Newcastle United are brought firmly back down to earth this week as The Mag Pod picks through a bruising 4-1 defeat at Leeds United and asks whether it was simply a bad night or a warning of bigger problems ahead.

Jamie, Simon and Hutch examine a performance in which Newcastle struggled physically, created little going forward and looked increasingly vulnerable as the game unfolded. The discussion turns to the lack of experience and leadership in the side, the impact of injuries and whether the current system is giving the defence enough protection. There is also plenty of debate around individual performances, from Sven Botman and Malick Thiaw at the back to Sean Sturr’s difficult evening after being introduced early, while Newcastle’s reliance on “vertical football” comes under scrutiny.

Amid the gloom, the panel considers the wider picture and whether patience is required with a young squad and a new manager. A comparison with a famous 4-1 defeat at Elland Road during the Kenny Dalglish era provides an uncomfortable historical parallel, while attention also turns to Newcastle’s upcoming fixtures and the importance of responding quickly.

The mood changes as the lads attempt a live watch-along of the Carabao Cup draw, hoping for one of the remaining lower-league sides before discovering Newcastle’s next opponents. There is the usual mix of tension, conspiracy theories and questionable football analysis as the balls come out.

Finally, attention switches to Hull City at St James’ Park. After the disappointment at Leeds, Newcastle need a response before the international break, but with promoted Hull enjoying an encouraging start to life in the Premier League, nobody is expecting an easy afternoon.

Key Moments

00:18 – Leeds United 4-1 Newcastle United

07:38 – Blip or cause for concern?

09:36 – Newcastle’s defensive problems and missing leadership

20:14 – Problems in attack and the lack of an outlet

23:42 – The Leeds defeat and an uncomfortable historical parallel

31:23 – Carabao Cup draw watch-along

41:55 – Newcastle draw Everton away

47:03 – Looking ahead to Hull City

54:36 – Final thoughts

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.