unleashes a cosmic, reality-warping evil. We break down the beautiful, rhythmic ancestral magic of the Ring Shout, the visceral body horror of the multi-eyed "Ku Kluxes," and the unforgettable bond between Maryse, Sadie, and Chef.

Timestamps:

• 00:00:29 – Welcome Back & Spoilers Ahead
• 00:01:47 – The Midnight Draw (Tarot Ritual)
• 00:02:00 – Lauryn’s Cards
• 00:04:25 – Morgan’s Cards
• 00:06:05 – Novella Discussion: Ring Shout Deep Dive
• 01:12:21 – Final Ratings and Thoughts
• 01:18:42 – Outro & Big July Announcement

Support the show

SUPPORT THE SHOW

Help us stay independent and ad-free by supporting the show directly at Buzzsprout Support Link.

BECOME A MEMBER

Want to hear the conclusion of the Purple Satin Killer? Join our Patreon for exclusive tiers, BONUS "Story Time" episodes, & a shout-out on the show - Patreon Link.

SEND US YOUR CONFESSIONS

We are currently accepting anonymous stories! Our Midnight Confessions Form is linked in our Instagram and TikTok bios, here or email us at Cozy.Midnight.Collective@gmail.com. Your identity is always protected.

Special Thanks to our Patreon Subscribers!

_______________________________________________________________________________________________

Produced + Edited + Mixed by | Morgan Davis & Lauryn Strickland

Artwork Designed by | Morgan Davis & Lauryn Strickland

Music by | Morgan Davis

_______________________________________________________________________________________________

LINKS

• Support us on ...