On St. Patrick’s Day 1935, Enterprise, Utah was alive with music, dancing, and laughter. By morning, rancher Thomas “Penny” Reed had vanished. For years, the town whispered — had he left his family, or had something darker happened that night?

Nearly three years later, a new sheriff uncovered a secret buried in the desert — and set the stage for one of southern Utah’s most sensational trials.

*This story is based on almost entirely from historical newspaper accounts, with the help of court records and family stories. Out of respect for descendants, the names of those most closely involved have been changed*

(Don't forget: If this story resonates, please follow, share, and review—it helps more than you know!)

🎧 Support and follow: → Become a patron: https://patreon.com/whatoncewas → Follow on Instagram: @whatoncewas.podcast

Please remember—many of the places mentioned are on private land. Don’t trespass or go exploring without permission. Let’s keep history alive without disturbing what’s left of it.

Intro music is "A Calm Hellfire" by the Wayward Hearts

Knitting Sound Effect by freesound_community from Pixabay

St Patricks dance Music by Alana Jordan from Pixabay

This isn’t a ghost town story. It’s the story of a town that survived. This episode follows this town from its beginning to the end of WW2.

Born from Hebron’s collapse and carved into the high desert by pioneers, Enterprise weathered floods, blizzards, epidemics, and the losses of two world wars. It was a place where children danced on reservoir banks, telephones carried the weight of war, and the dam wasn’t just a wall — it was a lifeline.

In this episode of What Once Was, we trace the rise of Enterprise, Utah — through the journals of Orson Huntsman, the grit of settlers like the Holts and Winsors, and the tragedies that tested this community to its core. From typhoid to warplanes, from ice cream parlors to spy arrests, this is the story of a town that wasn’t supposed to make it… but did.

*I am working on my correct pronunciation of towns so if you listened to the previous episode you might notice a different pronunciation of Hebron in this one*

(Don't forget: If this story resonates, please follow, share, and review—it helps more than you know!)

🎧 Support and follow: → Become a patron: https://patreon.com/whatoncewas → Follow on Instagram: @whatoncewas.podcast

The stories I share are based on old records, newspapers, local legends, and oral histories. While I do my best to tell them truthfully, some details may be lost to time.

Please remember—many of the places we mention are on private land. Don’t trespass or go exploring without permission. Let’s keep history alive without disturbing what’s left of it.

Intro music is "A Calm Hellfire" by the Wayward Hearts

In the shadowed sagebrush country west of Enterprise, Utah, lies a forgotten ghost town with a history as dark as it is captivating. Founded by pioneers answering Brigham Young’s call, Hebron promised prosperity but instead faced relentless trials—natural disasters, fires, drought, and even whispers of supernatural possession.

From cattle rustlers and telegraph fires, to the eerie claims of spiritual hauntings that tore at the fabric of the community, Hebron’s story is one of survival, struggle, and stubborn hope. Join me as we peel back the layers of time, exploring firsthand accounts, forgotten journals, and long-hidden tales of a community that ultimately vanished—but whose echoes remain.

This is the story of Hebron—once a bustling town, now a memory whispered by the wind.

If you love ghost towns, forgotten history, and stories that send chills down your spine, this episode is for you.

(Don't forget: If this story resonates, please follow, share, and review—it helps more than you know!)

🎧 Support and follow: → Become a patron: https://patreon.com/whatoncewas → Follow on Instagram: @whatoncewas.podcast

The stories I share are based on old records, newspapers, local legends, and oral histories. While I do my best to tell them truthfully, some details may be lost to time.

Please remember—many of the places we mention are on private land. Don’t trespass or go exploring without permission. Let’s keep history alive without disturbing what’s left of it.

Intro music is "A Calm Hellfire" by the Wayward Hearts

Accordion music in this episode by Peter Barbaix from Pixabay