Whitewater, Wisconsin, has a reputation for witch legends, spiritualism and haunted places. Among its most recognizable landmarks is the Hamilton House, a Victorian mansion with a history stretching back to 1861 and ghost stories that have followed it for generations.

But what was it like to actually live there?

In episode six of Weird Wisconsin, the first installment of Wisconsin's Most Haunted, I explore the history and reported hauntings of this 23-room house through someone who called it home.

DJ Phoenix lived in the Hamilton House from 1974 to 1983 while his family operated an antique business downstairs. He recalls unexplained activity throughout the house, a boy who appeared in his bedroom, a doll whose eyes seemed to glow red, and a photograph he believes captured two spirits. He also shares the increasingly troubling experiences that ultimately led his family to leave.

Carol Cartwright, president of the Whitewater Historical Society, provides the historical perspective. She traces the house's owners, explains how Whitewater's spiritualist history became entangled with its witch legends, and examines claims of secret tunnels connected to the Underground Railroad.

Some details have historical support. Others remain unverified. Together, these accounts explore the history, folklore and deeply personal experiences behind one of Whitewater's best-known haunted houses.

🎧 Listen everywhere

Follow Weird Wisconsin:
Facebook
Instagram
TikTok
YouTube

Featured in This Episode:
DJ Phoenix
Antique dealer, toy collector and former Hamilton House resident
Website

Carol Cartwright
President, Whitewater Historical Society
Website

Episode Artwork by Rachal Duggan
Instagram
Website

Original Theme by Tyler Quinn
Website

Welcome back to This Week in Weird Wisconsin, a weekly mini episode highlighting the people, places, and events that happened during this week in Wisconsin history.

This week, Wisconsin shuts down public gathering places during the 1918 influenza pandemic, and exactly 39 years later Milwaukee celebrates a World Series championship. We'll also revisit the bizarre Eagle Diamond case, where a woman sold a stone for $1 only to discover it was one of the largest diamonds ever found in America.

And finally, we head to Milwaukee in 1912, where Theodore Roosevelt is shot in the chest before a campaign speech and decides to speak for roughly 80 minutes anyway.

Explore this week's event:

Halloween Legends & Lore at Old World Wisconsin
Tickets

🎧 Listen everywhere

Follow Weird Wisconsin:
Facebook
Instagram
TikTok

Original Theme by Tyler Quinn
Website

Welcome back to This Week in Weird Wisconsin, a weekly mini episode highlighting the people, places, and events that happened during this week in Wisconsin history.

This week, we dig into the bizarre early history of Bucky Badger, including the live badger that kept escaping and a raccoon named Regdab that somehow became part of the mascot story. We'll also revisit a major 1962 civil rights protest in Madison, the 1912 American Grand Prix raced on public roads around Milwaukee, the flood that nearly erased downtown Black River Falls, and the Milwaukee Police Band's unlikely path from whistling officers to performing with John Philip Sousa.

And finally, we look back at the Peshtigo Fire of October 8, 1871, the deadliest wildfire in American history.

Explore this week's events:

Spiritualism in the Victorian Era at Black Point Estate
October 2 in Lake Geneva

Bayfield Apple Festival
October 2–4 in Bayfield

🎧 Listen everywhere

Follow Weird Wisconsin:
Facebook
Instagram
TikTok

Original Theme by Tyler Quinn
Website

Welcome back to This Week in Weird Wisconsin, a weekly mini episode highlighting the people, places, and events that happened during this week in Wisconsin history.

This week, Manitowoc holds an actual funeral for a steamship, Wisconsin's most famous Civil War eagle gets honored at the 1876 Centennial Exhibition, and the very first Smokey Bear costume makes its public debut in Wausau.

We'll also revisit the first regular-season game played at what became Lambeau Field, the Treaty of La Pointe, and Wisconsin's very first State Fair—where one of the biggest attractions was a 200-pound squash.

And if that somehow isn't weird enough, Mount Horeb is also preparing to burn a giant troll.

Explore this week's event:

Burning Troll
September 26 near Mount Horeb

🎧 Listen everywhere

Follow Weird Wisconsin:
Facebook
Instagram
TikTok

Original Theme by Tyler Quinn
Instagram

Welcome back to This Week in Weird Wisconsin, a weekly mini episode highlighting the people, places, and events that happened during this week in Wisconsin history.

This week, we dive into three Lake Michigan disasters, including a shipwreck still carrying its iron ore and a schooner that floated upside down for nearly two weeks. We'll also revisit one of Green Bay's largest fires, the recovery of a 3,000-year-old canoe from Lake Mendota, and one of the darkest cases in Wisconsin conservation warden history.

Thankfully, we'll balance all of that out with three days devoted entirely to cheese—and a parade led by actual cows.

Explore this week's event:

Green County Cheese Days
September 18–20 in Monroe

🎧 Listen everywhere

Follow Weird Wisconsin:
Facebook
Instagram
TikTok

Original Theme by Tyler Quinn
Instagram

For more than 150 years, a 1,600-pound piece of Ireland has been sitting in the foundation of Saint Bernard's Church in Watertown, Wisconsin.

The stone came from the Rock of Cashel, one of Ireland's most famous historic sites. According to legend, the rock was created when Saint Patrick banished the devil from a nearby mountain. While escaping, the devil transformed into a winged giant, bit off part of the mountaintop, broke his teeth and spat the rock ten miles across Ireland.

But how did a piece of that rock end up in Wisconsin?

In this episode, we trace the stone's journey from Ireland to Watertown. Its story involves a Civil War chaplain, a collapsed medieval tower, a debate in British Parliament and a three-month journey across the Atlantic.

When the stone was finally placed into the church's foundation in 1873, as many as 10,000 people gathered to witness it. Then, somewhere along the way, almost everyone forgot it was there.

With help from Irish historian Dr. Thomas Patrick Nelligan and Marquette University historian Dr. Timothy McMahon, we uncover the history, folklore and nearly forgotten meaning behind Wisconsin's stone from the devil's mouth.

🎧 Listen everywhere

Follow Weird Wisconsin:
Facebook
Instagram
TikTok

Learn More:

The Standing Stone with Dr. Thomas Patrick Nelligan
Website

Dr. Timothy G. McMahon
Marquette University

Rock of Cashel
📍Cashel, County Tipperary, Ireland
Visitor Information

Saint Bernard's Church
📍Watertown, Wisconsin
Website

Episode Artwork by Rachal Duggan
Instagram
Website

Original Theme by Tyler Quinn
Website

If you enjoyed this episode, follow the Weird Wisconsin Podcast on your favorite podcast app, leave a rating or review, and share it with someone who loves Wisconsin history, mysteries and folklore.

Welcome back to This Week in Weird Wisconsin, a weekly mini episode highlighting the people, places, and events that happened during this week in Wisconsin history.

This week, we uncover how the remnants of the deadly Galveston hurricane reached Wisconsin, look back at the first automobile race at the Milwaukee Mile, do some goat yoga at a historic stagecoach stop, explore a piece of medieval Ireland hidden in Watertown, and dive into two recently recognized Door County shipwrecks. We'll also revisit John Muir's Wisconsin roots and one of the state's forgotten aviation pioneers.

Along the way, I'll also point you toward a few places and events where you can experience these stories for yourself.

Explore this week's events:

Goat Yoga at Wade House
https://calendar.wisconsinhistory.org/events/month/2026-09/

Wisconsin's John Muir Exhibit
https://calendar.wisconsinhistory.org/events/month/2026-09/

Stone Age Astronaut Book Launch at Boswell Book Company
https://calendar.wisconsinhistory.org/events/month/2026-09/

🎧 Listen everywhere

Follow Weird Wisconsin:
Facebook
Instagram
TikTok

Original Theme by Tyler Quinn
Instagram