Spencer thought his first date with Mallory was a huge success! After matching on Hinge, they spent nearly three hours laughing, flirting, and even talking about seeing each other again. But Mallory suddenly ghosted him, and Spencer had no idea why. Turns out, something happened while he was in the bathroom that completely changed Mallory's opinion of him, and the truth behind what she discovered is even more complicated than she realizes!

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Amanda thought she'd made a great connection with Riley after a romantic Italian dinner filled with good conversation and even sharing dessert. But when Riley stopped responding, Amanda wondered if she'd done something wrong, especially after noticing he kept leaning away from her throughout the night. Turns out, Riley had a very specific reason for keeping his distance, and it's something Amanda never would've suspected!

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Blake thought his first date with Megan went well, despite an awkward run-in with his ex-girlfriend. But when Megan stopped returning his calls, Blake assumed that uncomfortable encounter was to blame. Turns out, Megan wasn't bothered by his ex at all. It was something Blake did AFTER their date, and discovering he'd done the same thing for other women made it even worse!

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Joey and Allie met on Match.com, and when Allie told him to surprise her with their first date, Joey decided to go all out by taking her skydiving! But despite the unconventional date, Allie stopped responding to him afterward. Turns out, jumping out of an airplane wasn't what scared her away. Something Joey did after their adventure ended up causing some serious problems for Allie.

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Alan and Lisa met at a college football game and bonded over how they're both active. So Alan surprised Lisa with their first date location and can't understand why he hasn't heard back from Lisa ever since. Where did they go that caught Lisa completely off guard and can we salvage a second date?

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Adam and Leslie met at a fancy gala and then went out into the Heights for a date a couple weeks later but since then Adam hasn't heard from Leslie. Leslie says Adam made a huge change in between their initial meeting and their first date that totally caught her off guard. Does she have a point or is she just being superficial? Find out on Second Date Update!

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Jose thought his first date with Amanda went great and worried that forgetting to open her car door might be why she ghosted him. Turns out, Amanda couldn't care less about the door. She lost all attraction after learning Jose is an avid Pokémon card collector who still buys packs and even waits for new shipments at Target. Jose sees it as a valuable hobby, while Amanda sees it as a grown man playing with children's toys. Gotta ghost 'em all.

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Chad thought his first date with Angela went great, but one casual detail about having a second apartment with his buddies raised some serious questions. Turns out, Chad and his friends call the place “The Embassy,” and Angela discovers it's less of a man cave and more of a secret headquarters where Chad's married friends can hook up with other women. Chad insists their marriages aren't his responsibility, but Angela thinks paying one-third of the rent makes him more than an innocent bystander.

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.