“Journalist Haygood tells a story of perseverance, courage, and breathtaking talent as he recounts, in vibrant detail, the achievements of the Tigers, a basketball and baseball team at Columbus, Ohio’s inner-city East High School.... [The] author creates moving portraits of the teenagers and their undaunted coaches and supporters.... Haygood dramatically renders the heady excitement of each game, the tense moments of a close contest, and the exuberant - tear-jerking - wins. The inspiring story of East High’s championship becomes even more astonishing in the context of endemic racism, which the author closely examines, and 'the turmoil of a nation at war and in the midst of unrest', roiled by the assassinations of Martin Luther King Jr. and Robert Kennedy. An engrossing tale of one shining moment in dark times.” (Kirkus, starred review)

“As in all his avidly read books, Haygood sets the stories of fascinating individuals within the context of freshly reclaimed and vigorously recounted African American history as he masterfully brings a high school and its community to life. This laugh-and-cry tale of rollicking and wrenching drama set to the beat of thumping basketballs and the crack of baseball bats, fast breaks and cheerleaders’ chants, is electric with tension and conviction, and incandescent with unity and hope.” (Booklist, starred review) 

“Mr. Haygood executes a series of historical fadeaway jump shots, taking us back for extended interludes with the likes of Rev. King, Jackie Robinson, federal Judge Bobby Duncan, and other civil rights catalysts...the interludes illustrate the forward leaps, staggering setbacks, and relentlessly hard work toward equality in America.... And then we’re off on a classic sports story, as the school’s basketball and baseball players take form and the teams clamber to improbable heights. Naturally, Mr. Haygood explores the forces that shaped the young men, almost all of whom grew up in fatherless families with working mothers who struggled to feed and clothe them. Like J. Anthony Lukas’ Pulitzer Prize-winning 1985 book, Common Ground - also focused on school segregation - there’s complexity and ambiguity throughout.” (Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)