エピソード

  • A $45 Million Post-It Note Gift
    2026/11/19

    A $45 million transfer on two Post-it notes sounds like a punchline, but it lands in the BC Court of Appeal with real consequences. We break down a British Columbia family law dispute where a preservation order under section 91 of the Family Law Act is meant to stop assets from being moved while spousal support and property-division claims are still alive. The twist is the defence: the money “wasn’t really mine” because it was held for someone else as the beneficial owner.

    We also get into why civil contempt is its own demanding corner of the law. The courts expect precision, clear allegations, and clear orders, yet the Court of Appeal still finds the breach and sends the case back for a penalty decision. That raises an uncomfortable practical question: what does punishment even look like when a person can part with $45 million as casually as signing a note?

    Then the focus shifts to negligence law in Canada after a stabbing at Matsqui Institution, a federal penitentiary in BC. Even with a conceded duty of care to protect inmates, the claim against the Attorney General of Canada fails on the hardest parts of negligence: whether the harm was reasonably foreseeable and whether the outcome is too remote to pin on the government, even when an officer doesn’t follow a verification rule.

    If you care about Canadian law, court orders, and how judges draw lines in messy real life, you’ll find a lot to debate here. Subscribe, share the episode with a friend, and leave a review, then tell us which decision you think the courts got right?


    Follow this link for a transcript of the show and links to the cases discussed.

    続きを読む 一部表示
    21 分
  • From Nuclear Bunker To Seismic Liability At Victoria Law Courts
    2026/11/12

    A building can be “safe” for the wrong disaster, and Victoria’s main courthouse may be the clearest example of that. We walk through how Victoria Law Courts was completed in 1962 with Cold War priorities in mind: reinforced concrete, a basement designed to function as a nuclear fallout shelter, standby power, water supplies, and even features meant to manage bomb-blast shock. Then we ask the uncomfortable modern question for British Columbia: what does that kind of design mean when the realistic threat is a major earthquake?

    We also trace what happened after the original build, including the decision to add two extra storeys in the 1970s and what later seismic assessments reportedly said about the building’s ability to meet modern structural expectations. We talk about why seismic retrofits are hard, what “pancake” collapse risk implies for a busy public building, and why small preparedness gestures can feel inadequate when the underlying structure is the real hazard. Along the way, we look at government decision-making signals, including later facility condition assessments and why some of the key rationale appears to be redacted from public view.

    In the second half, we shift to tech, competition, and consumer impact: a certified class action against Apple tied to the long-running Apple and Google deal that keeps Google as the default iPhone search engine. We unpack the Competition Act claims, the argument that market dominance can inflate online advertising prices, and how arbitration clauses can block lawsuits against major companies. We also explain what certification means, how expert economic evidence can be used at this stage, and why British Columbia’s class action rules can turn a case into a Canada-wide opt-out claim.

    If you care about public safety, seismic risk, competition law, or the power tech platforms have over everyday markets, hit subscribe, share the episode, and leave a review. What part of this story worries you most?


    Follow this link for a transcript of the show and links to the cases discussed.

    続きを読む 一部表示
    22 分
  • Crime Stoppers Data Breach Fallout
    2026/11/05

    Anonymous tips feel like a simple bargain: you share what you know, you stay protected, and maybe you even get a cash reward. That bargain collapses when the system gets hacked. We dig into the Crime Stoppers data breach and what it means for Canadian privacy, public safety, and real people who may have reported dangerous crime, believing their identity would never surface. We also compare Crime Stoppers to classic police informants, including why informant privilege is treated as almost absolute in Canadian law and why that secrecy can be both useful and unsettling.

    From there, we zoom out to the uncomfortable question the leak forces into the open: do we want a policing culture that encourages paid, supposedly anonymous reporting by neighbours and family members, knowing the risks of false tips and the reality that digital “anonymity” can evaporate overnight? We also look at the immediate fallout, including police agencies pausing participation and the role of Privacy Commissioner investigations when sensitive data is stored and then exposed.

    Then we pivot to practical law that hits close to home: a BC estate dispute where a will-maker may have intended to leave one daughter less, but a capital gains tax clause could leave her with nothing. We explain the Geulch gap idea, why competency isn't the only issue courts consider, and why proper will advice matters when trusts, taxes, and unequal gifts are on the table. We wrap up with the Presumption of Death Act and the legal steps families face when someone disappears, plus why a tip-line leak can complicate the “has anyone heard from them?” question.

    If you find this useful, subscribe, share the episode with someone who cares about privacy or estate planning, and leave a review. What do you think should change after a breach like this?


    Follow this link for a transcript of the show and links to the cases discussed.

    続きを読む 一部表示
    22 分
  • Advance Voting and No-Fault ICBC Insurance
    2026/10/22

    An 11% drop in advance voting sounds simple until you ask the uncomfortable question: who stayed home, and what does that change on election night? We start by unpacking the newest Elections BC advance poll totals, then zoom out to what we learned last election when early voters and election-day voters broke in different directions. It is a reminder that election data is never just numbers; it is behaviour, incentives, and timing.

    Then we get into one of the most personal policy fights in British Columbia: ICBC no-fault insurance and the care-based model. We talk candidly about why no-fault can feel efficient for minor collisions, yet become deeply unfair when someone is seriously injured, especially if their future earnings do not match their income on the day of the crash. We also trace the political backstory, including the role of the Move Up union and how organized support for monopoly ICBC coverage shows up during a campaign.

    We close with two sharp legal explainers. First, a complaint about an “official-looking” election mailer and what Elections Act section 234.4 actually prohibits, including the carve-out for parody or satire. Second, a BC Court of Appeal decision on a fire insurance claim that was denied because of an undisclosed risk that had nothing to do with the fire, a practical lesson under the Insurance Act for every homeowner.

    If you found this helpful, subscribe, share the episode with a friend who follows BC politics, and leave a review with your take on what the advance voting drop really means.


    Follow this link for a transcript of the show and links to the cases discussed.

    続きを読む 一部表示
    21 分
  • No-Fault ICBC Insurance Under Fire
    2026/10/10

    No-fault auto insurance is sold as the simple answer: fewer lawsuits, faster benefits, lower premiums. But what happens when the crash is not a fender bender, and someone’s life is permanently changed? We walk through why BC’s ICBC no-fault model has erupted into a provincial election fight, and why the promise of “enhanced care” can feel very different depending on whether you have a minor injury or a catastrophic one.

    We’re joined by Michael Mulligan, a criminal defence lawyer in Victoria, to unpack the real-world trade-offs between a tort system and no-fault insurance. We talk about fairness for seriously injured people, the problem of predicting future earning potential, and why “you’ll get taken care of” is not the same thing as having an independent court able to review decisions. We also push back on popular claims about limits, legal fees, and what compensation looks like when you can sue versus when you cannot.

    Then we get into the structure of the market itself: ICBC’s monopoly on basic auto insurance, the argument for private sector competition, and why choice matters if you believe a public insurer is truly offering the best deal. If you care about ICBC, BC car insurance rates, and what rights drivers give up for lower premiums, this conversation will sharpen your view fast.

    Subscribe for more, share this with someone debating no-fault versus a hybrid model, and leave a review with your take: should BC bring back the right to sue for serious crashes?


    Follow this link for a transcript of the show.

    続きを読む 一部表示
    9 分
  • Safe Supply On Trial
    2026/10/01

    A criminal trafficking charge sounds straightforward until you look at what’s happening on the ground in British Columbia’s overdose crisis. We dig into a BC Supreme Court decision sparked by the Drug User Liberation Front (DULF), a group that received Vancouver Coastal Health funding for drug checking and overdose prevention, then went further by buying drugs on the dark web, testing them, and providing them at cost to people who use drugs. After media attention and political blowback, funding ended, police searched the site, and the founders faced possession for the purpose of trafficking charges.

    From there, the story becomes a deep, practical Charter section 7 debate about life, liberty, and security of the person under Canada’s Controlled Drugs and Substances Act. We break down the evidence the judge relied on, including the scale of overdose deaths, and the argument that a tested non-medical supply can reduce fatalities. We also explain why the usual “just get an exemption” answer isn’t so simple, what happened when DULF applied for a federal exemption, and how delays and denial collide with an urgent public health emergency.

    We also sort out a confusing but crucial distinction: supervised consumption sites with federal exemptions versus overdose prevention sites approved provincially without the same legal cover. Add in the bottlenecks in prescribed safer supply, limited access to doctors, and real-world mismatch between prescriptions and what people will use, and you can see why the court calls the current framework a near-blanket ban with no meaningful safety valve. The judge declares the law unconstitutional in B.C., suspends the decision for six months, and tees up an appeal and a policy response that could reshape harm reduction and drug trafficking law nationwide. If you found this useful, subscribe, share the episode, and leave a review. What do you think Ottawa should do next?


    Follow this link for a transcript of the show and links to the cases discussed.

    続きを読む 一部表示
    21 分
  • Should Government Be Able To Rewrite The Rules For The Law Society?
    2026/09/24

    Government changing the rules for how lawyers are regulated sounds technical until you ask one blunt question: can a legal system stay fair if the bar is not independent from the state? We dig into British Columbia’s Bill 21 (the Legal Professions Act) and the ongoing court challenge over whether the independence of the legal profession is a constitutional requirement, not just a tradition. When the government is a frequent opponent in civil claims, Charter litigation, and criminal prosecutions, who should control the regulator that sets lawyers’ rules and discipline?

    A key development lands before the main appeal even starts: twelve different organizations apply to intervene at the BC Court of Appeal. We explain the test for intervention, the difference between a direct interest and public interest standing, and why the court decides these groups can add useful perspectives without turning the hearing into a free-for-all. The interveners range from national legal bodies to groups raising issues like DRIPA implementation, an Indigenous council within the proposed scheme, and serious concerns about a regulator potentially compelling medical or mental health treatment.

    Then we shift to a tragic negligence lawsuit from a municipal pool in Burnaby, where a four-year-old fell from the side of a three-metre diving board during “playtime” in swimming lessons. We unpack the standard of care for instructors, what the judge finds negligent, and how Canadian damages work, including the cap on non-pecuniary damages and the much larger numbers tied to loss of future earning capacity. If you care about public law, civil liability, and how courts actually reason, subscribe, share the episode, and leave a review with your biggest question from the cases.


    Follow this link for a transcript of the show and links to the cases discussed.

    続きを読む 一部表示
    21 分
  • Fairness On Cross-Examination
    2026/09/17

    One missing question can be the whole appeal, and that’s where we start. We walk through a B.C. Court of Appeal decision arising from a judge-alone second-degree murder trial where the accused admits indignity to human remains but denies murder, claiming an accidental death during consensual sex and blaming memory gaps on intoxication. The legal tension is sharp: if the Crown wants to argue the intoxication story is fabricated, do they have to put that allegation directly to the accused in cross-examination?

    From there, we explain the Brown and Dunn principle in plain language and why it sits at the centre of fairness in Canadian evidence law. We talk about what it means to confront a witness with your theory, what counts as a real opportunity to respond, and why appellate courts look at the entire trial record instead of treating the rule like a technical “gotcha.” If you care about criminal procedure, credibility findings, and how appellate review actually works, this is a must-hear breakdown.

    We then shift into the NCRMD system, where the words “not criminally responsible” can be deeply misunderstood. A woman with treatment-resistant schizophrenia grabs a child on a bus, truly believing the child is hers, and ends up in secure psychiatric custody for years. We unpack Review Board decisions, the “significant threat to the safety of the public” test, and how mental health law can mean detention with no fixed end date.

    To close, we tackle a home invasion conviction built on circumstantial evidence like DNA on masks and cell tower data, plus a thorny issue about a trial judge relying on material in a court file that was not marked as an exhibit. Subscribe, share the episode, and leave a review, then tell us: where should courts draw the line on fairness and proof?


    Follow this link for a transcript of the show and links to the cases discussed.

    続きを読む 一部表示
    22 分