The Ghost Town That Wasn’t: The Curious History of Old Jefferson Below Percy Priest Lake… The tranquil waters of Percy Priest Lake, a beloved recreational area near Nashville, hold a fascinating and somewhat paradoxical secret beneath their surface – or rather, not beneath their surface. The story of Old Jefferson, a town once destined to be submerged by the lake’s creation, is a tale of early ambition, a significant historical role, and a surprising twist of fate that left it as a “ghost town” razed by human hand, not by water.. A Frontier Hub and County Seat:.. Long before the idea of a dam on the Stones River even existed, the town of Jefferson was founded in 1802 or early 1803 at a strategic fork in the Stones River. It quickly became a vital hub in the burgeoning frontier. In fact, Jefferson was the very first county seat of Rutherford County, a testament to its early importance as a center for government and commerce. The town envisioned itself as a bustling inland port, connecting with the wider world via the mighty Mississippi River.. Jefferson’s early years saw the establishment of a public square, taverns that doubled as hotels for travelers, and various craftsmen and businesses. Crops like cotton, corn, and tobacco, along with red cedar, were shipped by the thousands of tons from Jefferson, reaching ports as far away as New Orleans and Pittsburg. This period cemented Old Jefferson’s place in the early economic development of Middle Tennessee. It also holds a somber historical significance as a route for several detachments of Cherokee during the forced removal known as the Trail of Tears in 1838.. However, despite its promising start, Jefferson’s prominence as the county seat was short-lived. In 1811, the county seat was relocated to Murfreesboro, and Old Jefferson gradually evolved into a quieter farming village, though it maintained a strong sense of community and history for its residents.. The Dam’s Shadow: A Town Doomed… Or Was It? Fast forward to the mid-20th century. As plans for the J. Percy Priest Dam and Reservoir took shape, the fate of Old Jefferson became intertwined with the ambitious flood control project. Engineers calculated that the rising waters of the Stones River, once impounded by the dam, would completely inundate the town. Residents were informed that their homes and farms would be lost to the lake. Through eminent domain, the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers acquired the land that comprised Old Jefferson. In preparation for the impending flood, the town was systematically dismantled. Houses were required to be moved, and if not, they were sold with the stipulation that the buyer move them, or simply burned to the ground. Buildings were bulldozed, and the once-thriving community was razed, leaving little trace of its historical structures. This occurred in the early to mid-1960s, a heartbreaking period for the long-time residents forced to leave their ancestral lands.. The Unforeseen Twist:.. A Dry Ghost Town But here’s where the story takes an unexpected turn. When Percy Priest Lake began to fill in 1968, engineers made a critical miscalculation. The water levels never reached as high as projected, largely due to unforeseen underground cave systems that absorbed and diverted the water. The land where Old Jefferson once stood remained largely above water.. Instead of becoming an underwater Atlantis, Old Jefferson became a ghost town not submerged by water, but by human demolition. The vibrant community, with its historic buildings and rich past, was intentionally destroyed for a flood that never reached it.. A Lingering Presence:.. Today, the site of Old Jefferson is a poignant reminder of this curious history. While no structures remain, the land itself is accessible to those who know where to look. History enthusiasts and former residents can still trace the faint outlines of old roads and envision where buildings once stood. The area is now part of the land managed by the U.S.