In this episode of The Southern Blueprint, we crack open one of the wildest true crime tales in bourbon history — the infamous case known as Pappygate. What started as a few missing bottles quickly unraveled into a sprawling investigation involving stolen barrels of rare whiskey, anabolic steroids, black-market dealings, and a close-knit Kentucky community blindsided by betrayal.

At the center of it all? Gilbert “Toby” Curtsinger — a longtime warehouse worker at Buffalo Trace, a devoted family man, gym rat, and recreational softball player, who quietly masterminded one of the most audacious organized theft rings the spirits industry has ever seen. Using his position inside one of the most respected distilleries in the world, Toby slowly siphoned off bottles and barrels of some of the rarest and most valuable bourbon on the market — including the legendary Pappy Van Winkle 20-Year and 23-Year — and sold them to friends, neighbors, and even teammates.

But this wasn’t just about missing bourbon. It was about legacy, trust, and the tightrope walk between small-town loyalty and personal greed. From the front lines of the investigation led by Sheriff Pat Melton, to the sensational headlines, media frenzy, and Toby’s 15-year prison sentence that was reduced to just 30 days thanks to Kentucky’s controversial “shock probation” law — this episode digs into every twist and turn.

We also examine the cultural impact of the heist, how it led to heightened security in the bourbon world, and why bottles of Pappy now feel more myth than spirit. Plus, we unpack the Netflix docuseries Heist, and how it shaped public perception of the man behind the barrels.

So pour a glass, settle in, and join us for a true story of stolen whiskey, Southern charm, and the fine line between a local legend and a criminal empire.

If you love bourbon, true crime, Southern storytelling, or just a damn good tale soaked in secrets and scandal — this one’s for you.