Episode 34: In today’s episode of Slice of the Paranormal, we visit one of my favorite haunted hotspots in Central Pennsylvania: the historic Penn’s Tavern, just south of Sunbury. This 1700s-era waterfront tavern is packed with ghost stories, folklore, and chilling firsthand encounters. If you’re into haunted restaurants with a side of history—and maybe a ghost in your glass—this one’s for you. Penn’s Tavern is no stranger to the supernatural. Many have seen the Woman in the Blue Dress gazing out from upstairs windows. Local legend suggests she may be the spirit of John Penn’s wife, who died in an upper room centuries ago. Then there’s the infamous Lady in Red, spotted descending the main staircase and wandering the dining area—rumored to have met a violent end on the property and possibly buried in the basement. Guests and staff alike have reported seeing a group of Civil War soldiers near the bar, sometimes gathered around a card game in the dining room. One of the tavern’s former owners, Buddy Baker, had countless ghostly run-ins—most famously triggering a blood-curdling scream from the Lady in Red after closing a window during a storm. And if you find yourself by the fireplace, don’t be surprised if you spot the ghost of a 1900s workman, still warming his hands after all these years. Haunted Penn’s Tavern is a must-see for paranormal enthusiasts, ghost hunters, and fans of local legends. Come for the history, hauntings, and incredible food—stay for the spirits, both supernatural and top-shelf. 👻 Featured Sources: “Penns Tavern” by Beverly Conrad, Paranormal Pennsylvania and Beyond (Issue 6, 2003) “The Headless Dog” by Beverly Conrad & Gregory Burgess (2013) “The Wolfman’s Grave” by Beverly Conrad & Gregory Burgess (2024) Eastern Pennsylvania Ghost Files by Charles J. Adams III 📍 Visit the Haunted Site: Penn’s Tavern – Historic Waterfront Restaurant 113 River Rd (PA-147), Sunbury, PA 17801 www.pennstavern.com #PennsTavern #HauntedRestaurants #ParanormalPodcast #SunburyPA #GhostStoriesPA #HauntedHistory #LadyInRed #CivilWarGhosts #PennsylvaniaHauntings #HauntedTavern #ParanormalEncounters #GhostHunters #SliceOfTheParanormal #HauntedPlacesUSA #GhostSighting

Episode 33: Welcome to another chilling episode of Slice of the Paranormal! This time, we hit the road to Crawford County, Pennsylvania—home of one of the state’s strangest urban legends: the Pig People of Meadville. Under cover of darkness, our podcast crew drove up the infamous Pig Hill in hopes of encountering these elusive creatures said to stalk the woods at night. We dig deep into the origin stories behind the Pig People legend, passed down for generations by locals in Meadville. We also spotlight the upcoming horror film Pig, based on the book by Meadville native Nancy Williams and starring horror icon R.A. Mihailoff—best known as Leatherface in Texas Chainsaw Massacre III. But that’s just the beginning. We explore other Pig Man legends from across Pennsylvania and beyond, comparing folklore, sightings, and spine-tingling similarities. And while we were in town, we couldn’t resist checking out some of Meadville’s most haunted hotspots. We visited the site where the legendary Bloody 32 engine once rolled through on a ghostly killing spree. We also stopped at the historic Academy Theatre—where visitors report phantom footsteps, disembodied voices, and mysterious figures lurking in the shadows. If you're into cryptids, haunted places, and horror legends with real historical roots, this is one you won’t want to miss. #ParanormalPodcast #PigPeople #MeadvillePA #UrbanLegends #ParanormalInvestigation #CryptidSightings #HauntedPlaces #PigHill #HorrorLegends #RAMihailoff #TexasChainsawMassacre #GhostTrain #Bloody32 #AcademyTheatre #SliceOfTheParanormal #CreepyFolklore

Episode 32: The Wolfman’s Grave: Werewolf Legends of Pennsylvania’s Forgotten Counties

In this shadowy tale from Northumberland County, Pennsylvania, we dig into one of the state’s most chilling legends: the lost grave of a werewolf said to rest near Schwaben Creek, beneath the watchful presence of Himmel Church, its old cemetery, and a covered bridge steeped in silence.

Local lore tells of “Die Woolf Man’s Grob”—The Wolfman’s Grave—a burial site now vanished from maps and memory. Here, a solitary figure known only as the Hermit Werewolf was once laid to rest, where his shack crumbled long ago. The Paul family tombstones still stand in the nearby cemetery, but the werewolf’s grave has been lost to time. Still, whispers say a phantom gray wolf prowls the area, eyes glowing under moonlight, leaving pawprints where no beast should tread.

Our own Steven had a brush with this spectral predator one night under a pale moon, and in this episode, we unpack that encounter along with other Pennsylvania werewolf stories, stretching beyond Northumberland to forgotten corners of the state.

Join the Slice of the Paranormal team as we track down shape-shifters, haunted hollows, and long-buried truths.

Sources:

• Supernatural Lore of Pennsylvania by Thomas White (2014)

• “The Wolfman’s Grave” and Other Wild, Weird, and (More or Less) True Tales of Central Pennsylvania by Beverly Conrad & Gregory Burgess (2024)

Episode 31: In this chilling episode of Slice of the Paranormal, we journey to the haunted shores of Presque Isle State Park, a strange sandbar stretching off the coast of Erie, Pennsylvania, in Lake Erie. Steeped in Native American folklore and shadowed by the ominous names of Misery Bay and Graveyard Pond, this mysterious location sets the stage for tales that blur the line between history and the supernatural. We dive deep into legends of the Lake Erie Storm Hag—a deadly spirit said to lure ships to their doom—and South Bay Bessie, the elusive Lake Erie sea monster. But the real twist? A firsthand retelling of a UFO landing on Beach 6, where five eyewitnesses reported seeing a craft descend and a mysterious creature leave footprints in the sand. No government investigation followed. No police report filed. Just silence… and a trail of articles in the local Erie Times-News. Along the way, we nearly lose our car to the sands of Beach 6—because of course we do. With ghost sightings, cryptid creatures, and UFO activity, Presque Isle might just be one of the most paranormally active places in Pennsylvania. Don’t miss this deep-dive into Erie’s haunted history, cryptid chaos, and unexplained alien contact. Hit play—before the Storm Hag calls your name.

Episode 29: Haunted Baltimore: Ghosts of the U.S.S. Constellation, Fort McHenry & John Wilkes Booth’s Grave 👻🍕 The Slice of the Paranormal team dives into the haunted history of Baltimore, Maryland, uncovering chilling ghost stories and eerie encounters that have stood the test of time. 🔹 U.S.S. Constellation – Spirits have been spotted on this legendary warship since 1863. From eerie apparitions in the brig to ghostly figures captured in photographs, we explore the ship’s lingering paranormal activity. 🔹 Fort McHenry – Known for inspiring The Star-Spangled Banner, this historic site is also home to restless spirits, including Lieutenant Levi Clagett, Private John Drew, and the mysterious ghost seen near the Orpheus Statue. 🔹 John Wilkes Booth’s Grave – The infamous assassin lies beneath an unmarked stone in Green Mount Cemetery, where visitors leave Lincoln pennies as a strange tribute. We discuss Booth’s eerie connection to Baltimore’s haunted past. Of course, no Slice of the Paranormal episode is complete without a pizza review! 🍕 We’ll grab a slice from Baltimore and let you know if the flavor is as legendary as the city’s ghosts. Want to explore more haunted locations in Baltimore? Check out "Baltimore Ghosts: History, Mystery, Legends and Lore" by Ed Okonowicz 👉 https://a.co/d/6s4b6T5 🎧 Listen now for spine-chilling stories, paranormal history, and the best pizza in town! #HauntedBaltimore #GhostStories #ParanormalPodcast #USSConstellation #FortMcHenry #JohnWilkesBooth #GhostHunting #SliceOfTheParanormal #BaltimorePizza

Episode 28: The Slice of the Paranormal team takes a spooky trip to Selinsgrove, Pennsylvania, where we uncover haunted history, ghostly encounters, and eerie happenings at some of the town’s most legendary bars. 🔹 Selin’s Grove Brewery – Once the home of Pennsylvania Governor Simon Snyder, this historic brewery is said to be haunted by his ghostly apparition, spotted gazing from an upstairs window. The building also housed Tillie Pierce, famous for her Civil War memoir At Gettysburg, What a Girl Saw. If that’s not eerie enough, patrons report encounters with "George", a spirit who makes his presence known near the downstairs fireplace—with sightings, sensations, and even an unmistakable scent. 🔹 Selinsgrove Hotel – More than just a place to stay, this historic hotel has a reputation for paranormal activity. Music turns on by itself, mugs fly off shelves, and a rowing paddle has mysteriously fallen onto guests. If you’re looking for spirits beyond the bar, this is the place to be. 🔹 BJ’s Steak & Rib House – Known for its Oyster Bar and legendary food, BJ’s has a haunted past that includes a stabbing right outside. The crime connects it to Bots Tavern, which—despite lacking famous ghost stories—may still have a spirit or two lingering from its past. Want to experience these haunted bars yourself? Try the Selinsgrove Haunted Bar Crawl and see if you can catch a ghost in your glass. 🎧 Watch or listen now for spine-tingling tales, ghostly encounters, and the best bar-hopping spots in haunted Pennsylvania! #HauntedBars #GhostStories #ParanormalPodcast #SelinsgrovePA #HauntedHistory #GhostHunting #SliceOfTheParanormal #SpookyDrinks

Episode 27: In this chilling episode of Slice of the Paranormal, we uncover the shocking history and lingering hauntings of the Trenton Lunatic Asylum—the first institution built under the Kirkbride Plan, spearheaded by mental health reformer Dorothea Dix. While her mission was to create humane treatment for the mentally ill, the asylum soon fell into the horrors of overcrowding, abuse, and brutal medical experiments. One of its most infamous figures, Dr. Henry Cotton, believed madness stemmed from hidden infections—leading to gruesome procedures where patients had their teeth, organs, and even limbs removed in an effort to "cure" them. Many never survived his horrific treatments, and their restless spirits are said to haunt the asylum’s decaying halls. Some claim even Dr. Cotton’s ghost still roams the institution, tormented by the echoes of those he harmed. Is the Trenton Psychiatric Hospital still haunted by the souls of the abused? What can we learn from its dark past? Tune in as we explore the history, hauntings, and legacy of this infamous asylum. ⚠ Warning: This episode contains disturbing historical accounts of medical malpractice and may not be suitable for all listeners. #TrentonAsylum #HauntedHospitals #ParanormalPodcast #KirkbridePlan #GhostStories #MedicalHorror #TrueCrime #SliceOfTheParanormal