What happens when a science-loving kid who once tried walking on water grows up? He becomes a priest of course!

In this episode of Holy Banter, Christina and Andrea sit down with Father Andrew Morand, who grew up at St. Alphonsus, to talk about his unexpected journey from curious kid to diocesan priest. Father Andrew shares how hearing the word “transubstantiation” during First Communion prep first captured his imagination, why he once thought priests knew secret “magic words” and how retreats, Catholic community, prayer and a growing desire to enter more deeply into the spiritual life eventually led him to discern the priesthood.

Along the way, Father Andrew talks about learning to hear God in silence, the joys and sacrifices of spiritual fatherhood, and what it means to preach to the person in the pew who may be suffering the most. And, of course, he explains how a 40-hour Minecraft experiment using canon law unexpectedly reached hundreds of thousands of people and sparked some surprisingly deep conversations about the Catholic faith.

It’s a funny, thoughtful conversation about science, faith, vocation, prayer and discovering that sometimes God’s call becomes clear long before you’re completely sure you want to answer it.

What happens when God keeps opening doors you never planned to walk through?

In this episode of Holy Banter, Christina Steele and Andrea Simpson sit down with Zionsville native David Price, who grew up Protestant before discovering the Catholic faith while studying at Hope College. David shares how his questions about the Eucharist, Scripture, and the teachings of the Catholic Church eventually led him to enter the Church in 2024.

But his conversion story didn’t end there. David talks about the unexpected “coincidences” and people God placed in his path—including a surprising connection with Deacon Tim—that helped him recognize God’s providence at work.

Just months after becoming Catholic, David found himself discerning an entirely unexpected call to become a FOCUS missionary. Despite repeatedly turning down invitations to apply, he eventually took a leap of faith, and during his interview weekend, his heart began to open to the mission.

Now preparing to serve college students at the University of Southern Indiana, David reflects on what it means to surrender his plans, trust God with his future, and follow where He leads—even when the destination is uncertain. It’s a conversation about conversion, the Eucharist, discernment, providence, and learning to trust God one step at a time.

Equal parts laugh-out-loud funny and genuinely inspiring, this episode of Holy Banter features an uplifting conversation about faith, ministry, and family. Co-hosts Andrea and Christina sit down with Seminarian Sam Bhatt to explore his unique vision of God’s call—not as a rigid obligation, but as the ultimate adventure of a lifetime. Through hilarious personal stories and deeply encouraging insights, Sam shares what it really means to step out in faith, embrace the unknown, and say a bold "yes" to a purpose much bigger than yourself.

In this episode of Holy Banter, Christina and Andrea sit down with seminarian Josiah Lewis to hear the story of his journey toward the priesthood—and what God has taught him along the way. Josiah shares how his vocation hasn’t been one dramatic “yes,” but rather a series of small yeses, each requiring him to surrender his desire for control and trust God with the next step.

Together, they talk about discernment, surrender, the desire to know what comes next, and learning to trust that we don't have to see the whole path—we just have to take the next step God puts in front of us.

Whether you're discerning a vocation, making a big decision, or simply trying to follow God more faithfully, Josiah's story is a beautiful reminder that God often leads us one yes at a time.

What happens when you've spent a lifetime searching for success, reinventing yourself, and chasing the next thing—only to discover that what you're really looking for can't be found in a career, a city, or a paycheck? In this episode of Holy Banter, Lisa Wykoff shares her remarkable journey from what she calls "bubblegum Christianity" to becoming Catholic at this year's Easter Vigil. Along the way, she reflects on life in Chicago, Atlanta, and Hilton Head, a stint in stand-up comedy, the heartbreak of starting over, a powerful spiritual awakening during COVID, and the unexpected path that led her to the Catholic Church. With honesty, humor, and plenty of laughs, Lisa opens up about faith, identity, spiritual warfare, and the moment she realized that true success isn't found in what you achieve—it's found in who you are as a child of God.

Join us for a conversation with Mat Lageman—a former Hollywood actor, voice performer, comedian, recovering alcoholic, devoted father, and the man behind one of the most memorable photos in our parish directory. From performing with Second City and working in Los Angeles to voicing a villainous tumor in a horror movie, Mat's life has been full of unexpected twists. But when God called him away from the spotlight and into a completely different role, Mat discovered a deeper purpose than he ever imagined. Filled with hilarious stories, hard-earned wisdom, and moving reflections on sobriety, fatherhood, faith, and surrender, this episode is a powerful reminder that God's plans are often far better—and far stranger—than our own.

In this episode of Holy Banter, Christina and Andrea sit down with newlyweds Nick and Lexi Krier to explore their remarkable faith journeys and what led them to become passionate volunteers in St. Alphonsus Liguori's middle school ministry. Lexi shares her path from a non-denominational Christian upbringing to entering the Catholic Church through OCIA, describing the mentors, friendships, and experiences that helped her discover the beauty of Catholicism and the Eucharist. Nick reflects on growing up Catholic, rediscovering his faith in college through the St. Thomas Aquinas Catholic Center at Purdue, and how community and retreats transformed his relationship with Christ. Together, they discuss dating across denominations, preparing for marriage, the importance of prayer and accountability, and the role of authentic Christian friendships in shaping a life of faith.

Christina Steele and Andrea Simpson sit down with Father Jacob Miller just days before his ordination to the priesthood. Father Jacob shares his inspiring journey from a small rural town in eastern Indiana to answering God's call to become a priest. He reflects on a powerful encounter with God's voice during his Confirmation, the years he spent discerning between marriage and priesthood, and the mentors who helped guide him along the way. Filled with humor, heartfelt stories, and profound insights on prayer, vocation, and the love of the Sacred Heart of Jesus, this conversation offers a moving look at how God patiently leads us to discover His plan for our lives. Whether you're discerning a vocation, seeking to deepen your faith, or simply love hearing powerful stories of God's work in ordinary lives, this is an episode you won't want to miss.