『Episode 41: September 11, 2001』のカバーアート

Episode 41: September 11, 2001

Episode 41: September 11, 2001

無料で聴く

ポッドキャストの詳細を見る

【Amazonプライム会員限定】今ならプレミアムプランが4か月 月額99円。

10月19日まで。※適用条件あり
September 11, 2001. The South Tower, struck second, collapsed in fifty-six minutes. The North Tower stood for a hundred and two — nearly twice as long. The one structural difference everyone repeats: the North Tower carried asbestos fireproofing on its lower floors, and the South Tower carried none. Episode One of this series opened with that number and asked the question out loud: could September 11th be the one day in 4,500 years that asbestos actually saved lives? Forty episodes later, this episode answers it — with all eight volumes of the federal investigation. The answer is no.What NIST's investigators found has nothing to do with what the fireproofing was made of. The aircraft impacts physically stripped the insulation from the steel in both towers — 43 of 47 core columns in the North Tower, 39 of 47 in the South — and NIST's own finding states that the towers would likely not have collapsed had the insulation not been widely dislodged, and that its thickness and condition played no governing role. Both planes hit far above the thirty-eighth floor, where the asbestos spray had stopped in 1970. The insulation torn off the steel in both impact zones was the non-asbestos product. The asbestos wasn't even in the wound.The myth, it turns out, has an author and a date: a column published on September 14, 2001 — three days after the attacks, while the pile was still burning — arguing that asbestos could have saved lives, and blaming the doctor who spent fifty years proving what the fiber does. The episode names him, and shows how his central "fact" quietly moved twenty-six floors between his own two tellings. Then it turns to the real asbestos story of that day: the dust. What was actually in it, what the government's measurements did and didn't say, why the "safe to breathe" threshold was a school clearance criterion and not a health standard, and the mesothelioma clock — median latency at least thirty-two years — that puts the expected wave, if it comes, in the 2030s and 2040s.What This Episode CoversThe myth, dismantled by the federal record itself — The claim that asbestos fireproofing held the North Tower up does not survive the NIST investigation. The impacts stripped the fireproofing from the steel in both towers; NIST never tested the asbestos product at all; and both impact zones were dozens of floors above where the asbestos spray stopped. The timing difference traces to more severe core damage in the South Tower — ten core columns severed against six — and to how long the fires took to weaken its perimeter. Fireproofing chemistry appears nowhere in NIST's list of causes.Who actually fireproofed the towers — and who didn't — The contract record names Cafco BLAZE-SHIELD Type D, made by U.S. Mineral Products Company of Stanhope, New Jersey, and applied by Mario & DiBono Plastering. The most famous name in asbestos appears nowhere in 2,030 pages of the federal investigation. The switch off asbestos came in April 1970 — two years before New York City's ban took effect — driven by emergency restrictions, five summonses in a week, health advice from Irving Selikoff's Mount Sinai group, and a contractor's frank memo about bad public relations.The man who sold the myth — "Asbestos Could Have Saved WTC Lives," published September 14, 2001, three days after the attacks. The episode names the columnist, quotes the column, and documents how its central claim — that asbestos ran to the 64th floor — became the 38th floor in the author's own 2007 retelling, with no correction ever issued. Folklore with a byline.What the dust actually was — The best chemical analysis (Lioy et al., 2002) found settled dust that was overwhelmingly pulverized building — 98% coarse particles, cement, gypsum, glass fiber — with chrysotile asbestos at 0.8–3.0% by mass, lead, dioxins, and a pH of 9.2–11.5: caustic enough to burn an airway on its own. EPA analyzed nearly 10,000 outdoor air samples; 30 exceeded the threshold in September 2001 alone — a threshold that was a 1987 school clearance criterion, explicitly not a health-based standard. EPA's own Inspector General concluded the early "safe to breathe" statement was not supported by the data available at the time.The clock that is still running — As of the end of 2024, the program treating WTC survivors had documented six mesotheliomas among its 17,449 members, with intervals from that day of fifteen to nineteen years in the first four cases. The classic occupational median latency is at least thirty-two years — which puts September 11th's median mark in 2033. Congress has now chartered a research cohort for the youngest exposed: the schoolchildren, only now entering the window.Key Statistics56 minutes / 102 minutes — collapse times for the South and North Towers (NIST NCSTAR 1)38th floor — where sprayed asbestos fireproofing stopped in the North Tower, stated five times in the federal investigationApril 13, 1970 — New ...
adbl_web_anon_alc_button_suppression_t1
まだレビューはありません