Send us your strange and spoopy stories and it might be featured on an episode!

What befell the 115 inhabitants of the Roanoke Colony who mysteriously vanished in 1590? Left with only two cryptic clues—the words "CROATOAN" and "CRO" carved into a post and tree—this centuries-old American mystery continues to captivate our imaginations.

Governor John White's journey is particularly heartbreaking. After establishing the colony in 1587 with settlers including his own daughter Eleanor and newborn granddaughter Virginia, he sailed to England for supplies. What should have been a brief trip stretched into three agonizing years as the Anglo-Spanish War prevented his return. When White finally made it back to Roanoke Island in present-day North Carolina, he discovered a ghost town where a thriving settlement once stood.

The most compelling theories suggest the colonists didn't vanish mysteriously but rather integrated with friendly Native American tribes. Archaeological evidence supports this idea, with discoveries showing English artifacts alongside indigenous items in the same soil layers. Researcher Scott Dawson argues the colonists likely joined the Croatoan tribe, with whom they'd established friendly relations, to escape starvation and conflict with hostile tribes. Other possibilities range from disease outbreaks to violent ends, though the complete absence of human remains raises questions about these darker scenarios.

Whether a tale of survival through cultural integration or America's first major disappearance, Roanoke's legacy endures in our cultural consciousness, inspiring everything from scholarly research to popular entertainment like American Horror Story. What's your theory about what happened to America's lost colonists? Share your thoughts and subscribe for more explorations of history's most fascinating mysteries.