She didn't come in swinging. She wrote up her own proposals, offered to handle her own packing and cleanup, and asked the brokerage to simply honor the guarantee she was promised in writing before she ever signed anything.

In Part Two of this two-part story, we pick up where Part One left off — the moment she went back to Brokerage and asked them to make good on their "Buy Back Guarantee." We talk about how many times someone from the brokerage has come out to look at the house without ever giving her a straight answer, what's actually been said to her along the way, and whatever happened to a promise that claimed "no gimmicks, no false promises." Months later, she's still living in a home she can't fully unpack, still watching her dogs struggle with what's underneath it, still putting plans like foster parenting on hold — waiting on a promise that hasn't been kept.

We also get into what it's been like to take this story public, the response from viewers and agents, the ugly comments about the type of home she owns, and whether anyone from the brokerage has said a word back since she started talking about it.

If you haven't heard Part One yet, start there — this episode won't make sense without it.

Sarah's Tiktok

Our Real Estate Community That Focuses On Consumer Protection

Got a question?

Support the show

State laws and regulations may vary.

Have a story you would like to share with other sellers or buyers?
Hit us up here.

This podcast didn't start as a place to dissect lawsuits and corporate policy, it started as a place for consumers to be heard. We built a community of people who actually give a damn about what happens to buyers and sellers, but somewhere along the way we got a little too deep in the weeds of the industry-wide stuff. So, we're going back to where this started: real people, real stories, and no filter on what we say about it.

Today's story is a doozey that it actually had to be seperated into two parts.

This buyer and her husband did everything a buyer is told to do. They'd already walked away from one deal over inspection concerns, so the second time, they were careful, they interviewed multiple agents, chose a big-name brokerage, and got a written guarantee that if anything catastrophic turned up in the first year, they broker would buy the home back. The inspection report that cleared the sale checked "satisfactory" next to the roof, the electrical, the plumbing. But after closing, that all fell apart and the advice they were given landed them in a home that is no longer insurable.

In part one of this two-part story, we walk through how they found this house, the promise that sealed the deal, closing day under pressure two weeks before Christmas, and the slow unraveling that followed with rotted subfloor hidden under vinyl flooring, wiring nobody flagged, a roof multiple contractors say needs full replacement, oh, and a homeless person was discovered living underneath their home.

Despite all that has gone wrong, this couple has been patient, kind, and communicative with all parties involved to figure out what to do with a home that now costs more to fix than to just buy a new home. Part two picks up next week with what happened when they asked the people who made those promises to actually keep them.

Their experience is a cautionary tale on trusting your gut, getting stuff in writing and why keeping notes and saving all your paperwork comes in handy.

Sarah's Tiktok

Join our loud community of providers who give a damn

Got a question?

Support the show

State laws and regulations may vary.

Have a story you would like to share with other sellers or buyers?
Hit us up here.

Content warning: sexual harassment, assault, sex trafficking, and child exploitation mentioned in this episode.

We were going to take the week off. Then our inbox had other plans.

This episode is about one thing: powerful people in real estate who abuse, harass, and exploit — and an industry that keeps protecting them. From a state association CEO with a civil trial on the horizon and allegations spanning two decades, to a national association president who resigned in disgrace, to luxury brokers convicted of federal sex trafficking, to a real estate professional charged in a child sexual exploitation case while colleagues allegedly stayed silent, the pattern is always the same. We all knew. He was protected. Nobody said anything.

For consumers: know who you're hiring. Check our Watchdog tool and GoodList in the show notes.

For the industry: the good ole boys club is not a shield. Things catch up. They always do.

Watchdog Tools To Help You

Change Petition For Realtor CEO

Realtor and Judge Charged

Florida Realtor's Comments on Muslims

Got a question?

Support the show

State laws and regulations may vary.

Have a story you would like to share with other sellers or buyers?
Hit us up here.

Pocket listings. Private exclusives. Coming soon. Off-market. Whatever they're calling it this week, the industry has spent years telling sellers that keeping their home out of public view is somehow for their benefit.

In this episode, we call that out.

We break down how private listing strategies turned your home into bait for brokerage marketing machines, how the "historic alliance" between Compass, Rocket and Redfin was built on the exact practices Compass spent years publicly condemning, and why Zillow, after spending a year suing Compass over private listings, just launched their own version with a financial incentive for listing agents baked right in.

We also get into Howard Hanna's HannaList, launching right here in Pittsburgh — and the CEO friend who apparently needs to sell his house without his partner, his neighbors, or even his children finding out. That's the example that was given. Publicly. In the Post-Gazette.

Plus: the studies that say private listings sell for more, the studies that say they sell for less, and what I learned from testifying against billion-dollar companies at our state capital about how those studies actually get made.

The bottom line: list the damn home.

📌 Sources & Links

• How Real Estate Companies Use Your Private Listing For Their Own Profit
• Compass and Rocket Form Historic Alliance — Rocket Companies Press Release, Feb 2026
• How Compass Leverages Private Exclusive Listings to Recruit Agents — HousingWire, April 2025
• Rocket Hit With Lawsuit Alleging RESPA Violations, Steering — Inman, Jan 2026
• Zillow Launches Zillow Preview — Zillow Investor Relations, March 2026
• Howard Hanna to Launch Brokerage-Owned Listing Platform — Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, Feb 2026
• DOJ Whistleblower On Corruption
• Lawmakers Raise Questions About DOJ Approval of Compass Merger — Senator Warren, Feb 2026
• Zillow Class Action Lawsuit Expands to Include a New Defendant — Scotsman Guide, Jan 2026
• CMLS Warns Pre-Marketing Could Fragment the Housing Market — HousingWire, March 2026

Got a question?

Support the show

State laws and regulations may vary.

Have a story you would like to share with other sellers or buyers?
Hit us up here.

Welcome to Real Estate Called Out, formerly The Real Estate Replay. New name, sharper focus, and zero patience for the corporate spin that passes for real estate news every single week.

For our first episode, we're starting with a good one.

Opendoor's CEO jumped on social media to announce 30-year fixed mortgages at 4.99%, nearly a full point below market rate, no points, no upfront fees. The internet lost its mind. The napkin math started. And then, one day later, he quietly came back to clarify that the offer is a limited beta test available in exactly two cities, when you buy an opendoor home, and not everyone would qualify for it.

But even if it were available everywhere, the story underneath that headline is worth understanding before you get swept up in the excitement. Because when a company that lost $1.3 billion last year offers you a below-market mortgage rate, the money to fund that discount has to come from somewhere. And that somewhere is almost always the price of the home.

This episode we break down what a rate buydown actually is and how builders have used it for years to distract buyers from purchase price, the basis points argument Opendoor is making and why it only tells part of the story, the equity trap and why a lower monthly payment today can cost you everything if you need to sell in 3 to 5 years, and Opendoor's listing transparency problem — and why you need three separate websites to see the full picture on any home they're selling.

Opendoor isn't the villain. But the devil is always in the details. And the details are exactly what we're here for.

Before you make an offer on any Opendoor home: pull county property records to see what they paid, check price history on Zillow and Redfin — not just the seller's site, and compare to recent closed sales nearby, not active listings.

New here? Real Estate Called Out is 20 minutes a week, one topic, no corporate sponsors, no spin. Subscribe so you don't miss what's coming next.

The PR machine is loud. We're louder.

Got a question?

Support the show

State laws and regulations may vary.

Have a story you would like to share with other sellers or buyers?
Hit us up here.

What happens when a Silicon Valley company offers homeowners $50 Amazon gift cards to submit favorable testimony to a state legislature, and doesn't disclose it? I watched it happen in real time.

In this episode, I'm telling the full story of the day I drove 3.5 hours to the Pennsylvania State Capitol to testify in support of HB 2120, a bill that would require home equity investments (HEIs), also called shared appreciation agreements or home equity sharing agreements, to be regulated as mortgage products under Pennsylvania's usury law.

What I witnessed was a masterclass in how money, lobbyists, and carefully placed friendships work behind the scenes to slow down consumer protections. And it got picked up by Spotlight PA.

We cover:

• What home equity agreements actually are — and why the math should scare you
• Why these products aren't regulated as loans in most states (yet)
• How Point, one of the largest HEI companies, offered customers $50 gift cards to submit written testimony — without disclosing the payments
• Why one company CEO couldn't tell a legislative committee how much a consumer would owe on his own product
• The Urban Institute report the industry cited — and what it actually said
• Why the National Association of Realtors was nowhere to be found (and why that's worth asking about)
• What this fight says about how consumer protection legislation actually works — and who's really in your corner

If you took out a home equity investment or shared appreciation agreement and have a balloon payment coming, you need to understand what's at stake. And if you haven't taken one out yet — listen before you do.

Mentioned in this episode:

• PA Representative Arvind Venkat
• HB 2120 (Pennsylvania House Commerce Committee)
• Spotlight PA: "A Silicon Valley firm offered gift cards as part of a campaign to defeat Pa. regulation"
• David Friend, former CFPB Counsel
• National Consumer Law Center
• Community Legal Services of Philadelphia

Got a question?

Support the show

State laws and regulations may vary.

Have a story you would like to share with other sellers or buyers?
Hit us up here.

Welcome to 2026!

Before we make any resolutions about doing better, let's talk about all the real estate ish that needs to stay in 2025.

This episode is your complete guide to everything we're leaving behind: coaches still denying the NAR settlement mattered, agents going viral for steering content and threatening critics, companies creating fake AI testimonials, RESPA violations dressed up as "networking," and brokers who conveniently ignored their top producers crossing every ethical line.

My "Just In Case" folder nearly crashed my laptop this year with screenshots, contracts, and social media posts that consumers definitely shouldn't have seen. So let's unpack it all, the Camp B coaches, the builder bonuses, the ego-driven commission wars, and the agent who literally looked up someone's phone number to threaten them for posting a critique.

But it's not all doom and gloom! There's actually some good news: Pennsylvania is moving forward with legislation to restrict predatory home equity agreement companies. Progress is possible when we demand better.

Plus: A personal update on why things got quiet around here at the end of 2025 (spoiler: health stuff, family stuff, life stuff), and what's coming in 2026, including special guests and our Housing Rebel provider member events with Rob Hahn on January 21st and Hunterbrook Media on February 18th for a belated Valentine's special on how much we love captive lending and new construction chaos.

Real Estate Ish We're Leaving in 2025:

• Coaches pretending nothing was wrong with pre-settlement practices
• Agents making steering content "for the algorithm"
• Fake testimonials and AI-generated marketing
• FSBO hostage situations and buyer manipulation
• "I don't do interviews" energy from agents with paid Zillow badges
• Builder bonuses to other people's fiduciaries
• RESPA violations disguised as "business strategies"

This episode is based on content from Housing Rebel. All examples are from publicly posted content by real estate professionals.

If you're looking for industry cheerleading, this ain't it. But if you're ready for honest talk about what went wrong and how we fix it, you're in the right place.

Got a question?

Support the show

State laws and regulations may vary.

Have a story you would like to share with other sellers or buyers?
Hit us up here.

Special Episode!

Between July and September 2025, we did something crazy: we pretended to be homebuyers and called 281 real estate agents across 26 cities to see what they're ACTUALLY telling consumers about commissions post-settlement.

The NAR settlement was supposed to introduce price competition and transparency. So what happened?

In this special one-off episode, I break down what we found:

• Why agents in 8 major cities ALL quoted the exact same rate (down to the decimal point)
• The #1 lie agents told us over and over (spoiler: it violates the DOJ-NAR agreement)
• How three agents in one Cincinnati suburb likely misled 175 consumers in a single year
• The one bright spot: two-thirds of agents WILL negotiate if you push back (they just won't tell you that)
• Tactical advice for home buyers and sellers entering the market

Whether you're buying, selling, or working in the industry, you need to hear this.

Read The Full Report

Get Help Finding An Agent

Got a question?

Support the show

State laws and regulations may vary.

Have a story you would like to share with other sellers or buyers?
Hit us up here.