Over half of everyone on Medicare is now enrolled in a Medicare Advantage plan — roughly 35 million people. In this third episode of the Medicare Season Survival Guide series, Amy sits down with Medicare policy expert Gretchen Jacobson, PhD (Commonwealth Fund) to cut through the TV ads and "$0 premium" promises and explain what Medicare Advantage actually is, how it works, and the trade-offs involved — from prior authorizations to the truth about extras like dental care, transportation, and in some cases, even kayaks.

KEY TAKEAWAYS

• Medicare Advantage plans are private insurance plans paid by the federal government — and private plans have been part of Medicare almost since it began in 1965.

• Despite the original promise of cost savings, Medicare Advantage has never cost the federal government less than original Medicare.

• Extra benefits (dental, vision, hearing, transportation, even sports equipment) can be genuinely valuable — but about 1 in 3 people in Medicare Advantage say they didn't use any of their plan's extra benefits last year.

• Medicare Advantage plans use managed care tools — provider networks, referrals, and prior authorization — that original Medicare doesn't require.

• A "$0 premium" plan still means you pay your Part B premium; it just means no additional premium on top of that.

• You cannot pair a Medigap plan with Medicare Advantage.

• Long-term care isn't covered by Medicare Advantage (or original Medicare) — only short-term, rehabilitative nursing home stays are.

• You keep the same rights and appeal protections under Medicare Advantage as under original Medicare.

• Plans and provider networks can change every year — review your plan each Open Enrollment, even if you're happy with it.

• Gretchen's checklist: confirm your doctors/hospitals are covered, check drug coverage and costs, verify the extras are ones you'll use, and look at the out-of-pocket limit.

IN THIS EPISODE

00:00 Welcome — why this episode matters before the ads start

00:59 Meet Gretchen Jacobson, PhD

02:44 What is Medicare Advantage, in plain English?

03:38 A brief history: private plans since the 1970s

04:30 Did Medicare Advantage deliver on its cost-control promise?

06:10 The "extras": dental, vision, hearing... and kayaks

08:52 Prior authorizations and referrals: the real trade-off

09:44 Weighing the trade-offs: who is MA right for?

11:32 Why your county matters — plans vary by geography

13:10 Part D and drug coverage inside MA plans

15:49 The truth about "$0 premium" plans

18:36 Surprising stat: 1 in 3 never use their extra benefits

19:33 Can you pair Medigap with Medicare Advantage?

20:33 Hidden costs: long-term care and cost-sharing

22:29 When Medicare Advantage really doesn't make sense

23:35 Where to get unbiased help: your SHIP

25:22 Buyer beware: how brokers get paid

27:56 Can you switch plans if you feel misled?

28:48 Gretchen's pre-enrollment checklist

30:36 The "hustle factor" no one can easily measure

31:18 Why plans and networks change every year

33:53 Gretchen's #1 piece of advice for families

34:59 Amy's closing thoughts: it's a set of trade-offs

RESOURCES MENTIONED

• Commonwealth Fund: Medicare Advantage Policy Primer — https://www.commonwealthfund.org/publications/explainer/2024/jan/medicare-advantage-policy-primer

• State Health Insurance Assistance Program (SHIP) — https://acl.gov/programs/connecting-people-services/state-health-insurance-assistance-program-ship

• Learn more about Gretchen's work or get in touch — https://www.commonwealthfund.org/person/gretchen-jacobson

THIS EPISODE IS BROUGHT TO YOU BY

Naborforce — connecting older adults with kind, vetted neighbors who help with rides, errands, companionship, tech help, and more. Learn more at naborforce.com

FOLLOW HOW TO AGE WELL WITH AMY KASZAK

Instagram: instagram.com/howtoagewell_podcast/

Amy on LinkedIn: linkedin.com/in/amy-kaszak-6702963/

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.