What separates a masterpiece from mere entertainment? In this episode of The TAC Podcast, we move beyond film criticism to explore the "first principles" of cinema.

Drawing on the insights of Aristotle, Aquinas, and contemporary thinkers, we discuss whether film truly "imitates nature" and what it means to make the invisible visible on screen. We dive into the ethics of storytelling, the difference between art and propaganda, and the paradoxical necessity of stories being both "surprising and inevitable."

Whether you're a filmmaker, a cinephile, or someone interested in the intersection of faith and art, join us for a deep dive into the soul of cinema.

In this episode, we discuss:

The nature of contemplation in a digital age.

Why "bad movies" often feel like commercials.

The role of human action and "the promise" in storytelling.

A philosophical defense of bleak masterpieces like No Country for Old Men.

Whether "Christian Film" is a coherent artistic category.

Chapters

00:00 - Introduction: Why talk about film?

02:15 - Art vs. Work: The nature of contemplation

05:03 - What makes a movie "bad"?

06:43 - Art, prayer, and the perversion of manipulation

09:13 - The first principles of cinema

10:05 - Does art imitate reality?

12:21 - The artist's role: Making the invisible visible

16:46 - Revealing the meaning in humble realities

21:00 - Respecting the medium of film

26:10 - The Pixar framework: "Surprising and Inevitable"

31:00 - The juxtaposition of images

36:08 - Can a "bad person" make great art?

41:00 - The philosophy of No Country for Old Men

48:40 - Defending the hero of the story

50:50 - Is there such a thing as "Catholic Film"?

54:00 - Can you evangelize through art?

01:02:04 - Why movies are miracles

01:04:30 – Conclusion

What does it mean to teach?

Can knowledge truly be transferred from one person to another, or must every student ultimately learn for himself? In this episode of The TAC Podcast, John Finley and Chris Decaen explore St. Thomas Aquinas's On the Teacher (De Magistro), one of the most profound reflections ever written on education, learning, and the life of the mind. Drawing from Aquinas's Disputed Questions on Truth, they examine whether human beings can genuinely be called teachers, how knowledge is acquired, why learning requires the active participation of the student, and what separates education from the mere transmission of information.

Along the way, they discuss:

• Can anyone actually teach you anything?

• Why learning cannot be forced

• The relationship between teachers, students, and truth

• Whether we can teach ourselves

• Why great teaching resembles guidance more than information transfer

• The connection between education, virtue, and human flourishing

• Aquinas's surprising account of angelic teaching

• Whether teaching belongs to the contemplative or active life

At a time when information is everywhere and artificial intelligence can answer nearly any question, Aquinas offers a timeless reminder: education is about more than information. It is about the formation of the human person and the pursuit of truth.

Learn more about Thomas Aquinas College at https://www.thomasaquinas.edu #Aquinas #Education #Teaching #Learning #Philosophy #GreatBooks #CatholicEducation #ThomasAquinas #ClassicalEducation #TheTACPodcast ___________________________________________________________________

00:00 - Introduction to Aquinas's On the Teacher

01:35 - The Disputed Questions vs. the Summa Theologiae

03:05 - Overview of the Four Articles on Teaching

03:40 - Article 1: Can a Human Truly Be a Teacher?

05:00 - Is God the Only Real Teacher?

08:55 - The Teacher-Student Dynamic: Pushing vs. Being Pushed

11:40 - Three Issues of Opinion: Existence, Virtue, and Knowledge

17:30 - Two Extremes of Moral Virtue Acquisition

22:20 - How Knowledge Comes to Be: Building on First Principles

27:00 - The Unity of Soul and Body in Learning

30:50 - The Teacher as a Guide and Instruction Giver

35:35 - The Medical Analogy: Doctors, Patients, and Nature

42:25 - Learning as a Recipient of a Gift

46:40 - Article 4: Is Teaching a Contemplative or Active Work?

51:50 - Article 3: Can Angels Teach Humans?

56:10 - How Angels Interact with Human Imagination and Light

1:00:30 - Closing Thoughts

Shakespeare's sonnets have captivated readers for more than 400 years. But what makes them some of the greatest poems ever written?

In this episode of The TAC Podcast, John Finley and Chris Decaen take a close look at two of Shakespeare's most celebrated sonnets, Sonnet 18 ("Shall I compare thee to a summer's day?") and Sonnet 29 ("When in disgrace with fortune and men's eyes"), uncovering the remarkable artistry hidden within every line. Together, they explore how Shakespeare uses rhyme, meter, structure, metaphor, and the famous "turn" of the sonnet to reveal profound truths about love, beauty, envy, memory, mortality, and the power of poetry itself. Along the way, they ask why the sonnet became one of history's most enduring literary forms and what these poems continue to teach us about the human person.

Whether you're reading Shakespeare for the first time or returning to him after many years, this conversation offers a fresh appreciation for the extraordinary depth packed into just fourteen lines. In this episode we explore Sonnet 18 and the promise of "eternal summer" Sonnet 29 on envy, love, and gratitude How rhyme, meter, and poetic form create meaning The surprising relationship between art, beauty, and immortality.

Learn more about Thomas Aquinas College at https://www.thomasaquinas.edu

________________________________________________

00:00 - Introduction to Shakespeare's Sonnets and Literary Genre

00:40 - The Structure and Form of a Sonnet (14 Lines, Rhyme Scheme, Iambic Pentameter)

00:53 - Modernity and the Context of Shakespeare's Work

03:05 - Key Elements of Meaning: Meter, Rhyme, and the "Turn"

04:02 - The Challenge of Formal Constraints in Poetry

05:04 - Contrast with Modern Poetry (e.g., T.S. Eliot's "The Waste Land")

05:44 - Analysis of Sonnet 29: "When in disgrace with fortune and men's eyes"

08:06 - The "Turn" and Imagery of the Lark in Sonnet 29

10:19 - Deep Dive into the Language and Meter of Sonnet 29

20:50 - Themes of Memory and Redemption in Sonnet 29

24:48 - Comparing Inward vs. Outward Perspective in the Poem

28:03 - Analysis of Sonnet 18: "Shall I compare thee to a summer's day?"

30:21 - Contrast Between the Temporary Nature of Summer and Eternal Art

33:24 - The Role of the Poet in Preserving the Beloved

39:35 - Chance, Nature, and Human Agency in Sonnet 18

45:10 - The Personification of Death and the Artist's Triumph

54:11 - Defining "Temperate" and Consistency in the Beloved

57:56 - Why the Sonnet is a Unique Literary Genre

01:00:50 - Comparing Sonnets to Soliloquies and Universal Human Thought

01:04:54 - Conclusion and Final Thoughts