Peter and Andrew dig into You Can See Everything, the documentary directed by Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim, which follows Theranos founder Elizabeth Holmes right before she heads to prison. The hosts wonder why Holmes and her partner Billy Evans ever let Fielder into their home in the first place, especially given his reputation for weaponizing deadpan silences and brutally blunt questions. Rather than feeling like a typical true-crime profile, the opening stretch plays out like a tense mental boxing match between Holmes and Fielder, where both refuse to break character while parsing through technical half-truths, legal semantics, and what it actually means to lie.

The conversation then turns to the film's wild mid-movie pivot: bringing in Amanda Seyfried, who famously played Holmes in The Dropout. Seyfried comes in as a breath of fresh air and an audience surrogate, offering genuine emotion and even clashing with Billy on camera, before the film veers into full-blown reenactments of scenes the crew couldn't shoot. Peter and Andrew praise how unpredictable and thrilling the nearly three-hour film feels, noting that by the time Fielder and Seyfried are running lines by a fireplace at the end, the line between reality, rehearsal, and pure performance has completely dissolved.