Get ready for another bonus episode, where Tayler and Colleen tell stories they pull from the tops of their noggins, and from the eerie depths of reddit. And in this episode, we have another skinwalker encounter story from Kilee! Grab a blanket, get cozy and get ready to embrace spooky season with us!

Have a story to tell? Email us at IGSTTYstories@gmail.com!

Back by popular demand — we got a whole lot spookier this week! We packed up our gear and headed to the famously haunted Jarrod’s Coffee in Mesa for a special bonus episode. Armed with our spirit box, we tried to make contact with whoever might still be lingering in the café.

From unexplained knocks to eerie voices coming through the static, this one had us looking over our shoulders the whole time. Grab your headphones, your coffee, and maybe some sage — because Jarrod’s doesn’t disappoint.

This week, Colleen and Tayler dive into not one, but two chilling legends of true crime and folklore.

Colleen takes us inside the twisted world of Ed Gein — the quiet Wisconsin farmer whose farmhouse of horrors shocked the world and inspired Psycho, The Texas Chainsaw Massacre, and Silence of the Lambs. From grave robbing to his infamous “woman suit,” Ed’s story proves sometimes the boogeyman is all too real.

Meanwhile, Tayler heads east to the Pine Barrens of New Jersey, where strange cries, hoofprints, and centuries of lore point to the winged cryptid locals call the Jersey Devil. Was it a cursed child, a colonial-era invention, or something darker still haunting the Garden State?

Two very different devils. One unforgettable episode.