What defines a great wrestling coach?

Championships? Career wins? State titles?

For legendary Raritan wrestling coach Rob Nucci, the answer goes much deeper.

Nucci became a high school head coach at just 22 years old, taking over Pinelands before eventually building Raritan into one of the Shore Conference's most respected small-school wrestling programs.

Over his coaching career at Raritan, he helped deliver five sectional championships, created one of New Jersey's most intimidating home wrestling environments — The Launch Pad — and built a culture that turned local wrestlers into hometown heroes.

But in this Coach's Corner episode of New Jersey Mat Chat, Nucci opens up about something far more important than his wrestling record.

He discusses losing seven former wrestlers to overdoses, the dozens more he says are in recovery, and how those experiences changed his understanding of coaching, mental health, and the responsibility coaches carry long after athletes graduate.

One of the most memorable moments comes when Nucci is asked whether he'd still be considered a great coach without his hundreds of career victories.

His answer changes the entire conversation.

He talks about seven former wrestlers he lost — and the many others whose lives continue beyond the wrestling room.

Because a coach's impact isn't always measured on a scoreboard.

Sometimes it's measured in the lives they help change.

Guest: Rob Nucci

Programs: Pinelands Regional / Raritan High School

Series: Coach's Corner — New Jersey Mat Chat

Subscribe to New Jersey Mat Chat as we document the wrestlers, coaches, and legends who shaped New Jersey wrestling.

Watch 'The Godfather of MMA'

Now available now on Amazon Prime:

https://www.amazon.com/gp/video/detail/B0HHCGGT6S

00:00 The Godfather of MMA

01:06 Meet Coach Rob Nucci

03:29 Growing Up in Toms River Wrestling

05:13 From Trenton State to Coaching at 22

06:19 How He Got the Pinelands Job

07:50 The Legendary Coaches Who Shaped Him

09:24 Coaching Was Always His Calling

11:02 Leaving Pinelands for Raritan

12:35 Rich Dunnels: A Coach Who Never Quit

14:05 Why Youth Wrestling Programs Matter

16:00 The Commitment to Keeping Kids at Raritan

17:52 The Personal Cost of Coaching

18:00 The Former Wrestler Who Said You Saved My Life

20:34 Why Parents Must Focus on Effort, Not Wins

21:06 Seven Losses That Still Haunt Him

23:57 How Mental Health Changed His Coaching

26:03 The Launch Pad: Raritan's Legendary Gym

28:00 The DelVal Rivalry and Five Sectional Titles

30:25 The Home-Mat Advantage

32:20 Why NJ Needs More Dual Meets

36:23 Creating Hometown Wrestling Heroes

37:21 Team Championships vs. Individual Success

41:27 How Nucci Developed State-Level Wrestlers

42:40 Is NJ Too Quick to Call Top Stalling?

46:00 Should Coaches Learn to Officiate?

55:00 The Crisis Facing Public School Wrestling

58:26 Why Schools Are Losing Coaches

01:01:00 The Greatest NJ Wrestling Legends

01:03:13 The Coaches Who Built the Shore Conference

01:05:32 The Challenges Facing Small Schools

01:06:40 Nucci's Greatest NJ Wrestler Ever

01:08:09 Final Thoughts and the Value of Small Programs

01:09:15 New Jersey Mat Chat Outro

Three high schools.

Three very different experiences.

And Sonny DiMatteo says he wouldn't change the path.

The Point Pleasant Borough senior has already experienced more change during his high school wrestling career than most athletes ever will.

He started at Brick Memorial — the program he had dreamed about wrestling for since elementary school.

As a freshman, he reached the blood round in Atlantic City.

As a sophomore, he placed 4th in New Jersey.

Then he made a major decision.

He transferred to CBA.

One year later, he made another one.

He left CBA and transferred to Point Pleasant Borough for his senior season.

In this episode of New Jersey Mat Chat, Sonny gives an honest look at what went into those decisions and what he's learned along the way.

One of the most interesting things about Sonny's story is that he doesn't pretend every decision worked exactly the way he expected.

CBA wasn't ultimately the right fit.

His wrestling career hasn't followed a straight line.

There were losses.

There were moments he questioned wrestling.

There were transfers.

But when we asked Sonny what he would change if he could do it all again, his answer was basically:

Nothing.

Brick Memorial.

CBA.

Point Pleasant Borough.

That's the path that got him here.

And as Sonny says in this episode:

“Everything happens for a reason.”

Now there's one chapter left.

🤼 Sonny DiMatteo

🏫 Point Pleasant Borough

🥉 NJ State 4th Place

🎟️ 3X NJ State Tournament Competitor

🔥 Shore Thing Wrestling

Subscribe to New Jersey Mat Chat for conversations with the wrestlers, coaches and legends shaping New Jersey wrestling.

Watch 'The Godfather of MMA'

Now available now on Amazon Prime:

https://www.amazon.com/gp/video/detail/B0HHCGGT6S

00:00 The Godfather of MMA

01:06 Meet Sonny DiMatteo

01:41 Growing Up at Shore Thing Wrestling

03:03 Why Sonny Took a Holdback Year

05:33 Why He Always Wanted to Wrestle at Brick Memorial

07:55 Creating His Own Wrestling Season

09:52 Why Sonny Never Bounced Between Wrestling Clubs

13:04 His Freshman & Sophomore Years at Brick Memorial

13:34 Why Sonny Left Brick Memorial for CBA

16:57 Adjusting to Life at CBA

20:12 A Rocky Start to His Junior Wrestling Season

21:23 The Time Sonny Almost Quit Wrestling

22:18 Why March Matters More Than Your Record

23:25 Looking Back at His First Season at CBA

25:23 Why Sonny Left CBA for Point Pleasant Borough

26:31 Choosing to Wrestle With His Brother

28:07 Starting Over at a Third High School

29:17 Becoming a Leader at Point Borough

30:33 Point Borough’s Team Goals

32:14 Sonny’s College Wrestling Recruitment

35:04 His Goals for His Senior Season

36:08 Why Sonny Signed Up for a Marathon

37:54 Advice to His 7-Year-Old Self

38:37 Public vs. Non-Public: What Sonny Learned

40:56 Why He Loves the Small-Town Feel

41:48 Would He Change His High School Path?

42:21 Greatest NJ High School Wrestler Ever?

42:59 Why Wrestling History Matters

44:15 New Jersey Mat Chat Outro

Orlando Cáceres didn't grow up expecting to become an Olympian.

Born in Puerto Rico to an Air Force family, Orlando eventually landed in Pemberton, New Jersey and started wrestling in seventh grade.

He considers himself an average young wrestler.

Then he got tired of losing.

What followed became one of the great — and often overlooked — stories in New Jersey wrestling history.

Orlando became:

🏆 2X New Jersey State Champion

🐝 Pemberton wrestling legend

🎓 Trenton State wrestler

🇵🇷 Puerto Rican National Team member

🔥 1984 Olympian

🥉 Two points away from an Olympic bronze medal

In this New Jersey Mat Chat Legends episode, Orlando takes us back to a completely different era of wrestling.

🤼 Orlando Cáceres

🏫 Pemberton High School

🏆 2X NJ State Champion

🎓 Trenton State

🇵🇷 1984 Puerto Rican Olympic Team

Subscribe to New Jersey Mat Chat as we document the wrestlers, coaches and legends who built New Jersey wrestling.

Watch 'The Godfather of MMA'

Now available now on Amazon Prime:

https://www.amazon.com/gp/video/detail/B0HHCGGT6S

00:00 The Godfather of MMA

01:06 Meet NJ Legend Orlando Cáceres

01:52 From Puerto Rico to Pemberton

02:48 How Orlando Started Wrestling

03:06 Why His Parents Wouldn’t Let Him Wrestle Varsity

04:35 Going From Average to Obsessed

05:17 Running Two Miles Before Practice

06:08 Wrestling in the 1970s

06:21 “Go Wrestle Every Bearded Man You See”

07:05 The Pemberton Wrestling Powerhouse

07:42 Becoming a Dark Horse NJ State Champion

08:32 State Final vs. Dale Mills

09:59 The Jump From Junior to Senior Year

10:14 Wrestling Grown Men in Open Tournaments

10:37 Training at Fort Dix With NJ Champions

11:13 Darryl Burley’s Influence

11:39 The 1980 State Final vs. Joe Duca

12:46 The Weight Cutting Mistake

13:09 Getting Recruited by Wrestling Powers

15:14 Becoming Pemberton’s First 2X State Champion

15:51 Why He Backed Out of Iowa

17:09 Choosing Arizona

17:30 Arizona Drops Its Wrestling Program

17:42 Coming Home to Trenton State

18:42 Struggling at Arizona

19:46 Why He Hated Collegiate Wrestling

20:18 Falling in Love With Freestyle

21:25 Coach Milt Schisler’s “Computer Match”

22:44 Why Wrestling Kept Him in College

23:04 Chasing Team USA & Puerto Rico

23:33 Missing the Plane to the USA Trials

24:23 Going Toe-to-Toe With Barry Davis

25:05 Wrestling in the 1984 Olympics

25:48 Orlando’s Olympic Run

26:34 Facing a World Champion From Japan

26:52 Two Points From an Olympic Bronze Medal

27:53 Life After the Olympics

28:36 The NJ Legends Orlando Helped Develop

29:09 Coaching Pat Lynch

29:46 Coaching at Peddie

31:39 Walking Away From Wrestling

32:28 Does an Olympian Have an Obligation to Give Back?

33:03 Gary Remembers Wrestling Orlando

34:07 Why Orlando Stepped Away From Coaching

35:20 Would He Have Made His Son Wrestle?

36:21 Greatest NJ High School Wrestler Ever?

37:38 New Jersey Mat Chat Outro