Send us Fan Mail

A brilliant linguist. A suspected poisoner. A killer whose crimes shocked 1800s New York.

Edward Rulloff was considered one of the most intelligent criminals of his era — fluent in multiple languages, studied by phrenologists, and defended even by Mark Twain. But behind the intellect was a trail of missing family members, robbery, murder, and one of the strangest executions in American history.

Did he dump his wife and daughter into Cayuga Lake forever hiding the truth beneath the Finger Lakes waters? And could the lake itself still be hiding secrets today?

Dive into the bizarre true story of Edward Rulloff, the missing women of Cayuga Lake, and the legend of Old Greeny.

Support the show

Instagram @vintagehomicidepodcast
Facebook Vintage Homicide Podcast
https://www.buymeacoffee.com/lachesis19v
email vintagehomicidepodcast@gmail.com
website https://vintagehomicide.buzzsprout.com

Send us Fan Mail

A newlywed found murdered. No weapon. No witnesses. No motive.

In 1968, 20-year-old Claire Josephs was brutally killed in her home in Bromley, England. What followed would change criminal justice forever.

With nothing but blood typing, fiber analysis, and emerging forensic science, investigators built a case against Roger Payne—marking the first murder conviction in England based solely on forensic evidence.

But decades later, after appeals, an escape, and a new identity… questions still linger.

Did science get it right—or was there more to the story?

Support the show

Instagram @vintagehomicidepodcast
Facebook Vintage Homicide Podcast
https://www.buymeacoffee.com/lachesis19v
email vintagehomicidepodcast@gmail.com
website https://vintagehomicide.buzzsprout.com

Send us Fan Mail

Blood, betrayal, and a mystery that still refuses to die…

Who really orchestrated the infamous St. Valentine’s Day Massacre?

Was it Al Capone pulling the strings from afar… or was his ruthless enforcer Jack McGurn the true mastermind?

From attempted hits and mob revenge to “blonde alibis” and courtroom loopholes, the story only gets darker. Gunmen vanish. Witnesses recant. Suspects turn up dead—one by one.

And just when it seems like the truth might surface… it disappears again.

💀 A massacre with no convictions
💀 A list of suspects who met violent ends
💀 Confessions that only raise more questions

Even decades later, we’re still left asking:
Did justice ever stand a chance in a world ruled by silence and bullets?

Support the show

Instagram @vintagehomicidepodcast
Facebook Vintage Homicide Podcast
https://www.buymeacoffee.com/lachesis19v
email vintagehomicidepodcast@gmail.com
website https://vintagehomicide.buzzsprout.com