What happens when beloved video games make the leap from console to cinema? Four gaming-enthusiast brothers dive deep into this creative crossroads, exploring untapped virtual worlds ripe for Hollywood adaptation—with one crucial rule: the games cannot have hit the silver screen yet.

The conversation weaves through several compelling candidates that deserve the movie treatment. Devil May Cry emerges as a natural fit for an action-packed adaptation, with the brothers debating which actors could capture Dante's distinctive blend of supernatural combat prowess and charismatic personality. Luigi's Mansion receives passionate advocacy as the perfect follow-up to the successful Super Mario Bros. Movie, potentially delivering a family-friendly ghost-hunting adventure with the perfect blend of humor and light scares.

Horror game enthusiasts will appreciate the detailed discussion of The Dark Pictures Anthology's cinematic potential. These narrative-driven experiences, already structured like interactive films, could translate beautifully to an anthology horror series while maintaining their character-focused storytelling. The conversation takes a surprising turn when Portal receives unanimous support, with the brothers highlighting how its innovative concepts, confined setting, and memorable antagonist GLaDOS could create something truly unique in the film landscape.

Throughout their debate, the brothers don't shy away from criticizing past video game adaptations, particularly lamenting how the Resident Evil films departed from the games' compelling storylines and atmospheric horror. Their passionate exchanges reveal a deeper truth about successful adaptations: they must honor what fans love about the original while crafting something that stands on its own cinematic merits.

Whether you're a dedicated gamer, film enthusiast, or simply enjoy listening to siblings playfully argue their positions, this episode offers thought-provoking perspectives on storytelling across different media. Which game would you most want to see adapted? Join the conversation and share your thoughts in the comments!

Support the show