The Industry Relations Podcast is now available on your favorite podcast player!

Rob and Greg break down NAR's latest settlement move, Zillow's shift toward pre-marketing, and what it all means for the industry. The back half turns into a heated debate on new "public marketing" laws, the definition of marketing itself, and whether the MLS is a listing platform or a broker cooperative.

***CORRECTION: During the podcast we mistakenly commented that we had recieved an update about the recent NAR settlement 24hrs ahead of time. That is not accurate. We recieved the update the day of the news being announced. We apologize and regret the error.***

• NAR's new settlement strategy is more proactive—but may face legal pushback

• Zillow's "Preview" signals a major shift toward pre-marketing

• Portal competition remains intense across Zillow, Homes.com, and others

• New state laws are vague and raise more questions than answers

• "What is marketing?" is becoming a core industry debate

• The MLS identity crisis: platform vs. cooperative

• Pre-marketing continues to reshape listing strategy

• Consumer expectations could determine where this all goes

Connect with Rob and Greg

Rob's Website

Greg's Website

Watch us on YouTube

Our Sponsors:

Cotality

Notorious VIP

The Giant Steps Job Board

Production and Editing Services by Sunbound Studios

The Industry Relations Podcast is now available on your favorite podcast player!

Rob and Greg discuss Northwest MLS countersuing Compass and the broader implications for private listings, cooperation, and MLS rules. The conversation centers on whether MLSs should enforce listing transparency, how "coming soon" and private exclusives are being used, and whether current policies are conflating professional cooperation with public marketing. They also explore potential futures for IDX, syndication, and the role of MLSs in regulating broker behavior.

• Lawsuit Focus – Northwest MLS is challenging Compass over private listing practices.

• Core Tension – Cooperation (agent access) vs. public marketing are being conflated.

• Private Listings – Debate over seller choice vs. market transparency.

• MLS Role – Split on whether MLS should enforce behavior or just enable cooperation.

• IDX Debate – Idea to remove IDX vs. risk of fragmenting listings.

• Fiduciary Risk – Future lawsuits may hinge on agent advice to sellers.

• Inconsistent Rules – "Coming soon" policies vary widely across MLSs.

• Fairness Concern – Private networks could limit access to listings.

Links

Nick Alfencamp's Article - The Pre-Market Arms Race
"Only the right ones..." - Compass agent's Instagram post
NWMLS Isn't Just Playing Defense Anymore -Vendor Alley Post

Connect with Rob and Greg

Rob's Website

Greg's Website

Watch us on YouTube

Our Sponsors:

Cotality

Notorious VIP

The Giant Steps Job Board

Production and Editing Services by Sunbound Studios

The Industry Relations Podcast is now available on your favorite podcast player!

Rob and Greg revisit the fallout from their conversation with Andy, focusing on the rapid shift toward "coming soon" and preview listings across major portals. Zillow's move into previews—alongside Redfin and Homes.com—signals a broader industry change in how listings are marketed and distributed. The discussion centers on whether Zillow truly "changed," what this means for MLS control, and how the definition of being "on the market" is evolving. The episode also explores whether the industry can move past moral arguments and accept these changes as business decisions.

• Zillow's move into previews

  • Zillow entering "coming soon" listings is framed as solving a distribution problem rather than a full strategic reversal.

  • Signals frustration with slow-moving MLS rules and lack of standardization.

• Shift from moral debate to business reality

  • Industry discussion may move away from "consumer harm" arguments toward competitive strategy and market positioning.

  • All players (Zillow, Redfin, Compass) are acting in their own business interests.

• Fragmentation vs. consumer behavior

  • Concern about a "streaming wars" future where buyers check multiple platforms.

  • In practice, buyers may already be using several apps simultaneously.

• Branding matters

  • Zillow's "Previews" is positioned as a clear, consumer-friendly product.

  • Competing offerings are less clearly defined or branded.

• MLS pressure and listing input risk

  • Portals accepting direct listing input (outside MLS) is a major long-term threat to MLS control.

• Changing definition of "on market"

  • Debate over whether "on market" means:

    • In the MLS

    • Under a listing agreement

    • Visible on portals like Zillow

  • Indicates a broader shift in how the industry conceptualizes market exposure.

• Impact on brokerage strategies

  • Exclusive vs. non-exclusive distribution (e.g., Compass vs. eXp) may influence listing pitches.

  • Market will determine whether sellers value broader distribution or platform-specific exposure.

Connect with Rob and Greg

Rob's Website

Greg's Website

Watch us on YouTube

Our Sponsors:

Cotality

Notorious VIP

The Giant Steps Job Board

Production and Editing Services by Sunbound Studios

The Industry Relations Podcast is now available on your favorite podcast player!

This episode features Andy Woolley (Homes.com) joining Rob and Greg to break down a wave of rapid industry changes driven by new agreements between Zillow, Compass, Redfin, and eXp. The conversation focuses on exclusive vs. non-exclusive listing deals, the rise of pre-marketing strategies, and the increasing fragmentation of listing distribution. Together, they examine how these shifts challenge the traditional role of the MLS as a broker cooperative, with ongoing debate about whether the industry is moving toward a more fragmented, lead-generation-driven ecosystem.

• New exclusive and non-exclusive listing agreements are accelerating fragmentation in listing distribution.

• Debate continues over whether these moves resemble competition or anti-competitive behavior.

• Pre-marketing ("coming soon") listings are a key battleground for platforms seeking inventory outside IDX feeds.

• MLSs face pressure as the industry questions whether they are cooperatives or listing platforms.

• Much of the conflict is centered on control of lead generation rather than access to listings.

• Homes.com is pursuing brokerage feeds to capture pre-marketing listings, while Zillow is incentivizing participation through its Preview product.

• Agents use pre-marketing to control pricing strategy, days on market, and demand signals.

• Ongoing debate between "your listing, your lead" vs. referral-based models.

• Larger platforms and brokerages with data/control advantages are positioned to benefit most.

• Rob's webinar - The Agency-Centered MLS: A Framework for Survival

• MLS Reset Registration
  
  
• Homes.com expands early access to pre-market listings
  
  
• Where brokerages stand on pre-MLS listings after a whirlwind week
• Zillow's 'simplified' listing standars make MLS optional

• Andy Woolley roast video of Greg at CMLS

Connect with Rob and Greg

Rob's Website

Greg's Website

Watch us on YouTube

Our Sponsors:

Cotality

Notorious VIP

The Giant Steps Job Board

Production and Editing Services by Sunbound Studios

The Industry Relations Podcast is now available on your favorite podcast player!

Rob and Greg discuss the implications of Howard Hanna's "Hanna List" and whether private listing strategies represent a broader shift in real estate brokerage competition. The conversation centers on whether these moves signal an industry-wide trend toward consolidation or whether they are simply outliers driven by unique companies with large market share. They also debate the strategic motivations behind Compass's acquisition of Anywhere, the role of private listing networks in recruiting and retention, and whether smaller brokerages can compete if large firms leverage exclusive inventory to attract agents.

• Greg criticizes the "Hanna List" branding and argues Howard Hanna's strategy may not be representative of broader industry trends because of its unique market dominance.

• Rob suggests the Compass–Anywhere deal could trigger consolidation, noting that Compass now dwarfs competitors in scale.

• Greg argues competitors may take a wait-and-see approach, questioning whether Compass can successfully execute its strategy and integrate multiple brands.

• The hosts discuss whether private listing networks are primarily about recruiting advantage rather than consumer strategy.

• Rob argues that controlling listing inventory can translate into recruiting leverage and potentially reshape brokerage competition.

• Greg counters that many agents prioritize culture, independence, and commission structure, meaning scale alone may not determine recruiting outcomes.

• They conclude that whether private listings trigger widespread consolidation will depend on consumer demand, execution by large brokerages, and regulatory responses.

Connect with Rob and Greg

Rob's Website

Greg's Website

Watch us on YouTube

Our Sponsors:

Cotality

Notorious VIP

The Giant Steps Job Board

Production and Editing Services by Sunbound Studios

The Industry Relations Podcast is now available on your favorite podcast player!

Rob Hahn and Greg Robertson discuss their experience attending the NAR Influencer Summit in Chicago, where they met with NAR leadership and staff to hear about the organization's strategic direction and turnaround plan. The conversation covers leadership changes, cost-cutting efforts, and the broader challenges facing the National Association of Realtors. Rob argues that the organization faces deeper structural problems—particularly around its value proposition and governance—while Greg is cautiously optimistic that new leadership could help move the industry forward. The episode also explores NAR's relationship with MLS organizations, the difficulty associations face in "de-risking" from MLS dependence, and the need to identify services members are actually willing to pay for.

• Rob and Greg attended the NAR Influencer Summit in Chicago, where leadership presented their strategic plan and invited questions from attendees.

• NAR leadership highlighted cost-cutting measures, including staff reductions of roughly 14–20%, as part of broader turnaround efforts.

• Rob says meeting CEO Nykia Wright in person changed his impression, noting her stronger presence and leadership than he expected.

• The hosts debate whether NAR's challenges are incremental problems or a deeper structural crisis tied to governance and leadership dynamics.

• A central issue discussed is NAR's value proposition—particularly whether agents would voluntarily pay to join if MLS access and other structural ties changed.

• Lobbying remains one of the strongest arguments for NAR's value, though Rob argues it suffers from a "free rider" problem where non-members benefit as well.

• Greg raises concerns about how local associations can reduce reliance on MLS revenue without clear alternative funding models.

• Both hosts discuss the role of volunteer leadership in shaping strategy and whether structural reforms may be needed to move the organization forward.

• The episode ends with a debate about NAR's stated goal of advancing Americans' ability to own real estate and what policy implications that might carry.

Connect with Rob and Greg

Rob's Website

Greg's Website

Watch us on YouTube

Our Sponsors:

Cotality

Notorious VIP

The Giant Steps Job Board

Production and Editing Services by Sunbound Studios

The Industry Relations Podcast is now available on your favorite podcast player!

Rob and Greg discuss the implications of a new deal between Compass and Redfin that allows Compass listings to appear on Redfin without traditional listing metrics like days on market or price change history. The conversation explores how this partnership could reshape the competitive landscape among major real estate portals and accelerate the normalization of private or exclusive listings. They also debate whether private listings harm transparency or fairness in the housing market, including a heated discussion around claims that such practices impact fair housing. The episode also examines how shifting alliances between portals like Zillow, Redfin, and Homes.com could affect MLSs and industry norms. Toward the end, the conversation broadens to macro trends including AI's potential impact on white-collar jobs, the future of real estate search, and how economic disruption could influence housing markets in the coming years.

• Compass and Redfin reached a deal allowing Compass listings to appear on Redfin without showing days on market or price change history.

• The move represents a major shift in portal alliances, potentially weakening the previous alignment between Zillow and Redfin.

• Private listings may become more normalized as brokers and MLSs respond to changing portal strategies.

• Rob argues that fair housing concerns around private listings are often overstated and distract from the real business debate.

• Greg suggests the practical impact may be limited if most listings ultimately still end up on MLS systems.

• Future home search may shift from portals to AI assistants that aggregate listings across multiple sources.

• The hosts discuss the broader economic implications of AI potentially replacing large numbers of white-collar jobs and how that could affect housing demand.

Links

Concerns Over Harmful Private Listing Networks Explained by NAEBA (The National Association of Exclusive Buyer Agents)

Connect with Rob and Greg

Rob's Website

Greg's Website

Watch us on YouTube

Our Sponsors:

Cotality

Notorious VIP

The Giant Steps Job Board

Production and Editing Services by Sunbound Studios

DISCLAIMER: Greg & Rob may have business relationships with one or more of the companies discussed.

The Industry Relations Podcast is now available on your favorite podcast player!

Rob and Greg discuss MLS autonomy and whether smaller organizations are truly positioned to handle independence from NAR. They examine legal exposure, slow consolidation, and the financial vulnerability of small MLSs. The conversation shifts to AI—highlighting Homes.com's new voice search experience—and what rapid innovation means for brokers, MLSs, infrastructure, and data access moving forward.

• MLS consolidation is happening slowly, but smaller MLSs may face increasing legal and financial risk.

• Independence removes guardrails and shifts more responsibility onto local leadership.

• AI-powered search is advancing quickly, raising questions about cost, infrastructure, and long-term sustainability.

• Agents will soon demand MLS data access for personal AI tools, and most MLSs aren't prepared for that shift.

• Over-regulation—whether in housing, energy, or MLS governance—can slow innovation and adaptation.

Connect with Rob and Greg

Rob's Website

Greg's Website

Watch us on YouTube

Our Sponsors:

Cotality

Notorious VIP

The Giant Steps Job Board

Production and Editing Services by Sunbound Studios