In this thoughtful and practical conversation, John Marshall sits down with Alan Derek Utley, HR executive, speaker, and founder of Culturate Advisory, to explore how good, well-intentioned leaders can unintentionally contribute to unhealthy workplace cultures. Drawing from more than 25 years in HR and leadership development, Alan introduces the idea of accidental toxicity and explains how hidden pressures, perfectionism, fear, and organizational expectations can quietly shape the way people lead and work. At the center of the conversation is Alan's concept of Fanatical Grace, a leadership approach that creates space for people to be human while still holding clear standards for performance and growth. John and Alan unpack why accountability and acceptance do not have to exist at opposite ends of the spectrum, how labels like "negative" or "micromanager" can keep teams stuck, and why constructive curiosity can lead to better conversations than criticism alone. They also explore psychological safety, productive conflict, the behaviors leaders model under pressure, and the role HR plays in aligning policies, incentives, and leadership expectations with the culture an organization actually wants. This episode offers a grounded look at how small moments of grace can interrupt toxic patterns, strengthen trust, and help people perform at a higher level without sacrificing their humanity.
Resources:
Alan Derek Utley - https://alanderekutley.com/
The Grace Period Newsletter - https://www.linkedin.com/newsletters/the-grace-period-7333176031089963008
CliftonStrengths - https://www.gallup.com/cliftonstrengths/en/
Connect with Alan Derek Utley:
LinkedIn - https://www.linkedin.com/in/alanderekutley
Website - https://alanderekutley.com/
TikTok - https://www.tiktok.com/@alanderekutley
Takeaways
Most workplace toxicity is not created by people intentionally trying to harm others; it often develops when good people respond poorly to hidden pressure, fear, unrealistic expectations, and systems that reward the wrong behaviors.
Leaders do not have to choose between accountability and acceptance. Healthy leadership holds people responsible for results while still recognizing their humanity, circumstances, and capacity to learn.
A simple check-in can feel like micromanagement when trust is already strained, which makes understanding how leadership behavior is experienced just as important as understanding the leader's intention.
Labels like "negative," "difficult," or "not a team player" can shut down understanding. Replacing those labels with observable behaviors and genuine questions creates space to discover what is actually happening.
Constructive curiosity can be more useful than constructive criticism because asking what is behind a behavior often reveals problems, pressures, or information that judgment alone would miss.
Grace does not mean ignoring mistakes or lowering expectations. It means acknowledging that something went wrong, separating the mistake from the person's identity, and then working together to make the next outcome better.
Hidden pressures often come from the person we believe we are supposed to be at work, such as the leader who always has the answer, the employee who never misses work, or the executive who prioritizes business at any personal cost.
Leaders teach culture through the behaviors they model. Telling employees to disconnect on vacation means little if the leader continues answering emails throughout their own time away.
Psychological safety grows when people know they can question decisions, disagree respectfully, admit mistakes, and raise concerns without being immediately punished or labeled.
Creating a grace-fueled culture requires more than individual good intentions. Organizations must examine their policies, incentives, leadership behaviors, performance measures, and cultural norms to ensure the entire system supports the behaviors they say they value.
Visit The Present Professional webpage on humessence.com and learn more about how we support leadership development and culture enablement at growth-stage organizations.
Thank you for listening.
Coach John Marshall | Instagram | LinkedIn