This week, we're discussing a potential broad daylight kidnapping in the small town of Greenville, Alabama. On June 6, 1984, 12-year-old Sherry Lynn Marler aka the "Little Farmer" disappeared from an errand with her stepfather. Sherry is still considered missing, though a local Facebook group claims to have evidence of her death.

VIEWER DISCRETION ADVISED: Click here to see the "pig pen" photo.

Sources used in this episode include:

• Alabama Law Enforcement Agency Community Information Center
• The Charley Project
• Surviving Parents Coalition
• Medium

Text us your tea!

Support the show

Ho ho ho, here's the horrifying story of a family annihilation to kick off the Christmas season! In December 1959, Christine Walker, her husband Cliff, and their two young children, Jimmie (3) and Debbie (1), were all found dead in their Florida farmhouse. Almost 600 suspects have been considered, but the case remains unsolved.

Sources used in this episode include:

• CBS News
• Herald Tribune
• Fox 13

Text us your tea!

Support the show

BOO! In this year's Halloween special, we're talking about two of the spookiest investigations undertaken by paranormal investigators Ed and Lorraine Warren in the 1970s-- Annabelle the doll and the Perron family's experience in The Conjuring House.

Text us your tea!

Support the show

Happy Halloween Eve -- or, in the Celtic tradition, Happy New Year's Eve! In this OG-style Salt Shakers episode, we're talking iconic Halloween costumes, least favorite traditions, and would-you-rathers.

Text us your tea!

Listen on: Apple Podcasts Spotify

Support the show

Did you know the Louvre had already been heisted before? In this episode, we're talking the 1911 theft and subsequent 28-month disappearance of Leonardo da Vinci's Mona Lisa.

Sources used in this episode include:

• NPR
• History.com
• Al Jazeera
• The Independent
• Vault Editions
• Garrett Museum of Art

Text us your tea!

Listen on: Apple Podcasts Spotify

Support the show

This week, we're talking everything we currently know about the October 19, 2025 theft of eight (almost nine) priceless pieces of the French Crown Jewels from the Louvre in Paris.

Sources used in this episode include:

• New York Times
• NBC News
• Al Jazeera
• ABC News
• Time
• CNN
• The Guardian

Text us your tea!

Listen on: Apple Podcasts Spotify

Support the show

In this episode, we're discussing the mysterious April 2014 disappearance of Dutch roommates Lisanne Froon (22) and Kris Kremers (21) from Panama's El Pianista hiking trail.

Sources used in this episode include:

• All That's Interesting
• Medium
• Wikipedia
• Newsroom Panama
• The Guardian
• The Daily Beast

Text us your tea!

Listen on: Apple Podcasts Spotify

Support the show

In case you missed it, this week we're revisiting the Appalachian folk tales of the Flatwoods Monster of West Virginia and the Bell Witch of Tennessee.

This episode was originally posted on August 31, 2024.

Text us your tea!

Listen on: Apple Podcasts Spotify

Support the show