Why We Chose Band

Four band educators compare origin stories, talk about what keeps them in the profession, and swap first-year teaching chaos stories. The conversation matters because it shows how band shapes identity, classroom community, and career commitment in ways that go far beyond playing notes.

Sponsors

Sight Reading Factory

RCP Drum Company

Wenger for Music Education

https://wengercorp.com/triplethreats?utm_source=BTP&utm_medium=podcast&utm_campaign=2627WCTT&utm_content=midrollad

Timestamps

0:24 Intro to the episode and the question of why each guest chose band

1:24 Ms. Hazlett introduces her Milwaukee band program and fifth-grade pilot

3:03 Regional dialect check: bubbler, cart, buggy, soda, pop, and Coke

4:44 Ryan explains the prank sound effects and cricket counter running through the episode

5:31 Why the group is talking about band and what each person will cover

5:58 Renee’s origin story: youngest sibling, family band tradition, and choosing saxophone

7:25 Renee on when band became part of her identity and why music classmates mattered

9:28 Ms. Hazlett on being a music education “Nepo baby” and choosing clarinet in fifth grade

11:25 Marching band, section leader responsibilities, and the moment teaching started to feel possible

12:30 Dad as band director versus dad not being her actual teacher

14:39 Strong female band director role models and why they mattered

15:57 Paul’s band origin story, his brother’s influence, and his high school jazz sax teacher

17:59 Ryan shares his own band director tribute and why the conversation hits home

18:54 Dr. Laura Dunbar’s idea: go into music ed because of a teacher, not in spite of one

19:56 Why Ryan believes band is the most important class in school

20:51 Renee on strong female directors and why band means life lessons, not just music

23:23 Paul on band as identity, difficulty, practice, and yearly variety

24:51 Adapting to changing student skill levels, instrumentation, and repertoire

26:10 Ms. Hazlett on choosing music education because she loves teaching, not performance

27:31 Why band can serve both casual participants and high-achieving students

28:37 The transition into first-year teaching stories and how hard the shift really is

29:17 Ms. Hazlett on year three, starting a brand new program, and imposter syndrome

32:21 Paul on imposter syndrome still showing up years later

34:12 Paul’s slow start after college, recession-era job hunting, and a point-two job

35:27 The jump from part-time work to running a full band and marching program

36:26 Trying to lead without pretending to be someone else

38:00 Student teaching as a safe environment versus the realities of a first job

39:17 Renee on student teaching in elementary and high school, then entering middle school

41:19 Renee’s first jobs in Wisconsin, Minnesota, and learning to manage a full program

42:56 Eighth graders pushing back and why sixth grade feels easier to shape

45:05 Paul taking over from a previous director and dealing with senior resistance

46:14 The awkward pressure of replacing a beloved director

47:40 Paul’s student teaching in jazz versus what the job actually required

48:32 Ryan’s classroom story about confiscating a phone and a student cursing his door with dirt

50:26 Ms. Hazlett’s first-year story about a firecracker exploding in a student’s pocket

54:42 Renee’s first-year story about a student throwing a chair and the chaos that followed

58:19 Why first-year teaching moments feel huge, but become part of normal school reality

59:09 Not taking student behavior personally and remembering what kids bring into class

1:00:57 Why admin emails can spike anxiety instantly

1:01:52 Paul’s funny first-year story: a car parked on the marching practice lot

1:02:24 Attempting the “move the car as a team” lesson and accidentally nearly having students break into it

1:04:42 Final round of appreciation for band, ending with a salute and sign-off