Did T.J. repeat as champion? Or is Zack back on top? The guys review their selections for the 2026 WAR Draft.

We hope you’ll consider joining our exclusive Guardians community of fans in our Discord, you’ll get an ADDITIONAL episode per week, all for supporting the show for $5 per month at Patreon.com/SelbyIsGodcast

Zack and T.J. discuss Stephen Vogt reiterating his commitment to staying and winning with Guardians despite challenge of living apart from his family, saying he believes Guards are "close," Carl Willis staying on as pitching coach and the health of José Ramírez entering the offseason.

The second half of our conversation is available at Patreon.com/SelbyIsGodcast

There are many more reflection days ahead, but Zack and T.J. sift through the immediate emotions of the team and themselves following the Guardians getting sent home in the ALCS, dropping Game 6 to the Rays.

We hope you’ll consider joining our exclusive Guardians community of fans in our Discord, you’ll get an ADDITIONAL episode per week, all for supporting the show for $5 per month at Patreon.com/SelbyIsGodcast

Listeners get $20 off their first ticket purchase at SEATGEEK with the promo code: SELBY.

Zack and T.J. discuss the meaningful moments of Game 4 between the Guardians and Rays and look ahead to a best-of-three matchup for a chance to go to the World Series.

We hope you’ll consider joining our exclusive Guardians community of fans in our Discord, you’ll get an ADDITIONAL episode per week, all for supporting the show for $5 per month at Patreon.com/SelbyIsGodcast

Listeners get $20 off their first ticket purchase at SEATGEEK with the promo code: SELBY.

Zack and T.J. react to Petey Halpin's massive 2-run homer that flipped the game after Halpin flipped his bat. The guys discuss the quick hook of Gavin Williams (and why they pulled him when they did), Cade Smith's continued October dominance and how anyone can be a hero in the postseason.

We hope you’ll consider joining our exclusive Guardians community of fans in our Discord, you’ll get an ADDITIONAL episode per week, all for supporting the show for $5 per month at Patreon.com/SelbyIsGodcast

Listeners get $20 off their first ticket purchase at SEATGEEK with the promo code: SELBY.

T.J. and Zack and back to recap Game 1 of the ALCS between the Guardians and Rays. How did Cleveland steal one? And how does the rest of the series unfold from here?

We hope you’ll consider joining our exclusive Guardians community of fans in our Discord, you’ll get an ADDITIONAL episode per week, all for supporting the show for $5 per month at Patreon.com/SelbyIsGodcast

Listeners get $20 off their first ticket purchase at SEATGEEK with the promo code: SELBY.

Zack and T.J. talk about the sights and sounds of the Guardians finishing off their comeback series win over the White Sox in the ALDS to advance to a date with the Tampa Bay Rays in the American League Championship Series. Jose Ramirez and Gavin Williams tossed Cleveland on their backs and carried their club to victory in absolutely legendary performances.

We hope you’ll consider joining our exclusive Guardians community of fans in our Discord, you’ll get an ADDITIONAL episode per week, all for supporting the show for $5 per month at Patreon.com/SelbyIsGodcast

Listeners get $20 off their first ticket purchase at SEATGEEK with the promo code: SELBY.

Zack and T.J. react and recap Game 4 of the ALDS, which saw Cleveland come back to stun the White Sox with a pair of wins in Chicago and force a Game 5 back at Progressive Field on Saturday.We hope you’ll consider joining our exclusive Guardians community of fans in our Discord, you’ll get an ADDITIONAL episode per week, all for supporting the show for $5 per month at Patreon.com/SelbyIsGodcastListeners get $20 off their first ticket purchase at SEATGEEK with the promo code: SELBY.