Host Jared Norman talks with Nik Suresh, who runs Hermit Tech, an extreme programming data consultancy in Melbourne, about why Scrum fails. Nik argues Scrum spread through dishonest marketing (Sutherland's "twice the work in half the time" promise) and that its rituals amplify bad management rather than fix it, from Fibonacci story points that are really just time estimates to one-hour standups he's seen more often than the correct version. His core point is that the map is not the territory: Jira boards and status PowerPoints give executives a simulated cockpit rather than an accurate picture, and he admits he once moved cards to done without doing the work and nobody noticed. He advocates treating any deadline slip as evidence the whole estimate was wrong, paying attention to morale and sick days as the real project signals, and tells engineers stuck in dysfunctional standups to just quit before the environment warps them. His closing lesson is that dropping Scrum alone won't help, since the conditions that produced it will just produce the next silly framework unless teams honestly ask how they came to follow a process on faith.

Links:

Tossed Salads and Scrumbled Eggs

Praise The Machine Spirit

Ludicity (Nik's blog)

Hermit Tech (Nik's consultancy)

The Agile Manifesto

Scrum: The Art of Doing Twice the Work in Half the Time by Jeff Sutherland

Dead Code Podcast Links:

Mastodon

X

Jared’s Links:

Mastodon

X

twitch.tv/jardonamron

Jared’s Newsletter & Website

Episode Transcript

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.