In this episode, Karen and Jaime answer the question, “So Whatya Think About The Thursday Murder Club?” This Netflix mystery had Karen rethinking her assumptions about British movies and discovering a possible new favorite genre: feel-good murder mysteries. The hosts talk charming characters, beautiful scenery, a mystery neither of them solved, and the sweet moments that made this one so special. In the second half of the episode, Karen reveals that she almost put up her Christmas tree in September, and Jaime reminisces about their past adventures finding fall. Grab a cup of coffee and get cozy with Karen and Jaime as they welcome the “ber months,” whether you’re ready for fall, Christmas, or a little bit of both!

In Episode 17, Karen and Jaime answer the question, “So Whatya Think About The Fault in Our Stars?” Karen revisits a movie she loved years ago, only to discover that it doesn’t quite hit the same way this time around. The hosts talk about the film’s emotional heaviness, whether it holds up, and how our perspectives on movies – and life – can change as we get older. In the second half of the episode, the conversation takes some unexpected turns, from the mysterious earring back Karen kept stepping on to Jaime’s fascination with the people he encounters at his favorite Circle K. Before long, the hosts find themselves ranking gas stations, discussing magical cleaning robots, and wondering how in the world a QT made it into Scottsdale. Join Jaime and Karen for an episode that hits it all – from cancer and Shakespeare to gas stations and free Slurpees.

Episode 16 has Karen and Jaime answering the question, “So Whatya Think About The Dark Crystal?” Jaime revisits his all-time favorite movie from childhood, while Karen watches it for the very first time and discovers that fantasy might not be her thing. They talk creepy creatures, elaborate puppetry, and the deeper themes hiding beneath this 1982 classic. In the second half of the episode, the hosts reminisce about favorite childhood cereals, Saturday morning cartoons, and Karen’s creative neighborhood business endeavors. Grab a cup of coffee (or a bowl of sugary cereal) and join Jaime and Karen for a trip down memory lane. You may even find yourself back in a sweet recollection of a stress-free childhood Saturday of your own.

In Episode 15, Karen and Jaime answer the question, “So Whatya Think About The Sheep Detectives?” This surprisingly charming whodunnit, streaming on Amazon Prime, had both hosts expecting a silly kids’ movie. Instead, they were won over by its lovable characters, beautiful visuals, and touching story. Hear about their favorite moments and what they thought of the mystery. In the second half of the episode, Karen’s summer comes to a dramatic close as she tackles furniture assembly, cuts the cord with Dish Network, and mounts a new TV on her wall, all by herself. Join Karen and Jaime for a feel-good episode filled with sheep, mysteries, summer projects, and just a touch of “I am woman, hear me roar!”

In episode 14, “So Whatya Think About Inception?”, Jaime and Karen dive into Christopher Nolan’s mind-bending thriller, as Karen admits that it took her quite a while to figure out what was actually happening in the movie. As the hosts untangle dreams within dreams, limbo, and that famous spinning top, they discover that sometimes the things that make a movie frustrating are also what make it so satisfying in the end. In the second half of the episode, the conversation turns to dreams and the fascinating ways our brains remember things. Karen shares some of her unusual – and surprisingly effective – visualization techniques for remembering everything from yarn to bananas. Join Jaime and Karen for a conversation that will have you thinking about dreams, memory, and maybe even what’s happening inside your own brain.

Episode 13 asks the question, “So Whatya Think About Won’t You Be My Neighbor?” Jaime and Karen reflect on the touching documentary about Fred Rogers and discuss the timeless messages of kindness, love, and self-worth that made such a lasting impact on generations of children. The heartfelt conversation has both hosts revisiting some of the film’s most memorable moments – and maybe reaching for a tissue or two. In the second half of the episode, Jaime and Karen reminisce about one of their earliest adventures together, laugh over Karen’s quest to master a harmony part for “Happy Birthday,” and dream up a creative new best friend side hustle.

Episode 12, “So Whatya Think About The Matrix?”, has Jaime introducing Karen to the iconic 1999 action film, The Matrix. After marveling at the fact that Karen had somehow never seen this sci-fi classic, the hosts discuss all things Matrix — from the groundbreaking action sequences and special effects to the mind-bending concept of an alternate reality. In the second half of the episode, their conversation evolves into a discussion about technology and AI, including Jaime’s perspective on using AI at work and Karen’s concern that technology could overtake the human experience. Be sure to listen to the end to find out which pill each host would choose if faced with the red pill vs. blue pill decision.

In Episode 11, Karen responds to Jaime’s dare to find a sappy chick flick for him to watch. She goes all in with an iconic tearjerker, and the two banter back and forth as they answer the question, “So Whatya Think About Steel Magnolias?” You’ll hear the hosts’ perspectives on this beloved 1989 drama and pick up a few fun behind-the-scenes facts about the film. In the second half of the episode, Karen and Jaime discuss all things travel, including the bold choice to wear flip-flops on an airplane, the eternal overpacking conundrum, and Karen’s many nervous-flyer idiosyncrasies.