Guest: Josh Volinsky, President & Co-Founder of Synergy Search Host: Benjamin Mena, Pinnacle Take Podcast

In this episode of the Pinnacle Take Podcast, host Benjamin Mena welcomes Josh Volinsky, President and Co-Founder of Synergy Search—a recruiting firm that transformed accountants into high-performing $400K billers. Josh shares the step-by-step blueprint behind Synergy Search’s rapid growth: hiring industry professionals with zero recruiting experience and training them into some of the most successful recruiters in the market.

This jam-packed interview covers building a winning culture, actionable onboarding, adapting to tough markets, and data-driven leadership, with hard-won lessons from record-breaking wins and challenging setbacks.

• How Synergy Search Turned Accountants into Top-Billing Recruiters: Josh reveals Synergy’s secret for transforming ex-accountants, CPAs, and industry professionals into full-desk recruiters who consistently bill $400K+ their first year.

• The Power of the Right Team and Founding Partners: Why choosing the right co-founders and splitting equity equally fueled performance and culture.

• Building and Scaling a High-Performance Recruiting Firm: Insights on ramping up operations, scaling hiring, and creating a repeatable training system.

• Adapting to Market Shifts & Setbacks: What happened when the “golden era” ended and how Synergy Search rebuilt momentum with accountability, transparency, and a focus on key metrics.

• Leadership Lessons & Culture: How tragedy, major setbacks, and rapid growth shaped the company’s values and future.

• “We hire A players—even if they have zero recruiting experience—and teach them everything. Attitude and industry knowledge are everything.”

• “Accountability and tracking key KPIs turned our worst quarter into our best. Transparency and culture drive results.”

• “You have to become obsessed: with your niche, your market, and your craft. Mentorship and relentless growth are non-negotiable.”

• Synergy Search’s founding story: why Josh left a high-earning recruiting job to start fresh

• Why hiring accountants—not recruiters—created a competitive edge

• The exact training blueprint that ramped up new hires to $400K+ in billings

• How Synergy weathered the 2024 market downturn & the challenges of scaling fast

• The critical importance of KPIs, accountability, mentorship, and leading by example

• Hard lessons and leadership moments—including the impact of losing a top team member

• What makes Synergy’s top billers different and advice for new recruiting leaders

• Recruiting agency founders and owners

• Talent acquisition leaders and in-house recruiters

• Professional services and executive search leaders

• Anyone interested in sales, leadership, and building high-performance teams

• Connect with Josh Volinsky on LinkedIn

• Learn more about Pinnacle Society: https://pinnaclesociety.org/

If you enjoyed this episode, please follow, rate, and review the Pinnacle Take Podcast, and share it with a friend in the recruiting world!