Before there was Rotten Tomatoes, before YouTube critics dominated our screens, two rival Chicago newspaper men forever changed how we talk about movies. What began as a local PBS show featuring a pair of bickering film critics evolved into a cultural phenomenon that would span decades and influence generations of film lovers.

The magic of Siskel and Ebert wasn't just in their famous thumbs up/thumbs down verdicts; it was in their genuine passion for cinema and their willingness to make thoughtful criticism accessible to everyday viewers. They weren't interested in impressing audiences with academic jargon or pandering to Hollywood studios. They brought an authenticity to television that felt revolutionary—two real newspaper rivals who genuinely disagreed about films and weren't afraid to challenge each other on screen.

Their impact extended far beyond reviews. They battled for proper presentation formats like letterboxing when pan-and-scan was standard practice. They championed forgotten films like "Batman: Mask of the Phantasm" and "My Dinner with Andre," giving them second lives. They highlighted important cultural conversations, from the disappearance of Black-led films in the 1980s to the rise of slasher movies they found morally objectionable. Whether you agreed with their takes or not, their integrity was never in question.

The tragedy of their stories adds poignant dimension to their legacy. Both men would eventually lose their ability to speak—the very gift that had made them famous. Gene Siskel kept his brain cancer diagnosis largely private before passing away in 1999 at just 53. Roger Ebert's battle with thyroid cancer was more public, robbing him of his voice but never silencing his passion for film criticism, which continued through his writing until his death in 2013.

Want to experience the magic of these pioneering critics firsthand? Seek out their clips on YouTube, where their chemistry and passion still feel as vibrant and engaging today as when they first sat in those theater seats. The balcony may be closed, but their influence on how we discuss, debate, and celebrate cinema continues to thrive.

Support the show