Meet Andrew and Thom, two longtime friends revisiting The Simpsons from a whole new perspective. In this four-minute sneak peek, they introduce themselves, explain the format of Donuts on the Couch: Growing Up on Evergreen Terrace, and share what inspired them to return to Springfield—this time as dads in their forties.

Andrew and Thom officially begin their journey through The Simpsons with “Simpsons Roasting on an Open Fire,” the episode that introduced the world to the Simpson family. They share their memories of watching the show as kids, revisit the episode through the eyes of fathers in their 40s, and explain what they hope to discover while growing up all over again on Evergreen Terrace.

Bart switches aptitude tests with Martin Prince and is promptly identified as Springfield’s newest genius. Andrew and Thom revisit “Bart the Genius,” comparing what they noticed as eight-year-olds with what stands out now as middle-aged dads—from standardized testing and schoolyard social hierarchies to cursive writing, morning routines, and the hazards of scientific inaccuracy. Along the way, they explore Bart’s brief life among the gifted, Martin’s complicated role as both victim and tattletale, and the surprising warmth of Bart and Homer’s father-son bond.

Homer loses his job at the nuclear power plant and spirals into one of the darkest stories of The Simpsons’ first season—before discovering a new sense of purpose as Springfield’s unlikely safety crusader. Andrew and Thom revisit “Homer’s Odyssey,” discussing unemployment, depression, suicide, and the episode’s surprisingly sincere depiction of a man trying to feel useful again. Along the way, they consider Bart’s tattoo ambitions, the joys and hazards of school-bus field trips, changing workplace culture, rural Wisconsin bar life, and the early appearances of Otto, Blinky, Smithers, and several other future Springfield regulars.

In “Life on the Fast Lane,” Homer’s spectacularly thoughtless birthday gift sends Marge to the bowling alley—and into the path of the charmingly persistent Jacques. Andrew and Thom discuss Marge’s growing dissatisfaction, Homer’s belated realization that his marriage may be in trouble, and the surprising emotional depth of an episode told largely from Marge’s perspective. Along the way, they explore forgotten birthdays, bowling shoes, marital communication, bottled-up feelings, and one of the most meaningful forks in the road of The Simpsons’ first season.

In “There’s No Disgrace Like Home,” Homer becomes convinced that the Simpsons are Springfield’s most dysfunctional family—and decides that a little professional help might be the answer. Andrew and Thom discuss the episode’s satire of family normalcy, Homer’s shifting role within the household, and Dr. Marvin Monroe’s unconventional approach to family therapy. Along the way, they explore screen time, picky eaters, workplace culture, Itchy & Scratchy, suspiciously perfect families, and the lengths Homer will go to protect the Simpson family’s reputation.

In “Bart the General,” a confrontation with Nelson Muntz leaves Bart bruised, humiliated, and ready to declare war. Andrew and Thom discuss the code of the schoolyard, Homer’s questionable lessons in fighting dirty, and Bart’s transformation from isolated victim to pint-sized military commander. Along the way, they explore childhood bullying, the importance of grandparents, Herman’s surprisingly elaborate battle strategy, and how the episode balances cartoon warfare with a thoughtful message about the realities of violence.

In “Moaning Lisa,” Lisa finds herself overwhelmed by a sadness she cannot explain—and surrounded by adults who do not quite know how to help. Andrew and Thom discuss the episode’s remarkably thoughtful portrayal of childhood depression, Homer’s well-intentioned but misguided attempts at parenting, and Marge’s eventual realization that Lisa needs understanding rather than encouragement to simply smile. Along the way, they explore sibling rivalry, vintage video games, jazz as emotional expression, and the importance of giving children space to feel heard.