In this unfiltered bonus episode, Tayler and Colleen dive into a mix of eerie stories pulled from both Reddit and the depths of their own memories. We start with the disturbing world of false confessions and how easily truth can get twisted, then spiral into a conversation about AI taking over. From there, we tumble straight into the strange world of faerie traps and Appalachian weirdness—where the trees whisper and not everything wants you to leave.

Have a story to share? Email it to IGSTTYstories@gmail.com to be featured on the next BONUS episode!

Episode 20: Lizzie Borden – Did She Really Do A Pear Of Murders??

For our 20th episode, we’re diving into the chilling case of Lizzie Borden. In 1892, Andrew and Abby Borden were brutally murdered in their Fall River home, and all eyes turned to Lizzie. But did she really do it?

We break down the gruesome details, the shocking trial, and the lingering mysteries surrounding this true crime legend. Was Lizzie guilty, or was she framed? And why does her story still haunt us over a century later?

Ghosts, Goat Men & Grizzlies… Oh My! This chaotic and creepy bonus episode, Tayler and Colleen take you deep into the haunted hollers of the Appalachian mountains. From eerie tales of the legendary Goat Man to unsettling UFO abduction accounts and the bone-chilling saga of the Grizzly Man, this episode is packed with strange and spooky stories pulled from folklore, Reddit, and our own memories. Expect twists, laughs, and just the right amount of “what the hell was that?” energy. You never know what’s lurking in the woods—or what we’ll say next.