We hit the stage at Bottle Shop 48 for a live show that had everything: chaos, ghosts, and a 60-ton military tank.

Colleen covers the unbelievable 1995 San Diego tank rampage of Shawn Nelson — a former Army tank crewman who stole an M60 Patton tank from a National Guard armory and drove it through city streets in one of the most infamous televised chases in history.

Then Tayler takes us across the pond to Borley Rectory, often called “the most haunted house in England.” Phantom nuns, poltergeist activity, mysterious messages on the walls — and decades of paranormal investigation that still spark debate today.

From freeway mayhem to ghostly hauntings, this live episode brings the energy.

Grab a drink and buckle up.

Join us as we gather once again at one of our favorite spots: Jarrod's! We recorded this episode on February, Friday the 13th aka Galentines day!

In this episode, Tayler tells the story of Brocarde, a singer-songwriter from Oxfordshire who is known for her dramatic gothic flair, dark romance, and theatrical aesthetic. But her love life took a very paranormal turn when she revealed she had fallen in love with a Victorian ghost named Edwardo. What started as a spooky rom-com fantasy complete with a gothic wedding and vows to thin air eventually turned into a cautionary tale, as Brocarde later shared that the relationship became intense and unsettling, leading her to end things and seek spiritual help. It’s a love story that proves dating is hard enough...even before you add ghosts.

Colleen covers “How To Loose A Guy In 10 Ways,” spotlighting infamous women in true crime and the very final ways they got rid of their men:

• Melanie McGuire (The Suitcase Killer) – An argument ends with her boyfriend trapped in a suitcase while she… goes to bed. Nightmare fuel with a side of bad decisions.
• Dalia Dippolito – Hired a hitman to kill her husband, unaware the “hitman” was undercover and the whole thing was caught on camera. True crime meets reality TV.
• Jodi Arias – A toxic relationship spirals into obsession, lies, and one of the most disturbing crime scenes in modern true crime history.
• Belle Gunness – Early 1900s serial killer who lured suitors through personal ads, murdered them, and buried them on her farm. Dating apps walked so Belle could run.

Join us for this exciting episode, as we step inside the haunted halls of East Valley Paranormal in the heart of downtown Mesa, to interview owners and paranormal investigators Michelle and Heather.

We sit down with them in their seance room, which is located INSIDE their haunted artifact museum. Tune in to hear all about how their friendship and love for the paranormal intuitively led them to what is now their own business, where their love for the paranormal started, how they formed community and so many spooky fun stories!

It’s our ONE-YEAR ANNIVERSARY — and we’re marking it with one of the most infamous studies in psychology: The Stanford Prison Experiment.

What began in 1971 as a two-week simulation of prison life inside a Stanford basement spiraled into chaos in just a few days. Ordinary college students were randomly assigned to be “guards” or “prisoners” — and very quickly, power, control, and cruelty took over. What happened next would shock the researchers, traumatize the participants, and forever change how we think about authority, obedience, and human behavior.

In this episode, we walk through how the experiment was set up, the key players involved, the chilling breakdown that followed, and why this study remains so controversial today. Was this groundbreaking psychology… or an unethical disaster that went way too far?

Get cozy and join Colleen and Tayler for a laugh-filled dive into the mysterious world of Bigfoot and Sasquatch! In this episode, we explore legendary sightings, share fascinating stories from the Bigfoot community, and even play real audio footage collected by the Bigfoot Field Researchers Organization. Whether you’re a believer, a skeptic, or just here for the fun, this episode is packed with laughs, intrigue, and a touch of the unexplained.

Got a story to tell? Email us at IGSTTYstories@gmail.com

In this episode of I’ve Got Something To Tell You, we play another round of Top 5, counting down the scariest types of ghosts. Grab a blanket, a warm beverage, and tune in and listen as your hear us overthink all of our answers in this chaotic episode.

Is a ghost astronaut scary to you? Have better answers then us? Email us what you think! IGSTTYstories@gmail.com

In this episode, we’re telling two stories that couldn’t be more different — and yet somehow feel eerily connected.

Colleen covers the survival story of Alison Botha, a woman who endured one of the most brutal attacks in South African history and lived to tell the story. What happened to Alison is horrifying, heartbreaking, and impossible to forget — but her survival is a testament to resilience, memory, and the will to live when everything says you shouldn’t.

Tayler explores the infamous alien abduction case of Betty and Barney Hill — a story that shaped modern UFO lore and raised uncomfortable questions about belief, fear, and how society treats people who experience the unexplainable.

Together, these cases reveal something deeper than crime or conspiracy: the ways systems fail victims, the way truth gets doubted, and the cost of not listening when it matters most.

This episode isn’t just about survival or starships.
It’s about accountability.
It’s about belief.
It’s about the quiet, devastating truth that sometimes the world needs to do better.

🎙️ Topics covered: true crime, survivor stories, alien abductions, justice systems, trauma, resilience, and the legacy of Betty and Barney Hill.

#truecrimepodcast #survivorstories #paranormal #alienabduction #truecrimecommunity #bettyandbarneyhill #alisanbotha #darkhistory #unsolvedmysteries

This week on I’ve Got Something To Tell You, we’re diving into two stories that live at the intersection of obsession, conspiracy, and control.

Tayler takes us deep into the Montauk Project — a long-running conspiracy theory involving secret government experiments, alleged mind control, time travel, and psychological warfare. From Camp Hero to the darkest corners of Cold War paranoia, she breaks down where the story came from, why it persists, and how much of it might be rooted in real government experimentation.

Meanwhile, Colleen covers the tragic and disturbing story of Chris Benoit — one of the most shocking cases in professional wrestling history. This segment examines Benoit’s rise in WWE, the brutal murders that ended his family’s lives, and the role chronic traumatic encephalopathy (CTE) may have played, while also confronting the complicated legacy he left behind.

Together, these stories explore what happens when power, secrecy, and unchecked damage collide — whether in alleged government programs or inside the human brain.

True crime. Conspiracy theories. Psychological horror. And a whole lot to unpack.