In the summer of 1932, the body of Mamie Thurman was found brutally murdered on Trace Mountain in Logan County, West Virginia. Her throat had been slit, her head beaten, and her body unceremoniously dumped off the hillside, her wedding ring still on her finger.

Mamie wasn’t just any woman in the coalfields. A 31-year-old churchgoer, socialite, and wife of a respected patrolman, she was known for her charm, her beauty, and her ability to float between the strict expectations of Logan society and the nightlife scene that simmered just beneath its surface. But as rumors of affairs, corruption, and bootlegging started swirling, her murder exposed more than just a killer, it exposed the moral double life of an entire town.

So who killed Mamie Thurman? And why?

In this episode, we explore the tangled web of suspects: from the handyman who went to prison for her murder, to a prominent judge, to whispers of a powerful cover-up that still echo in Logan County to this day. We unpack theories, evidence, trial transcripts, and interviews to piece together the real story of what happened that night on the mountain.

Nearly a century later, her ghost is said to still roam the hills. But the real haunting part? The fact that her case has never been fully solved.

#MamieThurman #Creepalachia #UnsolvedMysteries #WVTrueCrime #WestVirginiaHistory #LoganCountyWV #HauntedAppalachia #GhostStories #WomenOfAppalachia #ColdCaseFiles #1930sMurder #CoalfieldsCrime #SouthernGothic #TrueCrimePodcast

Like this video, subscribe to Creepalachia, and comment your experience below!

Review the Podcast on Spotify and Apple Podcasts

Follow Our Things! https://linktr.ee/Creepalachia

Merch! https://creepalachia.shop/

Website! https://creepalachia.tv/

Other Interviews - https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLxM_meUps8eNIjb64yLAS3Z2N9YRDUGMz&si=pQEw9jDJAP_Z4_95

True Crime - https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLxM_meUps8eNql44CayXCCBsW-6zIeWsA&si=3teIk_jc4MrmsUUe

Solo Stories - https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLxM_meUps8eOSFgB6XFmefueia2ZvRc4G&si=1wL1ft-UVhM_PiAN

Mysteries - https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLxM_meUps8eN0mOcv-OBjI1MqeQgoMi9W&si=wA7zLRkT5MiUQIlC

Hauntings - https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLxM_meUps8ePTwq7hLiYjlzSs-UqWtrfp&si=ddRW_lx1pXQrxLUC

Creepalachia was started and will remain as a show diving into the dark, strange, unknown, tragic, and heroic stories of J.D. 's homeland. These hills have stories. LONG LIVE APPALACHIA!

Disclaimer:

The stories, views, and opinions shared by guests on Creepalachia are solely those of the individuals speaking and do not necessarily reflect the views of the host or the show. Creepalachia does not guarantee the accuracy or completeness of guest statements and is not responsible for any errors, omissions, or outcomes related to their content. All discussions are presented for storytelling, educational, and entertainment purposes only. Viewers are encouraged to research and form their own conclusions.

Support the show

Are you an Appalachian with a creepy experience to tell? Email us at creepalachia@gmail.com and tell us all about it. We could possibly get you on the show!