Episode 78 starts with absolute NFL whiplash.

John opens the show reacting to the Jaguars and Patriots suddenly looking like legitimate AFC contenders, the Lions somehow scoring two game-winning touchdowns and still losing, and a brutal playoff exit thanks to Joe Burrow, Chris Olave, and Kenny Gainwell all choosing the same week to explode. The guys also take a look at the Jets’ season-long receiving leaders.

From there, it’s time for This Just In with Justin, as the injury carousel spins out of control. Lamar Jackson, Josh Allen, Jordan Love, Gardner Minshew, Quinshon Judkins, George Kittle, and more headline a week that leaves fantasy managers scrambling for answers — and depth charts in shambles.

That leads directly into Catch Some Waives, where the Comanagers break down their favorite waiver wire targets at every position. From streaming quarterbacks and running back injury pivots to sneaky wide receiver volume plays, tight end chaos, and defensive streamers, this episode is all about surviving the week and staying alive in fantasy leagues that don’t care about your plans.

If you’re tilting, checking injury reports every five minutes, or convincing yourself that “this waiver add could save my season,” Episode 78 is for you.

Text a question or just say hi!

Support the show

Episode 77 is all about putting instincts to the test — and watching them fail in real time.

The Comanagers dive straight into Keep, Trade, Cut, debating quarterbacks, running backs, wide receivers, and tight ends. From elite names like Lamar Jackson, Jalen Hurts, Bijan Robinson, Justin Jefferson, and Brock Bowers to polarizing depth plays and prospects, every decision sparks disagreement and second-guessing.

Next up is Blind Resume, where reputations are thrown out the window, and stats do the talking. The guys rank rushing efficiency among star quarterbacks, struggle to correctly order rookie running backs by production, and trip over a deceptively tricky wide receiver question involving “backup” pass catchers who definitely don’t feel like backups.

The episode wraps with rookie tight ends, where even educated guesses miss the mark — proving once again that fantasy football is humbling, chaotic, and the reason we keep coming back every week.

If you like debates, blind data challenges, and watching two confident managers slowly realize they might be wrong, Episode 77 delivers.

Text a question or just say hi!

Support the show

Episode 76 kicks off on a high note as the Comanagers take a moment to appreciate what this pod has become: two friends talking football, having fun, and realizing people are actually listening. From there, it’s straight back to business.

This week’s episode centers on the Fantasy Feast + Famine Week Preview, starting with another chapter of the Comanagers Clash. Justin continues his hot streak, securing a 6–3 victory by absolutely sweeping the Famine picks, while John is left searching for answers — and moral victories.

The guys break down who feasted, who starved, and why the Clash continues to tilt in Justin’s favor. Then it’s time to Choose Your Fighter, as John and Justin lock in their picks for the best plays among the week’s easiest matchups across quarterbacks, running backs, wide receivers, tight ends, and defenses.

Finally, the mood shifts with Fantasy Famine, where the siren rings and the takes get loud. From betting against the Raiders (which somehow always works) to calling out risky stars and brutal matchups, the Comanagers lay out who they think is most likely to sink lineups this week.

Whether you’re setting a playoff lineup or just enjoying the ride, Episode 76 delivers strategy, rivalry, and the kind of banter that only comes from doing this for the love of the game.

Text a question or just say hi!

Support the show

Episode 75 opens with Producer Dakota stepping in early — literally handing Justin a note reminding him to be nice. Things somehow only escalate from there.

This week is all about Winners and Sinners, and the fantasy scoreboard was absolutely unhinged. Trevor Lawrence headlines the Week Winners after a six-TD eruption, prompting John to attempt — and immediately abandon — a “Lawrence of Arabia” joke. Bo Nix, Kirk Cousins (inevitably vs. Tampa Bay), Brock Purdy, and Jared Goff round out a quarterback slate that delivered fireworks across the league.

At running back, James Cook, Bijan Robinson, and TreVeyon Henderson powered fantasy lineups, while Travis Etienne exploded with three receiving touchdowns. The wide receiver position was just as wild, with Amon-Ra St. Brown, Puka Nacua, Jameson Williams, and Nico Collins all delivering monster weeks.

Tight end might have been the most absurd position of all. Kyle Pitts finally detonated, Trey McBride continued his record-setting pace, and even depth plays like Colby Parkinson found the end zone twice.

Of course, not everyone survived the week. The Sinners list is long and painful, featuring big names, busted matchups, and one unexpected detour into a spontaneous Keep / Trade / Cut debate based entirely on Kareem Hunt’s dread pigtails.

If you’re still alive in the fantasy playoffs — or just here to laugh through the pain — Episode 75 has you covered.

Text a question or just say hi!

Support the show

The fantasy playoffs wait for no one — and in Episode 74, the margins were brutal.

We open with a full breakdown of Justin’s playoff collapse, a perfect storm of underperformers headlined by Isaiah Likely and capped off by running headfirst into Trevor Lawrence’s nuclear performance. On the other side of the bracket, John looks ahead to a tough matchup against friend-of-the-show Dave, who’s rolling out James Cook and Amon-Ra St. Brown.

The week itself was chaos. Grandpa Philip Rivers nearly completed a storybook comeback against Seattle before the Seahawks ripped it away at the buzzer. We saw historic performances from Kyle Pitts and Trevor Lawrence, pregame lineup drama with Rome Odunze ruled out minutes before kickoff, and yet another brutal injury slate that included three torn ACLs.

From there, we roll into This Just In with Justin, covering a shocking list of injuries and news — including Patrick Mahomes suffering a torn ACL, Jayden Daniels being shut down for the season, and key skill players dropping left and right as fantasy managers scramble for answers.

We wrap things up with Catch Some Waives, spotlighting late-season league winners and desperation plays at every position — from CJ Stroud and JJ McCarthy at QB, to emerging RBs like Jawhar Jordan and Jacory Croskey-Merritt, plus sneaky WR and TE targets that could decide championship week.

If your season ended in heartbreak — or you’re still fighting for a title — this one’s for you.

Text a question or just say hi!

Listen on: Apple Podcasts Spotify

Support the show

Monday Night Football is wrapping up as we hit record, and things are trending very differently for your Comanagers. John is cruising toward the 1-seed and a first-round bye, while Justin… well, Justin is fighting for his fantasy life. Emotions are high, confidence is… uneven.

We kick things off with a spicy round of Keep, Trade, Cut, including a special “Retirement Home Edition” featuring Philip Rivers, Tom Brady, and Derek Carr — and yes, we both cut Rivers. From there, we dive into the real decisions: Jayden vs. Herbert vs. Flacco, Corum vs. Neal vs. Monty, Michael Wilson vs. Flournoy vs. Jeudy, and a tight end showdown featuring Fannin, Pitts, and Kincaid.

Then it’s time for Blind Resume, where both hosts try to out-guess each other on fantasy production without the names.
• Justin nails the QB category by identifying Jameis Winston as the leader in points per game.
• John fires back by correctly calling CMC as the RB with the fewest rushing TDs.
• Justin stays hot by picking Rashee Rice in the WR category.
• John stumbles at the finish line, missing the TE question when Warren edges Fannin by a single catch.

Fun, fast, competitive — and maybe slightly emotional — Episode 73 brings all the fantasy heat heading into playoff time.

Text a question or just say hi!

Support the show

We’re recording during one of the wildest Monday Night Football games in recent memory — and Jalen Hurts is committing turnovers like he’s speed-running a bad Madden challenge. A -4 point play, five turnovers in an eleven-play span, and the first six-turnover first half since 1978. It’s chaos, it’s comedy, and it’s absolutely impacting fantasy leagues everywhere.

This episode, we dive into our Week Preview: Fantasy Feast + Famine, breaking down the best and worst matchups heading into the weekend. We recap the latest Comanagers Clash, where Justin steals another tight win (5–4) thanks to strong performances from Gibbs, Ceedee, and Knox. John put up a fight behind Josh Allen, and Denver DST — but came up just short.

Then we turn the page and make our Feast Picks, selecting the players primed to explode against soft matchups — Lamar, Shedeur, Derrick Henry, TreVeyon, Puka, JSN, Andrews, and more.

We follow it with the Famine Picks, where we highlight the players we expect to struggle in brutal matchups — from Brissett to Drake Maye, Kyren, Breece, Pickens, Michael Wilson, McBride, and several DSTs heading into buzzsaws.

A chaotic MNF, a tight Clash, bold projections, and plenty of fantasy drama lined up for the week ahead — buckle up, Comanagers.

Text a question or just say hi!

Support the show

The fantasy playoffs are heating up, but the NFL injury carousel keeps spinning — and this week it might have cracked open the door for one of the craziest storylines imaginable: Philip Rivers possibly stepping in for Riley Leonard, who’s now week-to-week with a strained knee ligament. Yes, the same Philip Rivers whose oldest child is literally the same age as the quarterback he may replace. You can’t make this stuff up.

This week, we break down all the Winners and Sinners from an absolutely chaotic slate of games.
We highlight massive boom weeks from Josh Allen, Shedeur Sanders, and Joe Burrow… plus the touchdown barrage from Jahmyr Gibbs, Tony Pollard, Blake Corum, Puka Nacua, Michael Wilson, JSN, and a handful of tight ends who came out of nowhere.

And of course, we cover the other side: a brutal list of fantasy Sinners that includes some of the biggest names in football — Mahomes, Bijan, Davante, Jefferson, Deebo, Andrews, Breece, and more.

From breakout performances to devastating flops, Episode 71 is a full-on fantasy rollercoaster. Let’s dive in.

Text a question or just say hi!

Support the show