Belle Gunness, the “Black Widow of La Porte,” lured victims to her Indiana farm with promises of love and prosperity—only for them to vanish without a trace. In this episode, we trace her journey from a poor Norwegian immigrant to one of America’s most prolific female killers. Through personal ads, calculated deception, and a trail of bodies buried in her yard, Belle’s story blurs the line between greed and pure evil. Was she a cold-blooded murderer, or did she fake her death to escape justice? We dig deep into the mystery, the crimes, and the enduring legend.

Richard Kuklinski, known as “The Iceman,” lived a double life—devoted family man on one side, ruthless contract killer on the other. In this chilling episode, we unravel his troubled childhood, his rise through the criminal underworld, and the brutal methods that made him one of the most feared hitmen in history. From mafia connections to his eventual capture, we explore the psychological makeup of a man who claimed over 100 lives and showed no remorse.

Explore the chilling psyche and life of H.H. Holmes, America's notorious serial killer, from his New Hampshire childhood to the infamous Murder Castle—and beyond. James and Emily dissect Holmes's psychological makeup, crimes, and the legacy that continues to fascinate true crime enthusiasts worldwide.