The charge? Making winning football look painfully boring. The defendant? BYU offensive coordinator Aaron Roderick. The jury? You.

After BYU’s win over TCU, Nate brings the case against A-Rod’s conservative play calling, while Josh argues that the results—and his work with Bear Bachmeier—deserve more credit. Is he holding the offense back, or doing exactly what it takes to win?

Plus: Nate makes the case for a home playoff game at LaVell Edwards Stadium OVER a first-round bye, we test our BYU jersey-number knowledge, revisit a Loyal Cougars history fumble, and attempt a BYU Mind Meld with wildly mixed results.

We wrap up with Iowa State score predictions and an update on our season-long prediction contest.

Drop your verdict in the comments:
⚖️ Is A-Rod guilty or not guilty?
🏟️ Home playoff game or first-round bye?
🏈 What’s your BYU–Iowa State score prediction?

Subscribe to The Brutally Honest BYU Pod for brotherly disagreements, BYU football talk, and occasional evidence that we know way too much about this team.

Go Cougs!

#BYUFootball #BYU #GoCougs #AaronRoderick #BYUCougars #CollegeFootball #Big12Football #BrutallyHonestBYUPod

Apparently, we’re bozos, tool bags, cornballs—and the two biggest tools on YouTube. We respond to the chaos in last week’s comment section and clarify what we actually meant by “defund the band.”

Then we get into BYU’s 28–17 win over Arizona:

• Was Bear Bachmeier’s throw to Legend Glasker the best BYU deep ball since Zach Wilson?
• How much did the slippery field hurt the Cougars?
• Is Isaiah Glasker looking slower this season?
• Were BYU’s defensive play calls actually bad?
• Are the wide receivers outperforming the tight ends?
• Should molded cleats be outlawed at LaVell Edwards Stadium?

We also debut “Start, Bench, Cut,” update the season-long score prediction standings, recognize some unsung heroes, and preview BYU’s road matchup with Colorado State—including the Rams’ biggest threats, BYU’s growing injury concerns, and our final score predictions.

Nate’s prediction: BYU 41, Colorado State 13
Josh’s prediction: BYU 45, Colorado State 16

Let us know your prediction in the comments!

#BYUFootball #BYUSports #GoCougs #Big12Football #BYUCougars

Utah fans came after Drake Toll—and Josh has had enough.

We open this week’s episode by going scorched earth on Utah’s fan base, its Big 12 entrance, and the rivalry it supposedly doesn’t care about.

Then we turn the brutally honest treatment toward our own side and explain why it may be time to DEFUND the BYU marching band.

We also break down what stood out against Utah Tech, put Nate’s ridiculous BYU quarterback knowledge to the test, introduce our season-long score prediction competition, and preview BYU’s matchup with Arizona.

Is Utah really the worst fan base in college football? Does the Cougar Marching Band improve or hurt the atmosphere at LaVell Edwards Stadium? And will BYU handle Arizona comfortably—or are we getting ahead of ourselves?

Let us know where we’re right, where we’re wrong, and what score you’re predicting this week.

Amen, Max.

Go Cougs.

#BYUFootball #GoCougs #Big12Football

Nate and Josh debate the best way to watch a BYU Football game, give their hot (possibly old man) takes on Cougar uniforms, and give their brutally honest predictions for the tilt against outmatched Utah Tech.

Calling out "Coach Speak," the best and worst moments of our BYU fanhood, and under-the-radar guys to watch out for this season.

Josh and Nate discuss how good the 2026 Football Team has the potential to be, draft their starting 5 BYU Talking Heads, and beg Aaron Roderick to throw the ball to open the season.