As the search for Suzanne Morphew expanded, so did the suspicion surrounding her husband, Barry. In this second installment, we follow investigators deeper into the Morphew home—uncovering hidden recordings, deleted texts, and a secret affair Suzanne had been keeping from Barry. While search teams scoured rivers and mountains, detectives started to build a very different story: one of control, fear, and a marriage on the brink.

And then… an arrest.
Barry Morphew—charged with first-degree murder, tampering with evidence, and attempting to influence a public servant.
But as you’ll hear, an arrest wasn’t the end of this story.

On Mother’s Day, May 10th, 2020, Suzanne Morphew vanished from her home near Salida, Colorado. At first, this case looked familiar: a small-town disappearance, a missing woman, a bike found off a ravine. But unlike the other women we’ve covered this season—Suzanne’s story has moved forward. Her remains have been found. An arrest has been made. And just three weeks before this episode aired, her husband Barry Morphew was indicted again for her murder.

In Part One of this three-part case, we take you through the baffling timeline of Suzanne’s disappearance: a husband with too many trash stops, a mountain bike that didn’t crash, and a Mother’s Day that unraveled into something much darker.

Visit SequesteredPod.com to view body cam footage, case photos, Barry Morphew’s plea video, and more.

In this bonus episode, Sara and Andrea sit down to revisit the first two cases from Season 2 of SEQUESTERED: the disappearances of Tonetta Carlisle and Brandy Hall.

With fresh eyes and honest questions, they unpack what still doesn’t sit right—from the mysterious witnesses in Tonetta’s case to the conflicting theories around Brandy’s final hours. Why did key players lie? What evidence might still be waiting in an old file or forgotten bag? And who, after all these years, still knows something but hasn’t come forward?

This is a deeper dive into what haunts us, what’s missing, and why these open cases still matter. Send us your thoughts at sequesteredpod@gmail.com