This week on Must Be Tuesday: A Buffy Podcast, we’re heading back to biology class for Teacher’s Pet, where Buffy loses a genuinely wonderful teacher, Cordelia finds a head in the fridge (Sunnydale High cafeteria vibes), and a mysterious substitute shows up with big “extra credit after class” energy. Spoiler: she’s a literal She-Mantis, because in this town even faculty recruitment is cursed.

We break down how the show tries to throw us off with “Fork Guy” — a clawed vampire who is very much not the threat — and how even he’s scared of our seductive substitute. We also get into the chef’s kiss levels of cringe high-school-boy behavior, from braggy locker-room fantasies to Xander’s “I swear I’m cool” meltdown, proving teenage hormones are almost as dangerous as giant mantis talons.

Plus: Buffy’s bat-sonar science moment and that egg-cluster stinger ending that absolutely says “this isn’t over”… even though thankfully, it kind of is.

Watch the video version on YouTube for extra clips and visuals, and follow us on socials to keep up with new episodes, behind-the-scenes chaos, and all things Buffy.

Slay along with us every Tuesday!

Watch Episode 5: Never Kill a Boy on the First Date before next week — and until next Tuesday, if the apocalypse comes, beep us!

Website: ⁠⁠www.BuffyTuesdays.com⁠⁠

YouTube: youtube.com/@MustBeTuesdayPodcast

TikTok: tiktok.com/@buffytuesdays

Instagram: instagram.com/buffytuesdays

This week on Must Be Tuesday: A Buffy Podcast, we’re stirring up trouble with Witch, where Buffy faces her first taste of magic, mother–daughter drama, and a truly cursed cheer squad. We break down the episode scene by scene, unpack Sunnydale High’s new brand of chaos, and ask the important questions—like how far would you go to make varsity?

It’s our spellbound play-by-play of Buffy’s first real monster (kinda) and one seriously overbearing mom with a talent for possession.

Watch the video version on YouTube for extra clips and visuals, and follow us on socials to keep up with new episodes, behind-the-scenes chaos, and all things Buffy.
Watch Episode 4: Teacher’s Pet to get ready for next week — and remember: If the apocalypse comes, beep us!

Website: ⁠www.BuffyTuesdays.com⁠
YouTube: @MustBeTuesdayPodcast
Instagram & TikTok: @BuffyTuesdays

This week on Must Be Tuesday: A Buffy Podcast, we’re diving fang-first into The Harvest, where Buffy faces her first big test as Sunnydale’s resident Slayer. We break down the episode scene by scene, relive the Bronze’s worst night ever, and ask the important questions—like how everyone just forgot about Jesse.

It’s our slightly chaotic play-by-play of Buffy’s first real showdown and the mysterious vanishing act of one very unlucky friend.

Watch the video version on YouTube for extra clips and visuals, and follow us on socials to keep up with new episodes, behind-the-scenes chaos, and all things Buffy.

Watch Episode 3: Witch to get ready for next week — and remember: If the apocalypse comes, beep us!

Website: ⁠www.BuffyTuesdays.com⁠

YouTube: @MustBeTuesdayPodcast
Instagram & TikTok: @BuffyTuesdays

In our very first episode, hosts Mike & Manny step into Sunnydale to kick off our Buffy the Vampire Slayer rewatch!

We’ll introduce ourselves, share why Buffy still slays decades later, and give you a taste of what’s to come — from campy chaos and heartfelt moments to deep dives into demons, destiny, and drama.

Then we dive into “Welcome to the Hellmouth” — where Buffy’s fresh start in Sunnydale High takes a deadly turn, and the Scooby Gang’s story begins.

Slay along with us every Tuesday!

Watch Episode 2: The Harvest to get ready for next week — and remember: If the apocalypse comes, beep us!Website: ⁠www.BuffyTuesdays.com⁠

YouTube: @MustBeTuesdayPodcast

Instagram & TikTok: @BuffyTuesdays