Oh, wow. It's time we cover Barry! At the end of 2025 Katie challenged Abby to watch this show so it could be discussed, and we're finally here. Which episode will be the best beignet of the bunch? Which sister will conquer the ever raging season 4 debate? Is Barry simply a "tale told by an idiot, full of sound and fury, signifying nothing"? We think not! There's so much to chat about we're going to need a heroin table! Let's get to it...

Did we get it right or wrong? Drop us an email at mustseeIMDB@gmail.com and tell us all about it.

Abby and Katie are having a hard time sticking to one show we are so obsessed with everything you can watch on PBS, especially if you support public media with their Passport to all past shows. Are we into true crime? Not really, but if you give us an offbeat detective of any kind on a PBS show we are already there with popcorn in hand. Performances of all kinds abound on this platform, and we dive into our favorites in the PBS universe. Some titles discussed include All Creatures Great and Small, The Puzzle Lady, Finding Your Roots, Wolf Hall, Endeavor, Bookish, The Magpie Murders, and many more!

Did we get it right or wrong? Drop us an email at mustseeIMDB@gmail.com and tell us all about it.

Abby and Katie welcome special guest, and SATC expert, Viann to discuss this classic NYC series of fairy tale meets reality. Will we wax poetic, with Charlottesque wonder at what the IMDB voters selected as the best episode of the series? Or more likely come in swinging like Miranda, with some blunt rebuttals of our own? Either way, we'll be doing so with Carrie-like wit, and a side of Samantha's saucy takes.

Did we get it right or wrong? Drop us an email at mustseeIMDB@gmail.com and tell us all about it.

Abby, Katie and special guest Sam are sneaking over to Scranton before the end of the year to celebrate The Office- which our polls show is top billed by listeners, and not yet covered by us! Abby regrets not choosing The Office to take to a deserted island after revisiting this gem, Katie knows which character would best assist her on an island, and Sam is here to offer a teen's perspective on why this show endures!

Even kid's love this show- check out Leo's drawing of the best Cold Open in history as our Episode Artwork

Did we get it right or wrong? Drop us an email at mustseeIMDB@gmail.com and tell us all about it.

To celebrate our 50th episode we look back on our best picks of the past, but also prepare for what we should cover ahead. A poll of Castaway Bay TV shows will decide a future episode, as will Katie picking a show Abby hasn't seen, and vice versa. We are in the business of finding hidden gem episodes, but we've noticed listeners like to hear about hidden gem shows, as they tend to be our MOST popular episodes. If you have a hidden gem show we've never heard of drop us a line at the email below. Onward to the next 50 episodes!

Did we get it right or wrong? Drop us an email at mustseeIMDB@gmail.com and tell us all about it.

Abby, Katie and special guest Chris discuss the hilariously stupid in all the best ways series- Detroiters. Only recently available to stream on Netflix we had to discuss which episode deserves top billing.

I Just Had To Tell You picks:

Katie's Book

Chris' Song/Music Video

Abby's Movie

ALSO- If you have your own recommendations for best episodes of a show we've covered and ignored or just got wrong, tell us all about it at mustseeIMDB@gmail.com

We'll be sure to include it in our look back as we cover it all in our 50th Episode Extravaganza coming up!

Did we get it right or wrong? Drop us an email at mustseeIMDB@gmail.com and tell us all about it.

You can count on Abby and Katie to find the very best episode of My Two Dads the classic 80s sitcom. Grab a spot on the purple car couch and let's dive in!

Did we get it right or wrong? Drop us an email at mustseeIMDB@gmail.com and tell us all about it.

Mothers. Daughters. Sisters. Women. Abby and Katie check all these boxes so it's finally time they sat down and watched the incredible Pamela Adlon show Better Things! They have done so and are ready to get down to business to find the very best episode. Regardless of the outcome, all agree touch point statues are winners and should be in every home.

Did we get it right or wrong? Drop us an email at mustseeIMDB@gmail.com and tell us all about it.