What do alien goblins and a self-proclaimed martial arts legend have in common? They're both at the center of this live episode of I've Got Something To Tell You.

Tayler dives into the infamous Kelly-Hopkinsville Goblins case, exploring one of the most famous alleged extraterrestrial encounters in American history and the strange night that left an entire family convinced they weren't alone.

Then Colleen heads to 1970s Chicago to tell the unbelievable true story of Count Dante—the self-proclaimed "Deadliest Man Alive"—and the bizarre chain of events that led to the infamous Chicago Dojo Wars.

From cryptids and UFO lore to karate rivalries gone completely off the rails, this live show has everything you could ask for: mystery, mayhem, and plenty of laughs along the way.

This week, Colleen takes us to 1920s Chicago for Part One of the story of Leopold and Loeb — two wealthy young men who believed their intelligence put them above everyone else, and set out to prove it by committing the “perfect crime.” We get into who they were, how their relationship developed, the murder of 14-year-old Bobby Franks, and the mistakes that quickly led investigators straight to them. Next week, we’ll pick up with the trial and the legendary attorney who stepped in to defend them, Clarence Darrow.

Then, Tayler takes us to the Philippines for the strange story of Cornelio Closa Jr., a teenager who reportedly began disappearing and reappearing under mysterious circumstances and claimed he was being visited by a mysterious girl no one else could see.

True crime, paranormal, and two stories that leave us with a LOT to talk about.

We’re back LIVE from BottleShop48!

This week, Tayler takes us inside the Crescent Hotel, a gorgeous mountaintop resort turned “health resort” with one of the most horrifying backstories imaginable. Somehow, this place became a literal aesthetic dream, but underneath all that charm is a history full of deception, medical nightmares, and ghosts who may have never left.

Then Colleen takes us to the 1994 World Cup for the tragic story of Andrés Escobar, the Colombian soccer star behind what’s been called the deadliest goal ever scored. But this story is not just about one Escobar… because hovering over Colombia at the same time was another name you definitely know: Pablo Escobar.

This live episode has it all: haunted hotel glamour, medical horror, World Cup heartbreak, cartel connections, and, as always, plenty of laughs from BottleShop48.

Hello old pals, we hope you haven't forgotten us! We took a couple weeks to take a little break and recharge. For this week's episode we decided to do a little revisit and rewind to some of our favorite episode's and next week we will be coming in with FRESH new stories.

This week, we're throwing it back to two stories from the podcast archives! Colleen revisits The Elevator Game from Episode 12, the infamous paranormal ritual from Reddit that claims to transport players to another dimension through a specific sequence of elevator rides. Tayler takes a look back at The Keddie Cabin Murders, the brutal and still-unsolved 1981 murders that Colleen originally covered in Episode 18. Join us as we revisit these early episodes and see how they hold up years later.

Email us at IGSTTYstories@gmail.com to send us a story or just say hi!

This week, Tayler dives into one of the strangest unsolved mysteries in modern history: the Oakville Blobs. In 1994, residents of a small Washington town reported a mysterious gelatinous substance falling from the sky. What followed were reports of illness, bizarre scientific findings, and theories ranging from military experiments to extraterrestrial involvement. More than 30 years later, no one can say for certain what really rained down on Oakville.

Then, Colleen takes us on a ride through some of the most shocking amusement park tragedies ever recorded. From mechanical failures and operator errors to accidents that forever changed safety regulations, she'll explore the devastating stories behind attractions that turned deadly and the lasting impact they left on the amusement park industry.

Grab your raincoat and double-check your safety harness—this episode is packed with mystery, mayhem, and plenty of questions that still don't have answers.

PS. SPOILER ALERT! We also talk Widow's Bay... Wanna join the conversation? Email us at IGSTTYstories@gmail.com

LIVE from Jarrod's! 🎙️

This week, we're bringing you one of our favorite live shows yet — and trust us, the giggles were out of control.

Tayler kicks things off with the story of Harold the Doll, a creepy little resident of Key West whose reputation for strange happenings has followed him for decades. And please don't insult him.

Then Colleen dives into the unbelievable life of Rasputin — the peasant mystic who somehow went from wandering holy man to one of the most influential figures in the Russian Empire. Between the scandals, the rumors, the royal family drama, and one of history's most infamous murder plots, Rasputin proves that sometimes the truth is stranger than fiction.

This episode has haunted dolls, Russian history, plenty of laughs, and all the chaos that comes with recording live in front of an audience.

SPOILER ALERT! We discuss our new found love - Widow's Bay - and will continue discussing until the season is over. Want to join the convo with us, or have any theories? Email us at IGSTTYstories@gmail.com!

Then, Tayler dives into the dark history and hauntings of Yuma Territorial Prison in a paranormal-only episode. Built by the very inmates who would later be confined inside its walls, the brutal desert prison became known for its extreme heat, harsh punishments, overcrowded cells, and infamous dark cell. But according to visitors and staff, some prisoners may have never truly left. From ghostly figures and unexplained voices to chilling encounters inside the prison walls, we explore the eerie paranormal stories that continue to surround one of Arizona’s most infamous prisons.

In this true crime only episode, Colleen covers the devastating case of Judy Malinowski, who was set on fire by her ex-boyfriend, Michael Slager, at a gas station in 2015. Judy survived for nearly two years after the attack, enduring countless surgeries while fighting to share her story and seek justice.

Colleen goes over the events leading up to the attack, the investigation and trial, and how Judy’s testimony helped make legal history after her passing in June 2017.