In this episode, Marcus and Elena uncover how a single misfiled document in the Queens Criminal Court archives changed Raymond Mercer's life forever. When a young public defender stumbles upon exculpatory evidence from a 1972 subway stabbing case that was deliberately buried for decades, it raises disturbing questions about justice in 1970s New York. Follow the paper trail through a system where some evidence isn't lost by accident.

About the Show

Buried Evidence: Cold Cases Unearthed is a bi-weekly investigative podcast that explores cold cases, wrongful convictions, and judicial oversights through meticulous research and compelling storytelling. Hosts Marcus and Elena navigate through dusty archives, interview witnesses, and shine light on cases that the system has forgotten.

Meet Your Hosts

Marcus Reed

Former paralegal turned investigative journalist with 15 years of experience covering the criminal justice system. Growing up in Brooklyn during the 1980s, Marcus witnessed firsthand how the aftermath of New York's turbulent '70s shaped the city's approach to crime and justice. He brings analytical precision to each episode, connecting historical cases to present-day issues with methodical, empathetic storytelling.

Elena Vasquez

Public defender turned true crime writer and podcaster with Puerto Rican roots in the Bronx. Elena brings perspective on how marginalized communities were disproportionately affected by New York's criminal justice system during the crisis years of the 1970s. Her passionate, incisive approach provides historical and social context for cases, highlighting patterns of institutional failure with righteous indignation toward systemic injustice.