❗️How does a devoted young father vanish during a duck hunting trip—only for the truth to surface 17 years later as a cold-blooded murder plot? The disappearance of Mike Williams is one of Florida’s most haunting true crime stories.

🔍 In this gripping episode, Joseph Lobosco and Adrienne Barker revisit the case of Mike Williams, who vanished in December 2000 while duck hunting on Lake Seminole near Tallahassee. At first, authorities believed he had drowned, his body supposedly consumed by alligators. But the persistence of Mike’s mother, Cheryl Williams, and years of unanswered questions revealed something far darker.

Live from Chatter Social, we explore:

🦆 Why police clung to the “alligator accident” theory despite glaring inconsistencies

💔 How Denise Williams, Mike’s wife, quickly collected life insurance and moved on with his best friend

🔫 The shocking confession from Brian Winchester that exposed a conspiracy of love, betrayal, and greed

⚖️ Denise Williams’ trial, conviction for murder and conspiracy, and the legal twists that followed

🕊 The relentless pursuit of truth by Cheryl Williams, who refused to stop fighting for justice

🧠 KEY TAKEAWAYS:

🕯 Mike Williams’ disappearance was staged—it was murder, not accident

🚨 Denise Williams and Brian Winchester plotted his death for money and a life together

📢 Brian confessed years later, leading to the discovery of Mike’s remains

💡 A mother’s persistence forced investigators to reopen the case and expose the lies

👥 Audience Contributors:

Mariana, Debbie

🙏 Special Thanks To:

🎤 The Debate the News team for supporting this independent true crime spin-off

💬 Our live contributors on Chatter Social for their thoughtful questions and emotional reflections

🕯 And to Mike Williams—your story is remembered, and your mother’s fight for justice inspires us all

💬 Join us live every Tuesday & Thursday at 7:00 PM ET on Chatter Social

📢 Disclaimer:

This podcast episode is for informational and discussion purposes only. The hosts and guests are not attorneys or law enforcement. All individuals named who have not been convicted of a crime are considered innocent until proven guilty. Any opinions shared are those of the individual speaker and do not represent the views of Debate the News or its affiliates.

Due to the disturbing nature of the crimes discussed—including themes of betrayal, conspiracy, and murder—listener discretion is advised.

Follow Debate the News: True Crime and never miss the next chilling case.

Theme Song: Alaina Cross - Karma [NCS Release]

Music provided by NoCopyrightSounds

Free Download/Stream: http://ncs.io/karma

Watch: http://ncs.lnk.to/karmaAT/youtube

#MikeWilliams #TrueCrimePodcast #FloridaCases #JusticeForMikeWilliams #DebateTheNews