A skeptical professor, a brooding estate, and a family who won’t let go—Haunted (1995) promises classic chills but delivers something stranger: a Gothic romance in ghost story clothes. We unpack why the movie looks older than its year, how the narration flattens tension, and where the tone drifts from eerie to oddly cozy. From fog-drenched train platforms to self-playing pianos and that not-so-subtle painting, the film throws every haunted-house trope on the table, then blurs the rules of the afterlife until the logic starts to wobble. If a ghost can drive a car, ride a horse, and charm a skeptic, what’s left to fear?

We dive into what could have worked—reframing the story through Nanny Tess’s eyes, dialing down the lighting and the score, and letting ambiguity do the heavy lifting. The source novel points to a sharper version with murkier motives and a lead whose unreliability could have turned every scene into a question mark. Instead, we get woodwinds where we wanted dread, romance where we needed restraint, and a twist you’ll likely call before the hour mark. Still, there’s a reason we kept watching: the manor has presence, Beckinsale and Quinn hold the screen, and a handful of set pieces hint at a better, darker film buried just beneath the surface.

We compare Haunted to The Others and Flowers in the Attic, explore why certain effects break immersion, and debate the ethics and impact of the film’s big choices. If you love haunted-house cinema, there’s enough here to study and argue about—even if the scares never quite land. Press play, then tell us: does tone matter more than twist?

Enjoy the episode? Follow us on Instagram at ScreamStream Pod, visit screamsandstreams.com for episode notes and our watchability scale, and please rate, review, and subscribe. Got a 90s horror gem we should cover next? Send it our way.

Head to www.screamsandstreams.com for more information related to our episode.