From the lights of Broadway to the wooded roads of upstate New York, eight unusual reports take us into the Empire State’s unexplained side.

In this episode of Phantoms & Monster Radio, we examine a family account of an alleged wolf-like creature on Broadway in 1911, an upright canine encounter in Sleepy Hollow, a towering horned figure in Freeport, and a tiny fairy-like being near Lake Erie.

We also explore a terrifying Christmas-night roadside encounter, a military veteran’s claims of Sasquatch activity at a nuclear storage area, Dan Aykroyd’s mysterious Manhattan encounter with a black sedan, and an extensive Hartwick report involving a dark flying humanoid, strange calls, and disturbing activity inside a home.

These accounts are presented as reported experiences, recollections, and interpretations, not verified proof of paranormal activity. Where details conflict or evidence is limited, we address those distinctions.

Which report do you find most compelling? Have you experienced something unexplained in New York? Share your account in the comments, including the approximate location and date, while respecting everyone’s privacy.

Subscribe to Phantoms & Monster Radio for more witness accounts, cryptid reports, and unexplained encounters.

👤 I'm Lon Strickler, creator of Phantoms & Monsters, and I’ve been a paranormal researcher and intuitive investigator for almost 50 years. My work has appeared on numerous television shows, including Ancient Aliens, Paranormal Witness, Monsters and Mysteries in America, and Unsolved Mysteries, as well as radio shows such as Coast to Coast AM.