Murder has a way of revealing secrets, and the investigation into Margarette Eby's brutal killing peels back layers of deception surrounding the prime suspect, Jeffrey Gorton.

Detective Dave King follows the old Flint police adage: "If you got a case on the come, you gotta write it till it's done." His investigation begins with Eby's list of lovers and the mysterious circumstances surrounding her death—no forced entry until the bedroom, suggesting she knew her killer. As King dives deeper into Eby's life, he uncovers a complex woman: strong-willed, brilliant, and unconventional, who had previously reported an intruder in her bedroom just weeks before her murder.

Meanwhile, we meet Jeffrey Gorton through the eyes of Brenda Fleming, who encounters him at a local bowling alley. Their relationship blossoms into what appears to be a perfect marriage. Jeff is generous, surprising Brenda with thoughtful gifts, such as an expensive bedroom suite, on their honeymoon. He becomes the ideal family man, coaching his children's teams, participating enthusiastically in family gatherings, and organizing spectacular Fourth of July fireworks displays. His only quirk seems to be his constant nervous movements—rocking and nail-biting that never stops.

Yet beneath this carefully constructed façade lies a troubled past. Through his high school friend, Joe Contreras, and his first girlfriend, Dawn Theerback, we discover a different Jeff—one who desperately tried to escape responsibility when Dawn became pregnant at 16, even joining the Navy to get away. Dawn's heartbreaking diary entries reveal her desperate pursuit of Jeff and his eventual reluctant acceptance of fatherhood and marriage.

The FBI's behavioral science unit, including famed profiler John Douglas (the inspiration for characters in "Silence of the Lambs"), provides a chilling psychological portrait of Eby's killer that begins to align with aspects of Gorton's personality and background. When Detective King receives a crucial tip connecting Gorton to Eby through a mutual acquaintance, the parallel narratives converge into a shocking revelation about the man behind the façade of the perfect husband.

Listen now to discover how this meticulous investigation unravels the complex web of secrets surrounding Jeffrey Gorton and the murder of Margarette Eby.

Send us a text

Support the show

Send us a text

Support the show

A children's roller skating party becomes the unlikely setting for a high-stakes undercover operation as police close in on Jeffrey Gorton, a seemingly ordinary family man they believe responsible for two of Michigan's most brutal unsolved murders.

Investigators suspect a predator of unimaginable savagery behind his façade of normalcy—a devoted husband, father of two, church member, and eager school volunteer. For over fifteen years, two horrific cases had haunted Michigan law enforcement: the 1986 murder of Margaret Eby, a prominent Flint university provost and musician found nearly decapitated in her home, and a 1991 case involving a flight attendant in Romulus who suffered a similarly brutal fate.

Advances in DNA technology had connected these crimes through preserved evidence, but police needed a fresh sample from their suspect to confirm their theory. Enter Mike San Andre, a scrappy undercover narcotics officer with silver hoop earrings and a shaved head, looking entirely out of place among elementary school families. His mission: to collect anything with Gorton's DNA—a napkin, cup, cigarette butt—anything that might finally close cases that had remained open for over a decade.

The episode follows this tense surveillance operation and the meticulous forensic work that followed while delving into the shocking details of the cold cases and their victims' stories. We witness the collision of scientific advancement with old-fashioned police work as investigators struggle with minute amounts of DNA and the pressure of knowing a potential predator remains free in the community.

Could a half-empty Mountain Dew cup and some twisted napkins finally bring closure to cases that had baffled police for generations? Join us for this riveting exploration of how the most minor pieces of evidence can sometimes break the most significant cases.

Send us a text

Support the show

Ten days before the Columbine tragedy's first anniversary, families of victims faced a devastating choice: trust officials who had been stonewalling them for a year or file lawsuits before the statute of limitations expired. For most, it wasn't a difficult decision.

What followed was a years-long legal battle that gradually pried loose thousands of pages of evidence Jefferson County officials had desperately tried to conceal. Through court orders and persistent advocacy, families uncovered proof that authorities knew about Eric Harris's threatening website and bomb-making well before the shooting—contradicting their public denials. The struggle culminated in revelations that police had actively prevented rescue attempts for teacher Dave Sanders, who bled to death over three hours while volunteer rescuers were kept at bay.

Behind the headlines, Principal Frank DeAngelis carried his own burden, shepherding traumatized students through three years of emotional aftershocks while battling PTSD himself. Despite developing a heart condition and eventually losing his marriage to the strain, DeAngelis made the surprising choice to remain as principal after his mission to graduate the last class of Columbine survivors was complete.

The tragedy transformed how America responds to school violence. FBI and Secret Service research shattered prevailing myths about school shooters, revealing no useful "profile" exists—except that 81% confide their intentions before acting. Law enforcement abandoned its old containment approach for the now-standard active shooter protocol that prioritizes neutralizing threats immediately.

Through their relentless pursuit of accountability, Columbine families didn't just uncover a troubling pattern of deception. They fundamentally changed how schools and communities identify potential threats, support troubled students, and respond when violence erupts. The full story won't be known until 2027, when depositions from the killers' parents are finally unsealed after decades of court-ordered silence.

Send us a text

Support the show

Delving into the disturbing minds of the Columbine killers reveals a calculated progression toward violence rather than a sudden snap. Eric Harris, a textbook psychopath, meticulously planned the attack for over a year while manipulating everyone around him with an Oscar-worthy performance of contrition and rehabilitation.

The yearbooks exchanged between Eric and Dylan became repositories of their murderous fantasies – complete with drawings of massacres and X's marked over classmates' photos. This exchange represented a dangerous pact of "mutually assured destruction," as either could have exposed the other. Yet the disturbing reality is that Eric's true intentions were hiding in plain sight, even as he charmed his way through a juvenile diversion program following an arrest for breaking into a van.

While Eric's journal entries revealed his genuine desire for mass destruction, Dylan Klebold appears to have been primarily suicidal rather than homicidal. His private writings focused on finding true love as an escape from his misery, suggesting he viewed their planning sessions as fantasy rather than reality until much closer to the event.

The aftermath rippled through the community in profound ways. When Columbine reopened, students and parents formed a "human shield" to physically block the media from accessing the school. The six-month anniversary brought new threats, heightened anxiety, and culminated in the suicide of a wounded student's mother. For survivors like Patrick Ireland, who was shot in the head, recovery meant not just learning to walk again but confronting the reality that dreams – like his plan to become an architect – might now be impossible due to his injuries.

This detailed examination of the Columbine tragedy challenges simplified narratives about bullying or snap decisions, revealing instead how psychopathy can manifest as a long-term, calculated path toward violence that remains undetected despite multiple warning signs. What makes Eric Harris truly frightening isn't just what he did – but how effectively he convinced everyone around him that he was reformed, remorseful, and ready to rejoin society.

Send us a text

Support the show

A grandmother with a peculiar laugh who poisoned multiple husbands with rat poison and confessed with a smile—welcome to the disturbing case of Nanny Doss, "La Viuda Negra" (The Black Widow) or "La Abuelita Risueña" (The Smiling Grandmother).

When investigators questioned Nanny about her husband Samuel's suspicious death, they encountered not a nervous suspect but a woman casually reading romance magazines and flirting with her interrogators. While local police struggled to penetrate her cheerful facade, Special Agent Ray Page finally broke through by asking about the "ghosts" of her past victims. What followed was a chilling confession delivered with disarming casualness: "I put rat poison in his coffee." Her reason? Samuel wouldn't let her watch her favorite TV shows.

The investigation revealed arsenic in the bodies of multiple husbands across several states. Perhaps most disturbing was the discovery that when caught, Nanny already had a dozen potential suitors lined up to become her next victims. Her charm continued even in prison, where she received romantic fan mail despite her conviction. Psychiatrists found no basis for an insanity defense—her actions were calculated and deliberate.

The psychological roots of Nanny's murders stemmed from two contradictory values instilled in childhood: her father's belief that human life only had value if productive, and her mother's teaching that true love was life's ultimate goal. The society that created her—with rigid expectations for women as wives and mothers—provided perfect cover for her crimes. No one expected that behind that pleasant smile lurked one of America's most prolific female serial killers, turning domestic life into her killing ground.

Listen now to hear the full story of America's unexpected "Giggling Grandma" killer. Don't forget to subscribe and share your thoughts about this haunting case!

Send us a text

Support the show

The seventh installment of Nanny Doss's murderous journey brings us to Samuel Doss, a man whose righteous façade conceals a suffocating rigidity that awakens long-buried trauma in his new bride.

After a brief courtship, Nanny marries Samuel, a 59-year-old Oklahoma state road inspector and Sunday preacher who neither drinks, smokes, nor gambles. Initially seeing him as the answer to her failed marriages, Nanny quickly discovers that Samuel's pious exterior masks a controlling personality reminiscent of her abusive father. Every aspect of daily life falls under Samuel's strict regulation – from when lights may be turned on to which chair she may sit in while reading.

When Nanny flees to Alabama after three months of marriage, Samuel responds not with genuine remorse but with calculated negotiation: adopt his lifestyle, and he'll share financial control. The parallels between Samuel and her father become impossible for Nanny to ignore, transforming this marriage into an opportunity for symbolic vengeance. The final breaking point arrives when Samuel discovers and condemns Nanny's beloved romance novels as sinful literature, stripping away her last source of joy and escape.

What follows is a methodical poisoning that lands Samuel in the hospital for 23 days before a seemingly miraculous recovery. Upon his return home, Nanny prepares a special homecoming meal complete with poisoned coffee – a final act that might have gone undetected if not for Dr. Schwalbein's professional curiosity leading to an autopsy that reveals lethal amounts of cyanide.

Join us for this haunting exploration of how childhood trauma, rigid control, and the dismissal of a woman's simple pleasures created the perfect psychological storm for murder. Subscribe now to hear the full story of Nanny Doss, whose grandmotherly appearance concealed one of America's most calculating female killers.

Send us a text

Support the show

In this thought-provoking episode, we delve deep into the psyche of Eric Harris, one of the perpetrators of the Columbine tragedy. By examining his journal entries and the chilling insights they contain, we aim to understand the motivations that drove him to commit such an atrocity. The episode highlights key themes like the influence of societal norms on young minds and the characteristics of psychopathy, painting a picture of a disturbed individual who felt disconnected from humanity.

Listeners will encounter a raw and honest exploration of the attitudes, beliefs, and philosophies that permeated Eric's thoughts, drawing on his perception of the world as a robotic assembly line stifling individuality and natural instincts. We juxtapose Eric’s dark narrative with an examination of how families of victims faced their grief amid public scrutiny.

This episode not only scrutinizes the actions of Eric Harris but also invites reflection on broader societal implications surrounding violence and mental health. With expert insights and heartfelt stories from those directly impacted by the tragedy, the discussion is both engrossing and haunting. Join us as we unravel the complex layers of this dark moment in history while exploring how we can learn from the past to foster a safer future. Tune in and immerse yourself in this gripping narrative, and don’t forget to leave your thoughts with us!

Send us a text

Support the show