By election night in 1876, Democrat Samuel Tilden appeared poised to become the next president of the United States. He won the popular vote by over 250,000. Yet the next morning, the New York Times would report that the results were “still uncertain.” And in the end, with all the election interference, Tilden’s opponent, Republican Rutherford B. Hayes, would be declared president instead — by one electoral vote.
Voting rights attorney David F. Walbert and journalist Anoa Changa-Peck explain the charged political climate of the era (this was only a decade after the Civil War, after all), the single telegram that put the election results in question, and the corruption that ultimately made Hayes the victor instead.
Anoa also interviews Jerry Goldfeder, director of the Fordham Law School’s Voting Rights and Democracy Project, to better understand why Democrats never challenged Hayes’ victory in court.
Stealing Elections, American Style is a new podcast that explores the country's history to better understand the biggest challenges facing our democracy today. Gerrymandering, voter suppression, ballot stuffing and straight up stolen elections — this is the story of the past, present, and future of democracy in America.
Subscribe to Stealing Elections, American Style for new episodes each week.
--------------------------------------------------
Key moments:
00:00 Introduction
02:45 The “anger on both sides” after the Civil War
11:18 How the 1876 results were in — before Daniel Sickles interfered
18:38 How railroad bosses corrupted the election
21:00 The “sewing machine scandal” behind Louisiana voter roll purges
24:58 How state canvassing boards in South Carolina and Florida left the count up to chance
32:27 How the 12th Amendment was exploited
38:30 The monied interests of US railroad companies
45:45 How Rutherford B. Hayes ultimately became president
57:06 Why Democrats didn’t challenge Hayes’ victory in court
01:01:30 Who actually won, according to the House of Representatives
01:03:04 Tilden’s final warning
01:05:49 Episode 3 preview
--------------------------------------------------
More about Stealing Elections, American Style: https://stealingelections.us/
Learn more about David Walbert: https://davidfwalbert.com/
See more of Anoa Changa-Peck: @OnTuesdaysWeBuild
This episode was taped at the Dana Fine Arts Building at Agnes Scott College.