In the fall and early winter of 1982, two young women were abducted and brutally murdered within weeks of each other in Morris County, New Jersey.

Eighteen-year-old Amie Hoffman disappeared on November 23 after leaving her job at the Morris County Mall. Two days later, her body was discovered in a secluded water-retention tank. On December 5, twenty-five-year-old Deirdre O’Brien was run off the road, abducted, sexually assaulted, and repeatedly stabbed. Although she was found alive, she died before she could identify her attacker.

With fear spreading across the community and few solid leads, investigators consulted Nancy Weber, a local psychic who claimed she could see the killer, his vehicle, his criminal history, and even injuries he would inflict upon himself. Her alleged insights would later become one of the most controversial elements of the investigation.

Then James Koedatich—a recently paroled murderer—reported that he had been stabbed by a mysterious woman while driving alone at night. Detectives quickly realized that Koedatich’s story was unraveling. His wounds appeared to be self-inflicted, his vehicle matched witness descriptions, and evidence found inside his car connected him to both victims.

Join us as we examine the murders of Amie Hoffman and Deirdre O’Brien, the violent history of James Koedatich, the evidence that brought him to justice, and the enduring question surrounding Nancy Weber: Did a psychic truly see through the eyes of a killer—or did time and television turn investigative coincidence into something supernatural?

Subscribe now and never miss a case!

Sources used for this podcast

• Join the H2H In-laws & Outlaws
• Follow H2H on Instagram
• Follow H2H on X
• Send Kris and Rob a Text or Message
• Start Reading Kris Calvert's Books for FREE

Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.

In the early morning hours of June 3, 1991, 23-year-old Denise Huber vanished after a flat tire left her stranded along a California freeway. Her abandoned car was discovered, but Denise was nowhere to be found. For three agonizing years, her family searched for answers—until a suspicious truck in Arizona led investigators to a horrifying discovery: Denise’s body, handcuffed and frozen inside a chest freezer.

The investigation exposed John Famalaro, a seemingly ordinary house painter who had abducted and brutally murdered Denise before preserving her body and possessions as trophies. Known as California’s “Cold Storage Killer,” Famalaro was ultimately convicted of first-degree murder with special circumstances and sentenced to death.

This episode of Hitched 2 Homicide examines the disappearance and murder of Denise Huber, the extraordinary chain of events that finally uncovered the truth, the evidence hidden inside Famalaro’s home, and how one of Orange County’s most haunting missing-person cases was solved nearly 400 miles away.

Subscribe now and never miss a case!

Sources used for this podcast

• Join the H2H In-laws & Outlaws
• Follow H2H on Instagram
• Follow H2H on X
• Send Kris and Rob a Text or Message

Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.

In October 1961, 19-year-old Betty Gail Brown — a promising sophomore at Transylvania University in Lexington, Kentucky — was found brutally murdered in her car on campus. Strangled to death with her own brassiere, her killer has never been brought to justice. This remains one of Kentucky’s most haunting unsolved murders.

On this episode of Hitched 2 Homicide, we dive deep into the shocking true story of the Betty Gail Brown case: a young woman full of potential whose life was cut short in a place meant for learning and safety. We examine the chilling details of that fateful night, the botched investigation, the dramatic 1965 confession by drifter Alex Arnold Jr. that led to a high-profile trial and mistrial, and the lingering theories that still divide the community more than six decades later.

Was Betty Gail Brown the victim of a random campus predator, a personal grudge, or something even darker? Despite multiple leads and intense media attention at the time, her murder stays cold — a heartbreaking reminder of how one night can shatter lives forever.

If you’re fascinated by unsolved true crime cases, Kentucky murders, campus killings, and deadly mysteries from the 1960s, this episode is for you. We honor Betty’s memory while exploring every angle of this infamous Lexington cold case.

️ Key Topics:

• Betty Gail Brown’s final hours and the gruesome discovery • Flaws in the original police investigation • The Alex Arnold confession and mistrial • Modern theories and why the case remains unsolved

Listener discretion is advised — this episode discusses murder and sensitive details.

If you have any information about the Betty Gail Brown murder, please contact the Lexington Police Department or the Kentucky State Police.

Like, subscribe, and leave a review on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen! Your support helps us bring more victim-focused true crime stories to light.

Follow Hitched 2 Homicide on Instagram @hitched2homicide for photos, updates, and bonus content. For video versions and exclusive episodes, check out our Substack.

#BettyGailBrown #UnsolvedMurder #LexingtonKY #KentuckyTrueCrime #ColdCase #TransylvaniaUniversity #1961Murder #TrueCrimePodcast

Episode Timestamps: 00:00 – Introduction 06:01 – Who Was Betty Gail Brown? 10:00 – The Night of October 26, 1961 16:55 – The Investigation Unfolds 27:33 – Alex Arnold’s Confession & Trial 38:10 – Theories & Lingering Questions 50:00 – Final Thoughts & Victim Memorial

Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.